(1935)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
For once, Leon isn't a bad husband....but a thoughtful one.
planktonrules22 February 2021
In most of Leon Errol's shorts, he plays a carousing husband who is caught or nearly caught by the wife as he chases other women and drinks. Here, however, he actually tries to be a good husband....and is treated every bit as bad as when he's actually been carousing!

When the story begins, Leon (called 'Harry' in this short) sees a friend on the street. The friend soon recommends that Leon buy his wife a surprise gift in order to keep her happy. So, he goes to buy a gift for her. Oddly, his awful mother-in-law sees him in the shop talking with the sales lady and then phones Harry's wife to tell him that he is cheating on her!! Also, as he leaves the store after paying for the umbrella, a guy accuses him of stealing it....and soon cops are chasing him. When he arrives home, the wife physically assaults him and announces they are getting a divorce!! Things only get worse when the wife's lawyer gets involved and when he's hauled in to court for shoplifting!!

The humor in this is watching lawyers abuse and berate Leon...a completely innocent man. I thought this all felt rather mean-spirited and unfunny as it went on way too long. By the time the film was over, the lawyers made him look like a combination Bluebeard, Attila the Hun and Genghis Khan! I also think the whole thing came off as ridiculous and poorly done...and a bit of subtlety would have helped. Overall, a film that is different but not necessarily better from Errol's other shorts.

By the way, it is rather weird how in many of Leon's films (this one included) the wife physically assaults Leon and it's supposed to be hilarious. In one, she gives him two black eyes, in this one she smashes him over the head with an umbrella. I do wonder how all this would have played if Leon had been the one hitting her instead...then or now. I should add that at the end, Leon hits his friend as well.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
When buying a present to get you in trouble, be absent!
mark.waltz12 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This moderately funny Leon Errol two reeler is of course an exaggeration of marital issues of the 1930's, but once again presents him as the husband of a younger woman (Maxine Jennings) whose interfering mother sees him buying a parasol in a gift shop and assumes the worst. The sales lady models it, walking around, and for some reason only sells it to him for a dollar when the price tag is $15. This gets him arrested for pillferring, but somehow he shows up with it at home anyway, causing her to accuse him of adultery and then file for divorce.

On the stand, he gets the third degree by a ruthless attorney (whose efforts to discredit him) are ridiculously over the top. Errol is presented to the court as a drunk, wife beater (having only saved his wife from choking by hitting her on the back), an ex-con (literally named a public enemy) and entering the court with a lethal weapon (in this case a simple pen knife). What is essentially a revamp of the "Pay the $2 sketch" had me with more eye rolls than laughs, but I couldn't help but feel sorry for Errol, showing that well-meaning people always end up unlucky, and in this case, that unlucky number is a double 13.

On a casting note, Dot Farley is the only other actress credited in this short, but is it as the interfering, trouble making mother-in-law, the attorney secretary or the sales girl?
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed