Brigadoon: Marin to Melan (TV Series 2000–2001) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A Very Different Robot Show
iwantsofia8 September 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I outgrew most sci-fi series involving robots years ago, but Brigadoon somehow seemed different.

The story begins by introducing Marin Asagi (voiced by Kaori, no last name), a very happy girl who delivers papers and daydreams a lot. She lives at a nagaya, a low income Japanese apartment complex, with the elderly woman who adopted her. Suddenly, a strange world appears in the sky, and killer robots attack Marin. Then a blue robot with a gun and sword for arms protects her. What's it all mean? You'll have to watch all 26 episodes to find out!

Tokyopop gave this series a 13+ rating when they released it on DVD in 2003. Certainly it's not appropriate for anyone younger than 13. The robots in this series are living weapons and they bleed purple blood. There's much purple blood splattered about in this show. There are also human casualties. Some viewers may also be offended by the frequency of "casual" nudity. It's hardly sexual in nature, but it's there. The most disturbing element, however, is child abuse. Marin is frequently beaten up by bullies, spit on, pushed off bridges, threatened with knives, guns and swords, shot at and - most disturbing of all - has her head pounded on a table repeatedly by the chief of police while the other officers have their backs turned, all because she won't cooperate! Anyone who has been through the same things will surely sympathize with poor Marin.

There's also a manga version credited to Nozomi Watase that tells an alternate version of these events. Not present is one of my favorite supporting characters from the anime, Midori Mano. Sumire Hanazono is renamed Hannah, and is less nice in the manga. Both versions are out of print, but well worth seeking out.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Caution: Spoilers!
melanbluegirl21 July 2003
Warning: Spoilers
Marin is a your average 13 year old teenager. Well, average if you count the fact that she has a blue armored 200 year old Monomachian for a bodyguard. Melan Blue, the aforementioned Monomachian is here to protect poor little Marin from evil Monomachians that try to kill/kidnap her and take her to Brigadoon, the city/planet that suddenly appears in our sky in an alternate version of the 1970's. A heartwarming tale as Melan gets "humanized" by Marin and her family.

Brigadoon's animation is flawless, and the storyline is goes at a relaxing pace (so far. I only have the two DVDs), changing between scenes of intense action and cute humor.

Marin is a caring girl, who doesn't want others to suffer because of her (this seems to happen a lot in the series so far).

Melan at the beginning, is a rather unemotional and honest character, who, at first, doesn't understand Marin.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed