"Maigret" Maigret et la vieille dame (TV Episode 1994) Poster

(TV Series)

(1994)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
"Why did she drink from your glass?"
garywhalen8 September 2023
Maigret is asked to investigate a death in a Normandy village. A maid has died in the home of the widow Besson. Poisoning. And that poisoning appears to have been intended for the widow and not the maid. To celebrate the Madame Besson's birthday her family (daughter and step-sons) had gathered at the house earlier on the day of the maid's death. Sounds like the opening of an Agatha Christie mystery, but Simenon, author of the Maigret mysteries, does what he does so well: He delves into the past, describes the nuances of the places, and examines not just the suspects but also those on the periphery. He provides an atmosphere of sights, sounds, and smells. In this episode the filmmakers deliver a perfect story capturing the cadence, the very feel of the novel.

The film follows the novel quite closely with only minor and unimportant deviations. The characters' relations to each other and their feelings toward each other are well scripted and acted. The pacing is excellent, especially considering that this story (as with many Maigret mysteries) is driven by dialogue. Dialogue can get boring, but that doesn't happen here because of the superb casting and the change of locations around this village. (Kudos to Odette Laure who plays the widow in what is a difficult role.)

As in the novel Maigret works outside in, talking to people about the widow and her family. Then he moves from one family member to another until the real story begins to reveal itself and the fake one collapses. I've read the book twice and seen this episode three times and consider it one of the best of the series.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Maigret finds a poisoner - buy VERY slowly!
Tony-Holmes16 June 2023
Saw this on Talking Pictures channel (UK TV - old films & TV shows). It was broadly faithful to the book, and indeed so was the Rupert Davies version (BBC - early 60s), which by coincidence was on the same channel recently, a further rerun of that series.

This story takes a while to unravel, in this version, the Davies story told the same plot in half the time!

Cremer though plodded slowly about, making witnesses uncomfortable, and using little tricks to discover a few secrets they'd like to hide. HOWEVER, it seemed quite unbelievable that he'd almost reached the end of the show before talking to the victim's family???

The victim was a maid, working for an old lady who was part of a formerly rich family, the maid had been poisoned, on a night when the family had gathered for a birthday, but was she the intended victim?

This version introduced an extra character, a gardener, who said very little to anyone (so didn't help the story much?!), and had also featured a clumsy seduction attempt on Maigret, which took quite some time to play out, and added nothing to the plot.

The acting is very good in this French series, and I can bear the subtitles, but frankly the stories are almost all padded out to a tiresome degree, and could do with being half an hour shorter (not almost 2 hours, which just drags).
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed