Wrong Number (1959) Poster

(I) (1959)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Odd but likeable, a bit stagy
huiac3 February 2001
An experienced gang have held up a post office van, but this time they killed one of the guards; a little old lady dials the wrong number and calls their hideout - will this be their undoing?

A curious detective story that is presented in a very plain, matter-of-fact way that seems quite stagy - almost like an old educational documentary - but nonetheless held my attention when I stumbled across it on Saturday afternoon TV.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Well crafted British crime thriller of the fifties
robert-temple-117 November 2016
This is a B picture which works very well and has an ingenious plot. It also contains a brilliant supporting performance by the elderly actress Olive Sloane, who out-performs all the other actors and frankly steals the film. The story concerns a gang of robbers who are unmasked because of Olive Sloane dialling a wrong number. This was in the days of the old Strowger switches when telephone exchanges had names. One dialled the first three letters of that name (all telephone dials then had both letters and numbers on them sharing the same spaces), followed by four numbers. Olive Sloane plays an elderly spinster, who had been a suffragette when young. She lives alone with her Pekinese dog called Belcher. Belcher becomes a bit ill, so she decides to phone the vet. But she is distracted by Belcher tangling up her yarn after dialling MIL, intending to dial MIL 1124. She then returns to the phone which she has continued to hold in her hand and starts with MIL again, which because she has already dialled MIL goes through as its three corresponding numbers, namely 645. She dials 1124 after that, only the 1 registering. So that means she has really dialled MIL 6451 without realizing it. This turns out to be the house where the robbers are counting their stolen £80,000. One of them is called Angelo, and his girl friend answers Olive Sloane's call and says: 'Angelo, is that you? How did it go?' before the elderly lady interrupts and asks for the vet. By this means the name of one of the robbers becomes known to the police. Olive Sloane's monologues and subsequent interactions with the police inspector are absolutely priceless, and for those interested in excellent performances, the film is worth seeing for them alone. The robbery aspects are more or less run of the mill stuff, but Vernon Sewell directs very well, and this 58 minute B picture manages to rise above its station, like a member of the working class refusing to doff his cap but putting on a bowler instead. Lisa Gastoni is very good, sultry and sensuous, as the girl friend of Angelo. She is an under-rated actress. I note from IMDb that she appeared in the spectacularly brilliant film SACRED HEART (2005) by Ferzan Ozpetek (see my review), by which time she was 70 years old, though I cannot retrospectively recall her character of Eleonora, as it is eight years now since I saw that film. However, Gastoni has made 79 films, including one to be released next year, and has achieved much greater recognition in Italy than in the English-speaking world. Although IMDb says that this film is based on a play by Norman Edwards, the film credits themselves say it was based on a short story by him. I do note from IMDb that this story was filmed first in German as FALSCH VERBUNDEN in 1955. This odd sequence of filming events remains unexplained, and I see from the internet that he published a detective novel called DILEMMA in 1936. He cannot be the same Norman Edwards of our own days who writes books about flower arrangements. I have a feeling that there is an interesting story behind our Norman Edwards, perhaps worthy of a private investigator's attention. Something tells me there is more to him than meets the eye, or ever will meet anyone's eye now, after so many decades have gone by. Aren't unanswered questions fun? This film is well worth seeing, for those interested in puzzling plots with new angles.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A new take on a familiar plot
wilvram24 October 2021
This is the old story of thieves falling out after a heist but is agreeably done and holds the attention throughout. There's the rivalry over the glamorous Lisa Gastoni between Peter Reynolds' Angelo and the gang boss Dr Pole, and tension between Pole who doesn't have a criminal record and the more reckless members of the gang. The dotty old lady whose crossed line causes the gang more problems might have become irritating, but is delightfully played by Olive Sloane, leading to a satisfying conclusion.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A minor, but enjoyable crime-gone-wrong story
shaneo35503 February 2001
A call to a wrong number leads to the downfall of a group of robbers. Typical of many others of it's time - the police are helpful, the crooks are greedy and squabbling, and the apparently doddering old lady still has her wits about her. No real surprises here, but still quaint and fun to watch.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Another miss marple?
malcolmgsw7 July 2019
Olive Sloane obviously enjoys hereself do all the detective work A lot of nostalgia,white fivers,steam trains and phone numbers with letters on the dial. Routine but entertaining thriller
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed