1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:
Very good movie, but the book was better
John Howard (bookreader222) from Indiana, United States
19 June 2006
As my reviews at Amazon will indicate, I am a fan of Christopher
Andrews the author. I read his book adaptation of "Dream Parlor" about
6 months ago, and I loved it. I waited to see if the movie would become
available for rent from Blockbuster, but I decided not to wait any
longer and bought a copy. For the most part, I am pleased with my
First, the movie is low budget, but I do not write this to be negative.
Viewers should just be aware that this is an independent film, and
should not expect the flash or special effects of current Hollywood
fare. The film makers did a lot with what they had to work with, and
the director has a good eye. There's some decent CGI work, but don't
expect "The Matrix" here.
Second, the performances were better than one might expect from a low
budget movie. I've already been impressed with Andrews as a writer, and
now I see that he's a pretty good actor, too. So are Harold Cannon (who
I think I've seen before) and Kevin Moore, and an enjoyable Kevin
Crowther. Alison Storry was less impressive, but she was far from
terrible. All together, a solid cast.
Finally, the movie has a slow but steady pace, which picks up
noticeably in the final act. The total running time felt a little
short, but I'll get to that in a moment. Social and religious
commentary is evident, but it does not bog the movie down. The story is
straight forward and relevant, and refreshingly high brow. There were
some strobe effects that got a little hard on the eyes during the
film's climax, but they don't last long enough to be a real problem.
And as I mentioned in my Amazon review of the book, the main characters
of Eli and Corbit are multi layered and very human.
My only real complaint is that some of the supporting characters ended
up being a little flat and two dimensional. And having read the book,
which was BASED on this movie, I was a little surprised by this. It had
been several months since I read the book, but I kept feeling that
something was missing here and there. So I looked through the DVD's
special features, and sure enough, THERE were the deleted scenes that I
was half remembering.
As I mentioned above, the movie is a little short, running just barely
more than 90 minutes. So I can't help but wonder WHY some of those
scenes were cut. A visit to the movie's website explains some of these
decisions, but still ... with so much time to spare under the 2 hour
mark, it seems that SOME of these scenes could have remained intact and
fleshed out those characters. Especially Kirk, who could have been more
than just a cookie cutter tough guy.
But again, I make these biased comments as a fan of Andrews' books in
general, and "Dream Parlor" in particular. It is possible that, had I
not KNOWN that something was missing here and there, I MIGHT not have
noticed as much.
Still, overall I enjoyed this independent film, and consider it a
worthy partner to its somewhat better novelization. Rent it if you can
find it, buy it if you can't!
Add another review