A Young Man's Fancy (1952)A visiting young man prefers the household electrical appliances over the teenage daughter! Director:Donald H. BrownWriter:Frank Murray |
|
| 0Share... |
A Young Man's Fancy (1952)A visiting young man prefers the household electrical appliances over the teenage daughter! Director:Donald H. BrownWriter:Frank Murray |
|
| 0Share... |
| Cast overview: | |||
|
|
Bonnie Baken | ... |
Judy Adams
|
|
|
Jean Hayworth | ... |
Mrs. Adams
|
|
|
Robert Casey | ... |
Alexander Phipps
|
|
|
Hazen Gifford | ... |
Bob Adams
|
|
|
Paul Kirk Giles | ... |
Mr. Harry Adams
|
| Marlene Cameron | ... |
Sally Porter
|
|
A visiting young man prefers the household electrical appliances over the teenage daughter!
"Young Man's Fancy" is getting slammed by the other reviewers, and unjustly it seems to me, for being unrealistic and poorly acted. Judgment over the acting is a matter of taste I suppose; so all I can say is that the performances aren't really all that different than anything else I've seen in the average range from that time period. They are generally credible, given the situation as it has been created by its authors, if a bit over the top. And as for the situation itself being "preposterous" as one reviewer put it, let's look at that. A young girl is attracted to a visiting young man but is having trouble catching his attention. In order to finally break through she resorts to feigning interest in one of the young man's hobbies. Is such a scenario really so outlandish? The only thing about that I found difficult to accept is the constant references to the miracle of electric appliances. That might have been the way people would have reacted twenty years earlier, but did anyone in America really need to be convinced of the value of an electric dishwasher or range in 1952? Yes, I know MST3K had a field day with this short; but if you're looking for outlandish propositions, try another short they skewered, "Out of This World", where a demon and an angel fight for the soul of a bread delivery man. Now that's preposterous, in spades!