User Reviews

Add a Review
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Historically important but dreadful.
MartinHafer30 September 2013
The title of this is "Gems of MGM". Well, in the gemological world, these gems MIGHT be quartz...at best! With such a big and important studio, you'd think they'd be able to do better than this! This is a dry, dreadful and, occasionally, gross little short film. It consists of Marion Harris, the Brox Sisters and Bechers Kiddie Ballet doing some routines that are old fashioned and uninteresting. But, to top it off, Benny Rubin does a black-face routine--one that is not just offensive but bad. In many ways, this is like some of the Vitaphone shorts--though the Vitaphone/Warner shorts usually featured GOOD acts--this MGM one does not! It's only of interest for its historical value. As entertainment, it's pretty awful.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? | Report this
Not a Good Film But Worth Watching for Film Buffs
Michael_Elliott21 September 2012
Gems of M-G-M (1930)

** (out of 4)

This short from MGM isn't what one would consider a "good" movie but I think film buffs will want to check it out. Benny Rubin first comes out playing an embarrassing Russian Jew with some rather unfunny remarks, which will probably insult some. Then he introduces Marion Harris who does a couple musical numbers. Rubin then comes back out, this time in blackface, and yikes is the performance bad. He then introduces The Brox Sisters who perform two music numbers. GEMS OF M-G-M certainly doesn't contain any gems but it's worth viewing for a couple reasons. One is Harris who does a nice job with a couple of her numbers and some might remember her name for a variety of reasons that can be found online. The second reason to watch the film is due to Rubin, not because he's good but because he's just so strange. Watching blackface acts today is a lot different than if we were in a theater back in 1930. This type of comedy no longer works today and usually when viewed today it's just for a shock value. The shock value is here but I found Rubin to be incredible boring and bland with his jokes. The dancing wasn't too bad but he's certainly a long way from Jolson.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? | Report this
A couple of songs to listen to.
39-0-1311 July 2007
Benny Rubin is an embarrassment, of course, not just the black face, but also the Russian Jew figure. Still, he provides a view of why Jolson, Cantor, and Jessel were more highly acclaimed on Broadway and vaudeville as black face and comedy performers. Those guys had more energy, more personality, more charisma than Rubin had.

But pay attention to the two featured performers: Marion Harris, who was fired by her recording company for wanting to sing Handy's "St. Louis Blues," is generally acclaimed as the first white woman to sing black blues back in the '20's. Here, she sings a radically alternate version of the Richard Whiting-Neil Moret standard "She's Funny That Way." She sings a dark, very bleak version called "I'm Funny That Way." I can't tell whether Whiting wrote the lyrics, and I can't find the song on any lyrics/song sheet collection on the Net. Still, this now forgotten singer conjures up images of other torch singers of that era -- Helen Morgan and Ruth Etting, for example. She does not come across as second rate by any standard.

Then, there's a couple of songs by the Brox Sisters. Three girls who predated the close harmony of the Boswell Sisters, the Perkins Sisters, the Andrews Sisters, the McGuire Sisters, etc. The song that stands out is "Just You, Just Me" which Woody Allen found good enough to include in his film "Everyone Says I Love You" (1996). Nice to hear how that song might have played way back when. It's still very easy on the ears.

Really, this film short, as shown on TCM, is very much worth watching. Not just for historical purposes, but for the delight of hearing two interpretations of songs that have now become standards.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? | Report this
A tomato hurling horror
glenndmiller21 December 1999
I happened to have my VCR on the "record" mode when this appeared on TCM. Judging from the film I'd say it was made in late 1928 - early 1929. Benny Rubin comes out in various guises (once in blackface; the 20's were such a tasteful time) and at one point introduces the Brox sisters. They appear to be wearing clothes made entirely of lace; they have pretty voices but the songs they perform, and their style of performance, is so far removed from our experience that one can't help but gape open-mouthed. I was waiting for three hooks to come out and snare them by their necks.
4 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? | Report this

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews