This simple film celebrates American diversity and immigration by showing the evils of racism and persecuting minorities. The film plot outlines how a society gradually accepts ostracizing "outsiders" as told by a Hungarian who witnessed this in the lead-up to World War II. The film speaks to us now in 2017 just as urgently as it did in 1943 & when it was re-released in 1946. Should be required viewing for middle and high school students. Propaganda with heart & soul.
8 Reviews
Still very powerful today
planktonrules16 August 2017
Lloyd Nolan narrates this short film and a few famous Hollywood actors (Paul Lukas and Felix Bressart) appeared in it. It was made for the war department and is a film anticipating the sort of racist crap that the Nazis were peddling being spread in America after the war.
The film consists of some ordinary boob listening to a speech by a Neo- Nazi type and agreeing with almost all of it. However, when the hate- filled diatribe also attacks him, indirectly, he's not so sure of the America first/non-whites suck message. Then an immigrant observing the speech (Lukas) talks about the many, many ways the speech is abhorrent to any decent American and why. While it could have come off as preachy and silly, the short film was handled well and is a lovely appeal for tolerance and decency.
The film consists of some ordinary boob listening to a speech by a Neo- Nazi type and agreeing with almost all of it. However, when the hate- filled diatribe also attacks him, indirectly, he's not so sure of the America first/non-whites suck message. Then an immigrant observing the speech (Lukas) talks about the many, many ways the speech is abhorrent to any decent American and why. While it could have come off as preachy and silly, the short film was handled well and is a lovely appeal for tolerance and decency.
"Ounce Of Prevention.........." (you know the rest)
redryan647 July 2017
WE HAVE ONLY recently became aware of this relic from the 1940's & bit of World War II American propaganda. As with so many other titles, we sort of accidentally bumped into it on Youtube.com. Being that the running time was listed at 17 minutes and change, we immediately watched it.
IN MUCH THE same manner as so many other films produced by the United States War effort, it is of surprisingly good, high quality production value, acting and effectiveness. This short manages to reach the subject and bring it in a highly effective manner to us, the viewing audience. And that message is one that is as pertinent to today's America and the whole, cockeyed World.
THE VERY FABRIC is the fact that we, as a people have a more than a casual and abrupt with the sort of discriminations. Although we may be aware and therefore, more or less immune from being taken over by such prejudices. But there is still danger of transferring at least some of these irrational dislike to the area of judging people not by race, creed, color or nationality; but by socio-economic status, income or occupation.
WHILE IT SURELY may be true that at least some of us have managed to recognize and avoid such discriminating when it comes to nationality, ethnicity and race-the same person may be inundated with petty peeves concerning anything that is found in the brotherhood of man.
THE VERY STRAIGHT forward story gets right to the point. There are indeed those who are less than honest with us. They may be sneak thieves, stick-up men or grifters. They are not by any means apt to be looking out for their fellow man, unless of course they can scam him.
THE LITTLE FILM manages to assemble the greatest little cast of players that one could imagine. Our cast includes: Paul Lukas, Chick Chandler, George Chandler, George E. Stone, Richard Lane (hey, it's Inspector Faraday!)and a number of actors that might be familiar to you by their names, but not by name.
ALTHOUGH IT APPEARS that many of our colleagues have panned this little movie, we must register our complaint to take the opposite position. The atrocities that plagued the World, and especially Europe, did not come about over night. It all started small and grew, unchecked.
AS A REMEDY for such happenings, may we suggest application of just a couple of old adages:
Do Unto Others As you Would Have Them Do Unto You.
Judge Not Lest You Will Be Judged.
IN MUCH THE same manner as so many other films produced by the United States War effort, it is of surprisingly good, high quality production value, acting and effectiveness. This short manages to reach the subject and bring it in a highly effective manner to us, the viewing audience. And that message is one that is as pertinent to today's America and the whole, cockeyed World.
THE VERY FABRIC is the fact that we, as a people have a more than a casual and abrupt with the sort of discriminations. Although we may be aware and therefore, more or less immune from being taken over by such prejudices. But there is still danger of transferring at least some of these irrational dislike to the area of judging people not by race, creed, color or nationality; but by socio-economic status, income or occupation.
