|Page 1 of 5:||    |
|Index||50 reviews in total|
When I first heard about this being based on Dostoyevsky's Crime and
Punishment I was fearful that it was going to be another half-hearted teen
version of a classic. I am so glad I was wrong.
While Dostoyevsky made his point with words, Rob Schmidt did the same with the films imagery which truly was both narcotic and haunting. He would make you feel as if you were in some drug induced dream/nightmare. You felt as if you were trapped between Heaven and Hell, happiness and sorrow, love and loss.
As the story progresses you watch the ghosts of Roseanne (Monica Keena) slowly absorb her. She goes from this glowing image of beauty to a shadow of a human being. It's stark and disturbing. While Vincent (Vincent Kartheiser) the seemingly gloomy one, who loves her from the beginning of the film is the sole voice of reason, hope, and beauty in her slowly cascading world of tragedies.
The film epitomizes the continuous hopelessness that many today feel but refuse to acknowledge. Although, I think what the film does best is that it shows us these sadnesses while reinforcing us with the concepts that we can make anything happen if we want to badly enough. Good or bad, we are the only ones responsible for our fates.
I'll admit, I was not in the most jovial of moods when I sat down to view
Crime and Punishment in Suburbia, so the plot had a far greater impact than
it would have had I been in an upbeat mood. But, at the same time I was
expecting yet another glossy teen flick where a mess of pretty people prance
around on the screen for ninety minutes, after which the credits roll to the
tune of a popular radio hit. However, I found quite the opposite. I was
genuinely moved by this film. Though it is not the most original movie I've
seen, it touched me in a very unique way.
Ultimately, do not judge this movie by it's generic, mainstream movie cover. It is actually a high quality piece of cinema. And fellow teenagers, drop your Cruel Intentions and Bring It Ons and give this a try. It might not be oscar award material, but it is far more engaging than any of the pg-13 tripe they try and pawn off on you at blockbuster. Give it a shot. If you like it, good. If you don't, oh well.
The 3 best aspects to this film are the acting, cinematography and
This film just made me a big fan of Monica Keena and Vincent Kartheiser. Both delivered dynamic and intriguing performances. Monica Keena's character is transformed throughout the film and she's able to convey that arc with great subtlety. Vincent Kartheiser's character was also conveyed very well, not overdone like so many other goth/nerd characters are portrayed.
The cinematography was great - visually compelling imagery and an unsteadiness throughout that lends to the feel of uneasiness with what is happening to the characters. It lends itself to the feelings, moods of not only the characters in the film but to the viewer as well. A great film engages the viewer and makes them feel as though they have been drawn into the world of the film.
Finally I'm a big fan of music and soundtracks that aren't cliché and don't dominate a scene. I'd love to get my hands on a list of all the songs used in the film.
The writing was decent, and many of the supporting actors played their parts very well - this easily could have devolved into overblown and overacted performances but nobody in the cast fell prey to that trap.
There's a strange morality to the story - one not easily discerned after one viewing. Of course there can be comparisons to the film "American Beauty" and while that one garnered all the praise and awards I believe this film is much more challenging yet far more fulfilling. It's more subtle and the answers aren't so easy to ascertain. I'll be watching this movie many times and I have a feeling I'll discover something new each time. Great movie!
Roseanne Skolnick (Monica Keena) is a popular cheerleader and
girlfriend of the football player Jimmy (James DeBello), and she has a
very dysfunctional family: her mother Maggie Skolnick (Ellen Barkin) is
having an affair with a bartender and her stepfather Fred Skolnick
(Michael Ironside) is a drunken and aggressive man. Vincent (Vincent
Kartheiser) is a sweet and weird teenager, who studies in the same
class and has a crush on Roseanne. He follows her everywhere with his
camera, taking lots of pictures of her in the most different places or
situations. When Roseanne is abused by her stepfather, she decides to
kill him, with the support of Jimmy. However, her mother Maggie takes
the blame and goes to the court for trial, being accused of murder.
