IMDb > The Girl with the Red Scarf (1978) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
The Girl with the Red Scarf More at IMDbPro »Selvi boylum, al yazmalim (original title)

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 7 reviews in total 

45 out of 51 people found the following review useful:
A love story between a truck driver and a village girl., 27 November 2003
10/10
Author: maysteng from Canada

Without doubt, one of the most beautiful Turkish movies ever. I have seen this movie on television a while ago and I dont remember the whole details clearly. But I definitely remember bursting into tears many times during the movie. A legendary movie indeed!

Was the above review useful to you?

27 out of 33 people found the following review useful:
Further than a milestone for Turkish cinema history, 19 December 2005
10/10
Author: Aytaç Demir from Turkey

"Selvi Boylum Al Yazmalim" is further than a milestone for Turkish cinema history and it takes a place among the most impressive and best films in Turkish cinema history as well. The film leaves a dramatic effect and many questions behind after leaving the theater. The story is based on "Cengiz Aytmatov"s novel named in Turkish "Yol Arkadasi" and screened by the direction of "Atif Yilmaz". In my opinion, the film has an allegoric exposition in which love and exertion usually clash each other though, the power of the exertion becomes superior at the end, is analogous with the spirit of communism. Meanwhile, the book mentioned above, also won the 1963 Lenin award. Audience can find great number of details about the praising of the strive. Performance of the players also seem excellent in this movie. Woman character; Asya; Turkan Soray, stuck in the middle of two men. On the one side her love and father of child, Ilyas; Kadir Inanir, whereas on the other side is desperately but constantly struggling man Cemsit; Ahmet Mekik. She is uncertain about where to go, whom to choose; love or exertion ?

Was the above review useful to you?

20 out of 23 people found the following review useful:
"love or struggle", 20 March 2006
10/10
Author: cuhadar_e from Turkey

This movie is an adaption of famous Kirghiz writer Cengiz Aytmatov's novel.The unforgettable moment in the movie is a dialogue: "What is love? Love is struggle, love is goodness, love is amity". The main theme in the movie is "love needs struggle". It is a turning point in Turkish cinema and a sheer gem confirmed by many rewards at home and abroad; second best movie in 15th. Antalya Altin Portakal Film Festival, Best Director, Tashkent Film Festival best actress (Turkan Soray). The Soundtrack of the movie is praised as the best soundtrack in Turkey. It was composed by "Cahit Berkay" from the band Mogollar. Especially, the song "selvi boylum al yazmalim" is still unforgettable and considered as one of the most contemporary folk song in Turkey. In order to understand Turkish culture, humanity, sensitiveness and rural life style, "selvi boylum al yazmalim" is the best movie to give a chance. It is an universal epic and the question of "love" through Anotolian point of view...

Was the above review useful to you?

21 out of 28 people found the following review useful:
A breathless story about love and faith!..., 24 February 2003
9/10
Author: yalnizkartal from Turkey



This is a story about love and faith. The author discusses the two comparable concepts based on the beautiful novel of Aytmatov.

One can say many things about the technical handling of the film. But besides, the story flows slightly and fetches the viewers eyes till the end. Questions appear on mind; What love means? What does faith mean? Can love keep a couple together? Did you ever fall in love? OK, then answer this; did you ever TRY?!?... A woman with a baby stands between a one who loved too much, and another who did try his best.

Sometimes life do not allow you to choose. It forces you through its own stream.

Kadir Inanir and Turkan Soray starred in many films together. This film is one of their best few. Ahmet Mekin was shining, as well. You'll love the movie, if you are one of those who likes stories which sparkle questions on one's mind... And a little warning; watch out for your tears...

Was the above review useful to you?

28 out of 52 people found the following review useful:
a review by Feride Sema Koseli (istanbul bilgi university), 31 May 2002
9/10
Author: Adam J. Simpson (tuscarara@hotmail.com) from istanbul, turkey

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

This is my favorite Turkish film. it was made in the 1970s, and the stars of the film are Turkan Saray and Kadir inanir. it's a drama, and it's about love.

i want to talk about the story because if you don't know the story you can't understand the message at the end of the film. Kadir comes from istanbul to Asya's (Turkan) village, and they love each other. Then, they get married and have a baby, whose name is Samet. By the way, Kadir is a lorry driver and always goes to other cities. One day, he goes and doesn't come to his home again. Asya gets so upset and escapes from the village. She meets another man, ilyas, he is interested in her and her son. They start to live together. One day, ilyas finds a man. it is Kadir and he has had an accident. They treat him. Asya is very surprised because she still loves him. At the end of the film, Kadir wants her to come with him. However, she says 'Love is a labor, ilyas looked after my child. Samet calls him father. He is very nice to us. You cheated me. i can't come with you.' She goes home with ilyas and Samet but she still loves him.

i love this film because of the message at the end of the film. i think that it's important to every culture in the World because love is an international feeling. This is a Turkish language film, and it is my favorite film because love is explained very well.

'Selvi Boylum' means 'He is very tall like a tree' and 'Al yazmalim' means 'my wife with the red scarf'.

Was the above review useful to you?

May be the best romance movie ever, 21 April 2012
10/10
Author: srbakir from Turkey

If you think, "Doctor Zhivago" or "Gone With the Wind" is the best romance&drama ever, you have to think again. And this time, before you decide, watch "Alyazmalim".

In this world, you can't be sure of anything. Except a few masterpieces:) And as you may guess, "Alyazmalim" is one of them. So, you can higher your expectations of the movie.

In the modern society, "love" is something common. Everyday people drink coffee, eat pizza, work and love. Yeah, these days love is only a consumption item. You love, spend some time together and then break up. Then you find someone else and love again. Simple huh? I don't believe that, eastern love is more precious, naive and pure than the western. I believe, being "local", living a simple and slower life, makes you a deeper person. And then, may be, you can find out the real meaning of love. So, i look for the love, away from the city.

"Alyazmalim" teaches and makes you remember "real love". It's not related to human flesh. No! It would be real shallow explanation. Love is only about "two souls". It's true that, you "may" need physical beauty at first. But, it's only like a key, opening a door. The door of a magnificent world. Believe me, when you get into that world, you totally forget about the key :) If a man comes from the big city(being Istanbul in the movie) to a little town, he looks for the same cursory life style and worthless physical love. But, he has a different destiny(oh yes. i believe in destiny:). God will teach him the meaning of love, with a simple, cute girl(she is being the "alyazmali-girl with the red scarf-").

I don't want to spoil the movie. So, i am not going to tell the story. But when the movie ends, you'll accept that, everything i said about "Alyazmali" is true. You may cry(don't be ashamed).

PS: If you read that review and watch the movie, and of course if you like it, don't think that Turkish movie history has only 1 big shot. I can say that, there are at least 20 films which, after you watch, you would give 10 over 10 on IMDb.

Was the above review useful to you?

4 out of 9 people found the following review useful:
Love Triangle, 7 January 2009
9/10
Author: semarw (semarw@hotmail.com) from Turkey

True love is the thing people try to find for centuries. But you will question what is "true love" while watching this classic film of Turkey.

Is it a physical attraction or is it a full devotion (sharing the good and bad sides of life). The story is a known one. An innocent girl and a passionate young man... And a third person enters their life. This could be seen as a love triangle. And the girl with the red scarf has to make a decision....

And you will think what you would do if you were Asya. You must think twice.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Plot synopsis Ratings Awards
External reviews Plot keywords Main details
Your user reviews Your vote history