After an argument with her sister, Melanie is distraught to hear Lisa wish she didn't exist. Upset, Melanie runs away on her pony and Lisa must venture out with Prancer in order to find her and make things right.
Veronica continues to ignore Garnet. In an effort to teach her a lesson The Saddle Club switch Garnet with Mrs. Marsten's mare Nomad. The Saddle Club's plan puts Veronica and Nomad in danger when Max changes Veronica's private lesson from dressage to jumping. Max suspends The Saddle Club from Pine Hollow for a week and tells Veronica to take care of Garnet.