Reviews & Ratings for
"The Metropolitan Opera Presents" Falstaff (1992)"Live from the Metropolitan Opera" Falstaff (original title)

« Prev | 45 of 57 Episodes | Next »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 2 reviews in total 

Correction Required

8/10
Author: dsmith300 from Canada
28 July 2016

My copy shows Franco Zeffirelli as Director. The director listed on this entry is Brian Large, who appears in small print on the back of the sleeve, as the person who operated the video camera. If you consult the illustration of the front cover of the DVD, you will be able to see the director listed. The other director (Music Director) is James Levine. Quoting his name would make a lot more sense than Brian Large. I would have entered the correction myself, but it is not as user- friendly as I would have hoped - and I do not have the time to teach myself a new skill. (Is that enough words to allow me to post this comment? That was another roadblock I would suggest yo remove.)

Was the above review useful to you?

Ties with the 2001 production as the best Falstaff

10/10
Author: TheLittleSongbird from United Kingdom
23 March 2012

Verdi is my favourite of all opera composers, and I love Puccini, Rossini, Wagner, Richard Strauss and Mozart as well. I do like Falstaff very much, I think the music and situations sparkle when done right and the characters are interesting. In short it is a great opera, that while not quite top 7 Verdi(like La Traviata, Don Carlo, Aida, Otello, Il Trovatore, Rigoletto and La Forza Del Destino, though every Verdi opera is worth seeing or hearing at least once) it deserves to known for much more than just Verdi's last ever opera.

Alongside this production, I have seen the Donald Gramm, Renato Bruson, Willard White, Bryn Terfel and Ambrogio Maestri performances. While every one of them have many virtues and highly recommended, my favourites are this, the Donald Gramm performance(which I think is from Glyndebourne) and the 2001 Maestri one. I have just purchased the Van Dam production and looking forward to watching it.

When it comes to the production values, I loved the rich interiors and the sumptuous Tudor costumes. The sound is clear and the camera work is fluid and interesting, never undermining the comedy or the drama. The picture quality is mostly good as well, if occasionally grainy. Once again, it is fantastic musically, it is such a pleasant if complex score, and the orchestra play beautifully and stylishly, while James Levine's conducting is as brisk and as deeply-felt as ever with the ensembles genuinely exciting.

Paul Pishka is outstanding in the title role, one of his best roles alongside King Phillip(Don Carlo), Fiesco(Simon Boccanegra), Alidoro(La Cenerentola) and Timur(Turandot). I do think his voice is more a high bass rather than a baritone/bass baritone, but hearing and seeing him here as Falstaff you don't care. When I hear Falstaff, I think(usually) of a voice with richness and sonority. Plishka has a very rich and sonorous voice, and also sounds very rounded and beautiful. With the acting, he is wonderfully comic in places with his facial expressions delighting, but he is also compassionate and vulnerable, a side that is just as mesmerising as his Jorg in Stiffelio.

Of the support cast, I was most impressed with Barbara Bonney's Nanetta, beautiful both in voice and appearance(love those eyes) and what a vibrant presence. Her rendition of Sul Fil D'Un Soffio Etesio is simply magical, my personal favourite individual rendition of the production. Mirella Freni is one of my favourite singers of all time, one of my favourite sopranos alongside Sutherland, Caballe and Tebaldi. With some slight harshness occasionally, the singing has a lot of sheer beauty and every word and phrase is shaped musically. She is an alluring presence, and while Alice doesn't show her at her best dramatically(while she is not the best actress, I think people do underestimate her) like Fedora, Mimi, Micaela and Cio-Cio San she is very charming.

Marilyn Horne as Mistress Quickly is delightful, with a voice that is as full and as agile as ever before. Susan Graham is a perfect Meg Page, the role is rather small but this doesn't matter as, as is always the case with such a conscientious artist like Graham, the voice is firm and the acting is astute. Frank Lopardo is one of the better Fentons I've seen, I can understand why one may prefer a more lyric-sounding voice in alternative to Lopardo's spinto-like tone, but he still sings beautifully with no obvious strain and plays the role with purity and charm.

Bruno Pola is good enough as Ford, I prefer Frontoli, Luxon and Nucci on VHS/DVD, if not always at ease as he could be on the dramatic side of things. The singing is lovely though. Bardolph is solid, not too clownish, Pistol also, but I really enjoyed Piero Di Palma, his diction is beautifully enunciated and the tone is very smooth. Overall, a wonderful performance and one of my favourite Falstaffs. 10/10 Bethany Cox

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings Plot keywords Main details
Your user reviews Your vote history