WHILE IT SURELY may be true that at least some of us have managed to recognize and avoid such discriminating when it comes to nationality, ethnicity and race-the same person may be inundated with petty peeves concerning anything that is found in the brotherhood of man.
THE VERY STRAIGHT forward story gets right to the point. There are indeed those who are less than honest with us. They may be sneak thieves, stick-up men or grifters. They are not by any means apt to be looking out for their fellow man, unless of course they can scam him.
THE LITTLE FILM manages to assemble the greatest little cast of players that one could imagine. Our cast includes: Paul Lukas, Chick Chandler, George Chandler, George E. Stone, Richard Lane (hey, it's Inspector Faraday!)and a number of actors that might be familiar to you by their names, but not by name.
ALTHOUGH IT APPEARS that many of our colleagues have panned this little movie, we must register our complaint to take the opposite position. The atrocities that plagued the World, and especially Europe, did not come about over night. It all started small and grew, unchecked.
AS A REMEDY for such happenings, may we suggest application of just a couple of old adages:
Do Unto Others As you Would Have Them Do Unto You.
Judge Not Lest You Will Be Judged.
common sense is not common even today
coach-angela25 June 2011
This spells it out, the case against racism and xenophobia. This short film is an excellent reminder, in clear language, about how we are all minorities. America is a melting pot, and we need reminded about that sometimes. Normally, I'm not a huge fan of old films, but this one drew me in with its clear message of tolerance. If we want others to be tolerant of us, we must be tolerant of them. I don't think the message is condescending, but it IS simple. It is so simple that some might feel a little put off by the message at the end. Yes, we are all minorities, even us white western European mutts that are lots and lots of generations Americans.
A case study in American pragmatism
mavaddat14 August 2017
The short film "Don't Be a Sucker!" (17 min) is a tidy argument against fascist racism and it is an eye-opening study in philosophical pragmatism. I was surprised to learn that the US War Department was so explicitly anti-racism in 1943 even before the end of the second world war.
As The Title
boblipton12 November 2019
The copy of the short subject I just looked at was not the original version released by Warner Brothers in 1943. It was a revised version issued by the War Office in 1947, which mentioned the Normandy Invasion.
It's a lovingly produced version, set up by Lloyd Nolan, then largely narrated by Paul Lukas, with a one-minute lecture by Felix Bressart on the nonsense of the idea of the Master Race -- before he is dragged off by the Nazis. If you had asked me ten years ago about this movie, I would have dismissed it as full of commonplace truths that we, as a nation, had evolved past. More recent events, including the rise of the alt-right, anti-Black sentiment, and other doctrines of hate, make it, unhappily, timely again.
I disagree with the movie's thesis, that people are not naturally prejudiced. We all grow up in our own little bits of society, dealing with people who look and think and feel like us. People who are not like us require thought and work and we don't always get them right, and when that happens, the results may be bad. Therefore, we approach strangers with caution.
Yet it is those very differences that make other people valuable to us. If we all had the same skills and attitudes, what need would we have for each other? If every man is a farmer, who will make his tools, his clothes, his home? We are stronger because of our diversity.
It's a lovingly produced version, set up by Lloyd Nolan, then largely narrated by Paul Lukas, with a one-minute lecture by Felix Bressart on the nonsense of the idea of the Master Race -- before he is dragged off by the Nazis. If you had asked me ten years ago about this movie, I would have dismissed it as full of commonplace truths that we, as a nation, had evolved past. More recent events, including the rise of the alt-right, anti-Black sentiment, and other doctrines of hate, make it, unhappily, timely again.
I disagree with the movie's thesis, that people are not naturally prejudiced. We all grow up in our own little bits of society, dealing with people who look and think and feel like us. People who are not like us require thought and work and we don't always get them right, and when that happens, the results may be bad. Therefore, we approach strangers with caution.
Yet it is those very differences that make other people valuable to us. If we all had the same skills and attitudes, what need would we have for each other? If every man is a farmer, who will make his tools, his clothes, his home? We are stronger because of our diversity.
Interesting for its time, irrelevant for today's politics
Horst_In_Translation21 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
"Don't Be a Sucker" is a 17-minute black-and-white short film from the 1940s (there are contradictory statements if it's from 1943 or 1947), but it sure was made during the days of WWII and it was the American's attempt to avoid a spreading of Nazi politics in their own country as many people were obviously impressed by Hitler's successes in Europe. So yes this is a propaganda movie, but of course not just Germans did these. Actually, Americans made a lot more, which is often forgotten because they were eventually proved right. The story-telling in here is nothing special really, the parts about the nationalist idea as a whole as well as the tragic fates of individual Nazis. This film is really more interesting for its overall context, namely the way Americans saw the global political climate back then. And from that perspective, I recommend it. But I do not recommend it for the ways in which some liberals desperately try to make a connection between this one and Trump's presidency. Maybe someone needs to tell them that they should be thankful that they are not ruled by a nationalist president and even more that we are not living in times of World War III and that there is no Nazi Germany these days. Don't let them fool you. If anything they are the big fakes and phonies this film criticizes. This is nothing the film ever intended or was made for. But with what it was made for, it is a success. No surprise though as the director was an Emmy winner and there even is an Oscar winner in the cast. Go see it.
Mike and the Professor
kapelusznik1815 August 2017
Somewhat confusing Hollywood made propaganda film-with the help of the US Defense Department-about the danger and horrors of an United States takeover by an un-named fascist group using patriotism as its way to split the population apart and against each other in order to achieve its ignoble gains. We get to see this loud mouth giving a speech on a soapbox about how foreigners and minorities are taking over the country and turning it into, even though he doesn't mention it, a third world backwater 12th century economy.
There's Mike-young healthy and with a job-swallowing every word that this big mouth utters until this wise old professor or recent Hungarian immigrant enlighten him about what's really going on behind the scenes. Being a Freemason-Like most if not all of the Founding Fathers including George Washington- Mike who at first thought he was an all American realizes that he himself,in being a Freemason,is also on the chopping block if big mouth-played by Richard Lane-ends up getting his way. We get to see in a number of flashbacks in how the Nazis took over Germany some 15 years ago using the same tactics that this fire brand speaker is using now. The way the film plays out you don't quite know if this takes place-it was made in 1943 and re-released with new scenes added in 1947-since you can't figure out if WWII was over or still in progress.
Using a number of outtakes of old WWII movies the wise old professor makes his point to the very confused and not really with it, in not having any sense of modern history, Mike what the speaker is all about. And in the end he finally sees the light in tearing up a what looked like literature about how great it would be if we, the American people, would follow the line of BS what the speaker tells us to do.
Released during or right after the end of WWII this 20 some minute so-called educational short made it look as if the US population were asleep or unconscious in what happened over the last four years when the USA was in a life and death struggle with Nazi Germany, Italy and Japan Germany's allies in the war were never mentioned once, that cost the lives of over 400,000 US servicemen. And even worse it had the professor who just became a naturalized American citizen as the only person in the film who had any idea of what Nazi Germany and the jerk, who you would have expected to be chased off the stage and forced to run for his life, giving the speech really stood for.
There's Mike-young healthy and with a job-swallowing every word that this big mouth utters until this wise old professor or recent Hungarian immigrant enlighten him about what's really going on behind the scenes. Being a Freemason-Like most if not all of the Founding Fathers including George Washington- Mike who at first thought he was an all American realizes that he himself,in being a Freemason,is also on the chopping block if big mouth-played by Richard Lane-ends up getting his way. We get to see in a number of flashbacks in how the Nazis took over Germany some 15 years ago using the same tactics that this fire brand speaker is using now. The way the film plays out you don't quite know if this takes place-it was made in 1943 and re-released with new scenes added in 1947-since you can't figure out if WWII was over or still in progress.
Using a number of outtakes of old WWII movies the wise old professor makes his point to the very confused and not really with it, in not having any sense of modern history, Mike what the speaker is all about. And in the end he finally sees the light in tearing up a what looked like literature about how great it would be if we, the American people, would follow the line of BS what the speaker tells us to do.
Released during or right after the end of WWII this 20 some minute so-called educational short made it look as if the US population were asleep or unconscious in what happened over the last four years when the USA was in a life and death struggle with Nazi Germany, Italy and Japan Germany's allies in the war were never mentioned once, that cost the lives of over 400,000 US servicemen. And even worse it had the professor who just became a naturalized American citizen as the only person in the film who had any idea of what Nazi Germany and the jerk, who you would have expected to be chased off the stage and forced to run for his life, giving the speech really stood for.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
