Yu mian xia (1971) User Reviews

Fun mix of kung fu, swordplay, comedy and drama - highly entertaining

[freydis-e · 7/10 · 3 March 2018]

Only one review here so I'll add my opinion. This is highly entertaining, mainly because of Lily Ho who takes the lead almost throughout. We have a bit of kung fu, a bit of swordplay and Ho isn't brilliant at either, but she's very agile - or so her character keeps telling us. As a cocky brat, raised by a bunch of villains she is quite perfect, she plays the part at all times with endless energy and enthusiasm and her facial expressions are often hilarious. Anyone at all pretentious (including both the hero and the villain) she treats with arrogant disdain, but she gets on just fine with more genuine people, as in the scene with the drunkard and the old priest at the temple, one of the funniest I've seen in this genre - poor bees! The support actors do their job but despite the twin billing, this is a one-woman show.

The standard revenge on parent-killer theme is complicated here (quite a lot) by the baggage left over from the plotting of three manipulative older-generation sisters, it's not always that obvious where the movie is headed and the fast pace keeps up the excitement throughout.

There's more location shooting here than you see in most Shaw Bros martial arts films, the scenery is gorgeous and the cinematography makes the most of that. Martial arts fans may be disappointed by the quality of the action, though there's plenty of it and some of the swordplay isn't too bad. Not one for the purists maybe, but in terms of entertaining fun, the Shaw brand doesn't deliver any better than this.

A jade face by any other name would be just as pretty

[ckormos1 · 7/10 · 18 March 2019]

I watched this movie three times over the past six years so I better get a review posted. "Jade Faced" can be translated as pretty or feminine faced so that can explain the title. Some of these movies have many other titles but I find no other titles for this one.

For the whole movie Lily poses as a man. She has minimal feminine traits in contrast to the usual hot chick posing as a man. The plot is rather overcomplicated but at the bottom is twins separated at birth to be reunited at a dramatic moment later in life. The plot was remade in 1979 as "Proud Twins". That's the Alex Fu Sheng movie. I liked that movie a lot more mostly because of Alex Fu Sheng. In this movie I enjoyed Mei Sheng Fan's character the most.

Yes, the fights are scarce and that usually means the action drags but this movie did maintain a good pace. My only complaint about the action was the wire work looked too much like poor puppeteering at times and the reverse motion was over used.

Shaw Brothers spent a bundle on outdoor sets for 1971 as seen with the big bridge, the pagoda and the Tiger gang fortress all visible in "The New One-Armed Swordsman" for one movie. None of that is seen in this movie. There are the usual fabulous indoor sets plus some also fabulous outdoor remote locations that Shaw Brothers rarely bothered to travel to despite being nearby.

Overall just another just above average movie from Shaw Brothers during their golden age of martial arts movies.

THE JADE FACED ASSASSIN—Lily Ho gives energetic performance in fun swordplay tale

[BrianDanaCamp · 2 February 2008]

THE JADE FACED ASSASSIN (1970) is yet another female swordplay adventure from Hong Kong's Shaw Bros. studio, but one distinguished from so many others by virtue of its eventful, unpredictable plot line, breathtaking location photography, and lead performance by Lily Ho that set a new standard for female-fighters-dressed-as-men-themed martial arts films. Lily plays Siao Lu Er, who was separated from a twin in infancy and raised by the motley crew of villains in Happy Valley, each of whom imparts his or her particular kung fu style to the girl. When she turns 18, she's good enough to beat them all and heads out on her own, dressed in male garb, on a mission of revenge laid out for her by Uncle Lian (Ku Feng), the one who'd rescued her from certain death in the opening scene when an intra-familial dispute left her real parents dead.

A lot happens in the film's running time and a plot summary wouldn't do it justice. Let's just say that Lily winds up mixing it up with just the right crew of characters to ultimately resolve all disputes even though none are initially aware of their real identities. The audience knows (or can figure out) far more than the characters do, which makes for genuine suspense and gives the viewer a real stake in the action. In the course of it, Lily latches onto a fellow called Hero Chang (Cheng Pei-shan) and correctly suspects him of great wrongdoing and then sets out to prove it. In the course of it she clashes with a young swordsman named Hua Yu Chun (Kao Yuen) whose relationship to her becomes obvious to the viewer long before the characters learn of it.

Lily was not one of the Shaw studio's greatest fighting stars. (She was more accustomed to contemporary dramatic roles or period courtesan ones.) However, she displays a great affinity with her character here and understands how to put over the fact that she's a girl masquerading as a guy. She moves in just the right way and addresses others and interacts with them with the easy familiarity of a cocky young man. She gets it right in a way so few of the actresses who played these roles did. We don't automatically think, "But it's obvious she's a girl!" She also gets to do a lot of action here, mostly running around, trailing bad guys, hiding under things, leaping out of windows and up to rooftops and such. There really isn't as much fighting action as there should be in a film like this and what there is isn't the most intricately staged. Still, there is so much movement among the characters and at such a fast pace that we really don't mind.

Another key factor of the film's appeal is the visual spectacle of some of the most unusual and picturesque mountain locations I've yet seen in a Shaw Bros. film. And they clearly took the main actors out on location for this action. The fight finale on a majestic mountain top with incredible views all around is quite amazing. I should add that the studio work is equally good, with an early segment in Happy Valley making excellent use of the Shaw studio's expert interior work, creating a setting of a rundown no-man's town of criminal fugitives that's quite striking and atmospheric.

The scenes of Lily in Happy Valley reminded me of THE PROUD TWINS (1979), in which Fu Sheng played a very similar character raised by unsavory characters. So I checked my notes and realized this one is indeed based on the same Ku Lung story that PROUD TWINS is based on. But there are enough significant plot changes to make the viewing experiences quite different.

Oh, and despite the title, I couldn't spot a single Jade Faced Assassin anywhere.