IMDb > A Flintstones Christmas Carol (1994) (TV) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
A Flintstones Christmas Carol (TV) More at IMDbPro »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 10 reviews in total 

10 out of 14 people found the following review useful:

Droll...Veeeeeeery Droll

Author: sm from usa
30 November 2003

When I first caught this movie on cable a few years ago, I expected it to be of the "Flintstones Meet The Jetsons" fare, or something equally par for the standard TV course. But I was happily surprised, and went out the next day to buy the videotape. True, the sub-plot of Fred ignoring work, friends, and family to rehearse his upcoming role as Scrooge for the Bedrock Community Players (and to give in to grandiose dreams of Broadrock Way) are of the typical fare we've been used to for a couple of decades now. But once the actual production gets underway, try to forget the rest because you will be as happily surprised as I. The voice talent seems to take their roles in "A Christmas Carol" very seriously, and most do a formidable job, handling the script with reverence and affection. Well, let's face it--what actor doesn't want to be in "A Christmas Carol" just once for the sheer fun of it? But Henry Corden is the surprising stand-out in this, proving that he can do more than just play straight man to Barney and Wilma's cutting one-liners. He treats this role as if he's been studying to play Scrooge

for years. You get a hint of what's to come in the Ebonezer/Fanny/Ghost of Christmas Past scene, mixing a balance of fragile loss and forced bitterness very well indeed. By the time the Ghost of the Future shows up, Henry really sports his acting chops, and by the last few scenes he pulls off a terrific and moving performance, showing the delicate sadness, guilt, and the pivotal dichotomy of the fear of living and fear of dying that the character of Scrooge is really made of. OK, so it's not Albert Finney in "Scrooge"; but it's certainly not the kind of acting one expects of a Flintstones cartoon--well, not since the passing of Alan Reed, and the mass-production of Saturday morning Flinstones cookie-cutter shows. It's refreshing to see Henry Corden pull out all the stops and remind us that he is an actor, not just a Fred substitute. Although one wonders and mourns what Mel Blanc could have brought to this tour-de-force as Barney/Cragit...(sad sigh). During the curtain call, all pull back and fall into typical Hanna-Barbara "filler humor", but what has just happened should more than make up for those last 4 minutes. Overall, this is a wonderful addition to anyone's Scrooge collection, and should be picked up to enjoy while decking the Bedrock halls for years to come!

Was the above review useful to you?

4 out of 5 people found the following review useful:

A Classic

Author: Dave ( from New York
26 March 2006

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

From Amazon

Fred and the gang have more than the usual festive preparations up their prehistoric sleeves, however, as they are staging a production of "The Christmas Carol" with Fred in the role of Scrooge. Things take a frightening turn when--in the classic tradition of method acting--Fred takes his role to heart and becomes a bit humbuggish himself. So preoccupied with his role is he, that he forgets to pick up Pebbles from day care, leaves Christmas shopping off his list of things to do, and belittles the parts played by his friends (such as Barney as Bob Cratchit). When the Bedrock bug (a flu virus) begins to fell cast members, it provides the ideal opportunity for costume maker and stage manager Wilma to take on understudy duties and scare some sense into her self-absorbed husband. And just in time for Christmas Eve.

From Me This Christmas Special is a Classic, I have been watching it every Christmas since it came out and it still touches me. This even inspired me to create a production of a Christmas Carol, which from hundreds of people I was praised with two thumbs up. You definitely need to catch this, a great special from the modern StoneAge Family.

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Not quite classic status, but a nice Flintstone twist on the timeless story

Author: TheLittleSongbird from United Kingdom
30 December 2010

A Flintstone Christmas Carol was very good. I loved the twist on one of the all-time great Christmas stories A Christmas Carol especially, however it doesn't quite make classic status for me. Is it as good as the TV show? No it isn't, but as well as putting the twist to Christmas Carol, it does make an effort to stick to the show's spirit. If anything, I wish this cartoon was a little longer, and one or two parts are a little uneven in pace, but that's all I have to say that's negative really. The animation is good, it has a colourful and charming feel to it. The music was also very nice, quite heart-warming and melodious, and the story is of course great. I loved the writing overall too, while there are some funny lines there are also some touching parts without feeling mawkish. The characters are still likable, and step into the Dickens characters' shoes with aplomb. It was a delight in itself seeing who was who. And the voice acting is fine, and like the special itself all the voice actors do make some effort to stick to the original voices which is no easy feat(especially in Mel Blanc's case). Overall though, it was a nice special and definitely worth re-visiting. 8/10 Bethany Cox

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Yabba Dabba Ho

Author: Shawn Watson from The Penumbra
21 December 2010

Bart Simpson once put it best when he said that TV writers have been milking the 'Christmas Carol' goat for years. Nearly every established animated franchise (as well as some sitcoms and soaps) have cut and pasted Charles Dickens' novel over the years, from Mickey Mouse to Mr. Magoo.

The Flintstones manage to do it a little bit better though, by giving the story a meta-fictional edge, much like Scrooged. Fred is busy preparing for his role as Ebenezer Scrooge for the Bedrock Community Theatre, so much so that he's been neglecting his own friends and family in order to boost his performance. The line between fantasy and reality blurs as Fred/Scrooge is scared straight by the three ghosts,

A very good Xmas Special, though I'm still not sure how the holiday is exists in the prehistoric era, or how a 19th century novel manages to exist either. Either way, it certainly worth watching.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

The tale comes alive!

Author: Robert from United States
31 December 2011

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

The Flintstones are in a play, titled the Christmas Carol. It may seem to be just another rendition with characters and general locations changed to fit the cartoon, but this also integrates the story into real life. Fred is the main character in the play... but he acts like the main character in real life! He ends up having the play help him to realize the mistakes he's made and he, while performing in the play, realizes the wrongs he has done that Christmas.

I loved the humor and the jokes... including the gross bedrock bug, haha.

Anyway, rating this 8/10 for fairly accurately capturing the story as well as putting it in real life.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Yabba Dabba Humbug!

Author: ExplorerDS6789 from United States
21 December 2011

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

It's Christmastime in Bedrock, now you might be wondering how can there possibly be Christmas in the Stone Age, long before Jesus was even born? Simple, this is a cartoon. Back to the story, the Bedrock Community Players were putting on a production of Charles Brickens' classic tale, A Christmas Carol. Fred Flintstone managed to land the role of Scrooge since Wilma is the play's producer, and talk about a method actor, Fred practically disappears into his character as he ignores his friends and family and putting himself first all for the sake of rehearsing. Wilma began to feel Fred was a bigger Scrooge than Scrooge. Before he leaves, Wilma reminds Fred to drop Pebbles off at Cave Care and to make sure he picks her up at 4:00; At the quarry, Mr. Slate lets everyone off after lunch so nobody will be tardy to the play. Barney uses this time to wrap his presents and Fred... suddenly remembers he didn't buy any for his family so he races to Bloomingshales which is, of course, jammed. This is Christmas Eve, after all. He hastily grabs some gifts and heads to the gift wrap line, which stretched out a mile. Suddenly, it's 4:00. Showtime! Fred asks a kid in line to hold them and hurries out. He stops at home for a bite and then gets to the theater. But it seems in all his haste that he had forgotten something mighty important: pick up Pebbles! Luckily Barney had gotten her when picking up Bamm-Bamm. This selfish oversight on Fred's part was the straw that broke the camel's back as Fred gets a wake-up call, as well as curtain call, so now the play can finally begin. Ebonezer Scrooge (Fred) is the cold-hearted miser who just lost his business partner, Marbley (Mr. Slate). After berating Bob Cragit (Barney) for using coal, Scrooge is visited by his nephew Ned (changed from Fred for obvious reasons), who invites him to dinner. Scrooge rejects the invitation and sets to greedily counting his money, and if you look up 'over-actor' in the dictionary, you'll find Fred's picture.

That night, Scrooge was visited by Marbley's ghost who is suffering for his sins and promises the same for Scrooge unless he changes his ways. Three more spirits would be visiting him. The miser assumes it's all a bad dream and goes to bed, as Act I comes to a close. By the way, there's a running gag where various characters come down with the Bedrock Bug, a prehistoric version of the flu. This causes Wilma to have to fill in as the Ghost of Christmas Past who, after abusing Fred for a bit, takes Scrooge to visit his past. How he started off as a quiet, lonely boy at school to an ambitious young go-getter working for Fezziwig (also Barney). It was at his employer's party that Scrooge met the love of his life, Belle (also Wilma because of the B.B.) Fred was unaware of the cast change so when he asks aloud why he isn't doing the scene with the other woman, Wilma takes offense. As we all know, greed got the better of Scrooge and he broke it off with Belle. This scene gets Wilma overly emotional, mainly because she's still bellyaching over Fred forgetting Pebbles, which Betty takes the opportunity to shame him for. It's at this point that Fred remembers the gifts back at Bloomingshales. Unfortunately, they're now closed, so Fred breaks in. He breaches an alarm, but thankfully Officer Philo Quartz is a friend of his and he's in the play too. So, Fred is off the hook and he rushes back to the theater. Well, onto the present. The ghost shows Scrooge Bob Cragit's family feasting on a meager meal, and he notices his youngest son is ill. If these shadows remain unaltered by the future, the child will die, you know the story. So after learning that the whole town essentially hates him, but will drink a toast to him on Christmas, Scrooge begins to get a good look at himself, as does Fred. Finally, the Ghost of Christmas Future shows him a future in which Cragit's son Tiny Tim has died, as has Scrooge, but nobody cares. When returning to the present, Scrooge has seen the error of his ways and was a new man. Fred was like a new man too, realizing how badly he'd neglected everybody, but he finally made amends with Wilma when he agreed to let his mother in-law come to dinner, then the kid showed up with the Flintstones' wrapped gifts, and to top it all off, Fred came down with the Bedrock Bug. Merry Christmas!

For what it is, A Flintstones Christmas Carol is a decent adaptation. Those who have seen Mister Magoo's Christmas Carol will recognize the play format and here, it works just as well, even if they do stray away from the story at times. I'm glad they didn't go the traditional route and have Slate as the Scrooge character and Fred as Cratchit, probably because The Jetsons did that about ten years prior. Now, I like how in this special, it parallels both Scrooge and Fred learning how to be good to their fellow men and how not to be so selfish. Fans of the franchises, both Flintstones and Christmas Carol, should definitely check it out. It's certainly an overlooked classic. Also, fans of The Flintstone Kids get a rare opportunity to see Philo Quartz all grown up!

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Rehashed Flintstone Plot Within a Christmas Carol

Author: richard.fuller1
25 December 2009

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Apparently this is truly one of the most multi-faceted Flintstones cartoons to be found. I caught on to neither the need to change the nephew's name to Ned or that the black officer was from Flintstones Kids (well, I never watched that cartoon), but the continuity is truly rare.

While the kid who wrapped Fred's presents may have resembled Arnold the paper boy from the sixties cartoon, he was never named such, nor was a co-worker identified as good ol' Joe Rockhead. Pity.

What I couldn't help but notice was how Fred being called a scrooge and he took it as a compliment was some strange underlying representation of offensive slang being taken in a positive manner. And it would happen more than once.

Wilma's behavior was a clunker. In the '77 Christmas program, in which Fred substitutes for Santa Claus who is ill (and a reworking of the Christmas episode from the sixties), Wilma and Mr. Slate and some very bratty children BLAME FRED, BLAME FRED, BLAME FRED! This is actually a strange holdover from the sixties cartoon (as is seen in Charlton comic books from the early seventies) in which Fred is overly self-centered and Wilma comes at him with a scowl and unkind word.

One bit worth noting is in the '77 cartoon, Pebbles and Bamm Bamm are small, talking children (younger than they were in the Sally Struthers-Jay North Saturday morning cartoon), but now in the 90s, they are reduced to toddlers once more.

Nevermind that somewhere in this decade, there would be the marriage of Pebbles and Bamm Bamm and the birth of the Flintstone-Rubble grandchildren in another program.

The Christmas Carol as a play then redone into the cartoon as a real incident was entertaining, but Fred's sudden revelation (as callously noted by Wilma) was unexplained.

Many of these attempts to do Flintstones, Muppets or Bugs Bunny versions of A Christmas Carol are odd to watch, as they tend to have no weak frail child like Tiny Tim in this age of precociousness (Tweety Pie was Bugs' and nephew Robin was the Muppets), nor do they have an overly intimidating creature like Scrooge. Donald Duck is cheery nephew Fred in the Disney cartoon version? Philo Quartz and nephew Ned show some thought was in this production. It could have been better, say, perhaps if Barney had been Jacob Marley and Slate had been Crachit.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Charles Brickens' A Christmas Carol!

Author: ( from U.S.A
4 December 2002

*** This review may contain spoilers ***


The Bedrock community theater, headed by Wilma Flintstones, will be putting on a production of Charles Brickens' A Christmas Carol and guess who will be playing Ebonyzer Scrooge? No, not Mr. Slate. That would be typecasting. The one chosen for the role was Fred Flinstones, who let this go to his head so much that he began acting like a Scrooge. Before he left for work, Wilma made him promise to pick up Pebbles at day-care before going to the theater. Fred promised. All day, he kept rehearsing for his part. Barney would be playing Scrooge's employee, Bob Cragit. Mr. Slate did get a part in the play: Ghost of Jacob Marbley. Fred returned home for a snack then remembered he hadn't done any Christmas shopping so he races to the crowded mall, picks out gifts, has them wrapped and held for him then he rushes to the theater, forgetting all about Pebbles! Barney got her when getting Bamm-Bamm. Wilma was very angry with Fred and frequently expressed it.

The show went on: Scrooge bellowed at Cragit for using coal, then Scrooge's nephew Fred came in to invite Scrooge to Christmas dinner. Scrooge refused the invitation and then kicked him out along with collectors for the poor. That night when going home, he was visited by the ghost of his former partner, Jacob Marbley. He told Scrooge that he would be visited by three spirits. The first came at 1:00. The Ghost of Christmas Past (Wilma, still irked at Fred) shows Scrooge his past, including his old love: Belle (also Wilma because the original actress came down with The Bedrock Bug). After that, the Ghost of Christmas Present shows Scrooge the present: his nephew Fred's family speaking ill of Scrooge, then the Cragit family: Bob, Mrs. Cragit (Betty), and Tiny Tim (Bamm-Bamm) who was crippled. The spirit told Scrooge that if these shadows remained unaltered by the future, he saw an empty chair where Tiny Tim once sat. At the end of the act, Fred suddenly remembered the presents so he zoomed to the mall, now closed. He sneaked in--and was apprehended by Officer Philo Quarts. He let Fred go because he was also in the play. Fred returned in time to do the scene where Scrooge is greeted by the Ghost of Christmas Future who shows that Tiny Tim has died and so has someone else whom nobody in town shows any mercy for. The departed was Scrooge! Just then, Scrooge awakens in bed. Had it been all a dream? Nope, but Scrooge is now a changed man. He brings a huge turkey and gifts to the Cragit family and all was well! "God bless us, everyone" says Tiny Tim and that was the end of the play, but everyone was still angry with Fred for what had happened, but he made it up to his friends. He even declared he'd invite his mother in-law to dinner. Wilma was pleased, then Fred's presents were delivered. Suddenly, Fred didn't feel so good. The Bedrock Bug!

A pretty good Christmas special. Fred Flintstone is the perfect Scrooge. That was bad that he forgot Pebbles, but wasn't Wilma a little hard on him at times? Other than that, I enjoyed A Flinstones Christmas Carol! If you enjoyed this, I recommend reading the Charles Brickens', er--Dickens novel! It's good. I haven't read it, but I'm sure it's good. I also recommend Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol which also pretty good. I haven't seen it in a long time but for now, check out A Flinstones Christmas Carol! Yabba Dabba Doo!

Was the above review useful to you?

0 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Not Bad Not Great "Right In-Between"

Author: kenny from USA
25 December 2010

This is on Boomerang now as I write the review.

I still have a hard time getting past the new voices, so that could be a part of it for me. They just aren't the same without the classic voice actors.

The animation is actually quite nice. The new voice actors do a good job even though I am so used to the classic ones. They hold true to the story with a fun back-story.

It's a cute re-tell, but is one that I wouldn't miss if I never saw it. If this is on & there isn't much else worth watching then have a go at it.

Was the above review useful to you?

5 out of 11 people found the following review useful:

Very very good...

Author: fjustice ( from hahaha
26 July 2002

A VERY FINE FEATURE FILM/CARTOON/ANIMATION/PLAY. I Love it. It is recommeded highly by me! Very funny rendition, even though I think it is just a bit to overdone. But, nonetheless, it is very great, and, if it were real people, Fred Flintstone would be the best Scrooge!!

10 OUT OF 10

Was the above review useful to you?

Add another review

Related Links

Ratings External reviews Plot keywords
Main details Your user reviews Your vote history