During the trial of her mother, Roseanne has to live with her guilt,
being supported by Vincent. In the end, she has to decide: leave her
mother be convicted and live with the feeling of guilt for the rest of
her life, or assume the responsibility for the crime. "Crime and
Punishment in Suburbia" is a surprisingly great teen free adaptation of
Fyodor Dostoyevsky's "Crime and Punishment". The screenplay is very
well developed and the young cast has excellent performance. Although
having a great moral in the end, with the redemption of Roseanne, the
direction is so good that is able to conclude the plot without being
corny. I like good contemporaries free adaptations of famous romances,
and this one has not disappointed me. My vote is eight.
Title (Brazil): "Crime + Castigo" ("Crime + Punishment")
A powerful film that deserves much more attenion and credit than what it's getting. It barely played in theathers here, it was only in for about a week! The movie has wonderful acting by the entire cast. The standouts to me are Monica Keena who is the star of the film. I'm not sure on exactly how old she is, but, I honestly feel, that she does have a future in films. I think an Oscar nomination would be in order for her. But the chances of that happening are slim to none. And Ellen Barkin was wonderful in this movie as Monica's mother. It would also be wonderful to see her up for an Oscar also. But, again, the Academy would never nominate this film for anything. It's not mainstream enough. This is suppose to be a mordern retelling of Dostoevsky's "Crime and Punishment", while I fail to see any real comparisons other than the moral dilemma of murder, the film does a bad job retelling the story. But even so, I don't think the screenplay was bad. I think it was a very well written film, that makes sense, and is enjoyable to watch. I have nothing but great things to say about this films, but, I don't think it's for everyone. I think that has become obvious due to the very unwarm comments made by not only critics but also viewers. This is a movie I really hope people would watch and give it a try.
*** This review may contain spoilers ***
I hated this film, it was one of the cheesiest things I have ever seen. I rented it because it looked different from the usual teenage thriller types. Boy, was I wrong. I don't know what I hated more; the obvious trying to be emotionally intense or the obvious attempts to be cinematic. In both cases, they fail horrifically. I can honestly say that this is one of the worst films I have ever seen. From the poor acting to the cheese-fest killing scenes to annoying, hate-able protagonist I don't know which bit made me laugh most. This is one of those teenage films that tries to be American Beauty when really it's Confessions Of A Teenage Drama Queen. I enjoyed The Covenant more, at least The Covenant KNEW it was dumb, whereas this film is just in denial. I know a lot of teenagers my age think this is "arty" and "shocking!" but most teenagers are dumb as hell anyway. If you appreciate good cinema don't rent it, it sucks. If you have no idea what the words "good cinema" and "Gus Van Sant" mean, watch Donnie Darko, a film that is effortlessly cool and moving, unlike this lumbering piece of trash. "Best soundtrack of the year"? What movie were THEY watching?
Watching this movie, I thought "Gosh, a parody of American Beauty, terrific!". But, in the long run, I realized I was watching a strange, disturbing, involving movie. A movie about self-punishment, violence, beauty, love, crime... all mixed up, just in our life. Michael Ironside is a glorious b-movie star: it was the first time I saw him playing in such a character, obscene and suffered at the same time. A movie about how to get a new life, passing through tears and blood. A religious movie, worthy of Martin Scorsese or Sam Mendes (I wish Mendes could equal Scorse
I would be more perplexed by the low rating and the many vituperous
reviews if I didn't understand as much as I do about family
dysfunction, alcoholism, irresponsible behavior and all that. Some
people don't like this much truth in their faces. Oddly, it's not just
the perps; it's often the victims, as well.
For me, this is just an artfully rendered case study of the stuff I deal with four days a week. But I see more Victor Hugo (and "Les Miserables") here than I do Dostoyevsky.
Yeah; I agree the execution is uneven. At times to the point of being almost senseless. But that may be part of the charm. Life in the world described here -is- uneven. At times to the point of being almost senseless. (How many adolescent females with alcoholic parents have I known who think life is senseless? A hundred? -Two- hundred?)
Can't say I "enjoyed" this movie. The "Jimmy Stewart" character (from "Rear Window") is just a little too obsessed to work in the world of a young victim / victimizer who seems, at least, to be trying to make sense of it all. The trial scenes may well be meant to have a dreamlike quality, but they just seem disconnected. And the whole trip is plain ugly.
But the fact that the whole trip -is- so ugly is a major reason why this film demands to be seen. Alcohol; frustrated, narcissistic fathers; cougar moms and hottie daughters are a recipe for disaster that's being cooked daily in suburban America. This is reality in modern America. It'd be nice to put a stop to it before our whole culture becomes dysfunctional.
Nice little wake-up call here.
I knew nothing about this film before I saw it, so I was hoping it would be
some undiscovered classic. Quite soon, however, I realised that it was
pretentious nonsense. It had the air of being made by some studio in order
to appeal to teenagers who write rubbish goth poetry in their bedrooms. It
makes awful, contrived attempts to be "arty", while forgetting to add any
actual meaning. The characterisation is almost non-existent, people don't
seem to have any justifications for their actions, and while they may
occasionaly give reasons verbally the acting is so poor that the motivation
just isn't there. The dialogue, especially in the voice overs, is terrible
and amateurishly written. The pace is painfully slow, since I hadn't read
synopsis of the film (and I'm not familiar with the source material, and
same probably goes for the target audience, which shows how misjudged the
film is) I spent a long time wondering when this film would get to its
and indeed where it was going. There is no need for it to be so slow, and
there is also no point in dividing it up into sections other than to have
"cool" titles like "Damaged little f***ers" flashing up on the screen.
Dividing it up into sections only serves to highlight the lack of structure
and the inconsistency of the plot. The film is narrated from the point of
view of a character who only appears sporadically throughout the film, and
the film ends by concluding a plot line that is not very prominent except
the very beggining, so is quite pointless, yet acts like it is some kind of
I realise this review probably reads like a jumbled mess but then so does this film. Life is too short for garbage like this.
*** This review may contain spoilers ***
This movie is like the world's longest synopsis. You get the general
sense of what the story is about but none of the content or depth to
make it worth watching. The characters get almost no time to do
anything but be pounded down by the Almighty Plot Hammer. The dialog is
never better than a bad daytime soap opera. And yes, there are good
daytime soaps. When Days of Our Lives was about Doug and Julie and the
guy who played LeBeau on Hogan's Heroes, that was some quality
television. This film doesn't come close to being that engrossing. It
just introduces us to people who are, more or less, arbitrarily unhappy
and expects that to be enough to hold our interest. It's not.
Roseanne (Monica Keena) is a high school girl with a dumb jock boyfriend (James DeBello) and a gothy teen stalker (Vincent Cartheister) who turns out to be a Jesus freak. She also has some bitterly dysfunctional parents (Michael Ironside and Ellen Barkin). Roseanne's mom runs off with this random bartender (Jeffrey Wright). Roseanne's step-dad gets drunk and rapes her. The step-dad gets killed, someone who didn't do it winds up on trial and none of it has any impact. It just goes on and on and on and then on some more.
I've got no complaint with how Crime and Punishment in Suburbia was shot. The music is fine and scenes are well edited. I can find no fault with the cast's performances. And it's not like it doesn't make sense or is without a definable purpose. But there's no meat on these bones. It takes about an hour and a half for this movie to get to its first substantive conversation and that's mostly a monologue about teen age angst. Voice over narration is used as an obvious crutch when these filmmakers didn't have any better idea how to convey something to the audience. When the film wraps up by telling you what happened to each character, you can't avoid the realization that they could have all been eaten alive by meth-fueled fire ants for as much as you care about them.
Crime and Punishment in Suburbia is clearly one of those motion pictures that is supposed to connect with the viewer on a gut level and it's that investment which then provides the meaning and context for everything on the screen. My gut didn't connect with anything, reducing the movie to a tedious chore. If your gut is more sensitive than mine, you might get something out it. If you're bored after the first 15 minutes, though, take my advice and move on because it won't get any better.
|Page 1 of 5:||    |
|Newsgroup reviews||External reviews||Parents Guide|
|Plot keywords||Main details||Your user reviews|
|Your vote history|