| Index | 2 reviews in total |
5 out of 7 people found the following review useful:
Not bad, but disappointing., 2 December 2001
![]()
Author:
somemoviesilike (j@tom-rathbone.demon.co.uk) from Farnham, England
After having read the book by Michelle Magorian, which is engaging and of
interest, as all of her books are, this make was very disappointing.
Nothing
seemed to fit well in terms of the plot, it was unfocused, and major
storylines had been left out as the book progressed. There was very good
acting, especially from Stephanie Cole, Sarah Lancashire, and newcomer
Jessica Fox, but it is by no means up to scratch on Goodnight Mr. Tom. That
was much better directed and was a far more convincing adaptation. For all
its faults however, it kept me going to the end, and was enjoyable.
Wouldn't
watch it again, though I would like to see the earlier version to
compare.
6 out of 10 (That's generous).
1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:
Interesting, but flawed, 5 August 2005
![]()
Author:
ladyillana from United States
*** This review may contain spoilers ***
This was a great TV movie, but it really missed the point of the book. Rusty, in the book, is not able to accept the changes in her mother that occur over the war period, just as her mother cannot accept the changes in Rusty until the end of the book. The Disney movie captured this well even if it did gloss over the more brutal aspects of her parents' relationship. This movie seemed more a vehicle for Sarah Lancaster and a fleshing out of Peggy's character than the mother and daughter relationship that is central to the book. It also really doesn't spend much time on Rusty's own difficulties fitting in to post-war Britain after being a sea-vacuee to America for five years. Jessica Fox did a marvelous job with what she was given as did the rest of the cast, and it made a good movie, but the 1996 Disney movie is truer to the heart of the novel, and it's really ashame it's out of print so most viewers will not be able to compare them.
| Plot summary | Ratings | Plot keywords |
| Main details | Your user reviews | Your vote history |