Catman thinks Timmy has been kidnapped. He mistakes Chloe for Catgirl and enlists her help to save Timmy. Timmy wishes Dad was Mayor, but Timmy gets tortured by the paparazzi and risks having his fairies discovered.
Cosmo and Wanda are exhausted from taking care of their baby, so Timmy volunteers to take over and give them a night out on the town./Timmy wishes up indestructible hair with personality that can never be cut!
Timmy's got to have his tonsils out and Vicky is determined to make his stay in the hospital as painful as possible!Timmy wishes to see his favorite baseball team, the Pirates, but baby poofs them unto to a real pirate ship.
Timmy's tired of being the guinea pig when the fairies, anti-fairies and pixies compete to see "who is the best magical creature in the universe?" He suggests a competition to determine once and for all who is best.
Dad entrusts Timmy with washing and preserving his classic Stryker Z sports car!Wanda worries that Poof doesn't have interaction with other fairy babies, so Timmy turns the adult fairies into babies, so Poof can play with.
Timmy wishes up a girlfriend for Crimson Chin and soon the Chin dating a woman named Golden Locks...except now the comic is both boring and romantic.Vicky is determined to get a job after Timmy's parents fire her.
When Catman tells Timmy that he's used up 8 of his 9 cat lives saving Dimmsdale from crime, Timmy helps Catman find a "safer" job where he can still help people. Mom turns the house into a bed and breakfast!
When Timmy doesn't get what he wants for Christmas he simply wishes for it. But his friends can't do the same, so Timmy wishes every kid could get a magical coupon that would allow them to wish for the one thing they didn't get.