IMDb > Anatomy of an Accident (1961) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
Anatomy of an Accident More at IMDbPro »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 2 reviews in total 

7 out of 7 people found the following review useful:

Good film, but unintended blame?

Author: briguy_52732 from Eldridge, Iowa
26 April 2008

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Not a bad safety short, but I'm thinking there may have been some unfair blame placed on the father who swerved to avoid one collision but it ended up resulting in an even worse accident. See below for more.

The father, John, is a lineman for a telephone company. He takes his family of four (wife Helen, son, Tommy, and daughter, Kathy) up to see the in-laws. Prior to the trip, he does a thorough inspection of the car, having his son help demonstrate. Later, the family passes the scene of a multi-car pileup, caused in part when an elderly woman (driving an olive green car) didn't stop at a stop sign and the driver who had the right-of-way had to stop suddenly; several cars were following too close behind and thus, the accident. All along the road, John explains the principles of safe driving.

Later, the family comes up on the same old woman and her friend in the green car are driving very slowly (well below the posted speed limit) along a busy road; there are few passing lanes on the winding road. The woman finally decides to pull onto a side road but changes her mind at the last moment (the side road was "too dusty"); John tries to swerve around the old woman's car as she is attempting to pull back onto the road, but winds up colliding head-on with a semitruck driver. John is killed instantly; Tommy is knocked unconscious, while Helen and Kathy are bruised but OK. Of course, the old woman driver is nowhere to be found (she had earlier refused to stop at the accident in the city).

Herein lies my complaint — a post-moterm John blaming himself for the accident. However, I saw John as simply practicing defensive driving ... swerving to avoid one potential accident (with the inconsiderate woman, who probably should have pulled over when a line of cars formed behind her) but it didn't work out. He tells his son — who lays dying in the final scene — that his actions were too much of a gamble. Maybe, but in the age of two-lane roads, he had little choice to swerve to avoid one accident. Simply put, John was in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Still, a very good safety film that should be re-made for modern audiences. Even this 1961 original would be a great teaching tool.

Was the above review useful to you?

6 out of 6 people found the following review useful:

Dramatic ending

Author: spitfire-41 from United States
2 August 2008

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

I saw this film in grade school circa 1967, the family was the typical nuclear family of the late fifties era, preparing for and traveling en route to a vacation in the country. The scene I remember most was at the end of the story, the father and son are dead and the now financially desperate mother and daughter are forced to sell off some of the household possessions and furniture. Adding insult to injury, the woman driver who caused all of the accidents, Irene Tedrow, shows up at the sale. After making some snide comments about the decor, she then offers to buy the father's favorite leather easy chair for only a fraction of what it was worth. The widow and her daughter reluctantly part with the chair which wasn't originally tagged for sale.

Was the above review useful to you?

Add another review

Related Links

Plot summary Ratings Plot keywords
Main details Your user reviews Your vote history