Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 3 reviews in total 

9 out of 12 people found the following review useful:

An incredible musical document!

Author: richards1052 from Seattle, WA
1 January 2003

This is a remarkable film on the War Symphonies of Shostakovitch & covers roughly the period 1936-1952. There is a seamless quality to the music & interview footage with ea. commenting incisively on the other.

The most powerful & amazing feature of the film is its depiction of the terrifyingly fragile existence that Shostakovich led during this period; thinking that his every breath (& certainly every new piece of music) might be his last if Comrade Stalin disapproved (as he sometimes did).

It is hard to find to view, but worth every cent of effort. Contact Bullfrog Films if you'd like to buy the video (it ain't cheap!)


Was the above review useful to you?

0 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Fascinating and keeps you riveted all the way through

Author: TheLittleSongbird from United Kingdom
19 October 2013

One of those documentaries where you learn such a lot from but also can get emotionally invested in. The War Symphonies: Shostakovich Against Stalin easily could have been pandering and insensitive, but it wasn't any of these things, and it treats the subject matter with intelligence and care not to skim the surfaces too much. The archival footage included is powerful and often heart-wrenching, and to have survivors of the purge as well as the musicians, friends and fellow composers are an inspired touch and added a touch of honesty. And this is to the extent that even when you know something about Stalin's regime(which saw a lot of murder, totalitarianism and repression), what is said by the participants goes into much depth that you think "maybe I didn't know about it as much as I thought I did", and for the survivors it in some ways must have been painful to relive. The documentary also focuses on the plight and struggles to fight against the regime with the fear of being caught(anybody else thinking of George Orwell's 1984 here?) of Shostakovich himself, and here you relate to the composer every step of the way. The documentary is very well shot, while Shostakovich's music in the foreground and background has such intensity and somewhat reflective too. They come through loud and clear, and with so much feeling, in the orchestral playing and Valery Gergiev's- one of the best conductors working today- authoritative and very intelligent conducting(certainly didn't feel like a recording/Gergiev promotion to me). Gergiev is also one of the main participants and he shows himself to be very knowledgeable as well as thoughtful, though you do wish that he wasn't being interviewed from the back of a moving car. The archival footage, the music and documentary interviews as well as Shostakovich's plight and struggles are meshed beautifully and flow seamlessly, no obvious signs of disjointedness. Overall, The War Symphonies: Shostakovich Against Stalin is both riveting and fascinating. If there was anything to criticise it for, it was that it was so powerful and absorbing that you wish that it could have been longer. 10/10 Bethany Cox

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 13 people found the following review useful:

Boo Stalin!

Author: Spuzzlightyear from Vancouver
18 October 2006

The War Symphonies: Shostakovich Against Stalin is all about one composer's (that would be Shostakovich) fight against a brutal regime (that would be Stalin). We've seen a lot of these types of movies before, heck some even current (most of them of course coming from China), but this topic never gets old. Communist Russia, for some odd strange reason, is fascinating to me, so this was especially interesting. Weinstein deftly handles the material using a wealth of stock footage not only of Shostakavich and Stalin, but of general scenes from Communist Russia (and best of all, from those old Communist manifesto musicals), and makes this film about classical music (usually a warning sign for me) passable.

Was the above review useful to you?

Add another review

Related Links

Plot summary Ratings External reviews
Plot keywords Main details Your user reviews
Your vote history