IMDb > Romance de Paris (1941) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
Romance de Paris More at IMDbPro »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 2 reviews in total 

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

For Charles Trenet's fans

Author: dbdumonteil
2 March 2006

Even for people who are not exactly from his generation,Trenet commands respect.He was certainly fascinating and one of his songs , "la mer" (the sea) was translated into so many languages it became a perennial.

"Romance de Paris'" is a musical ,since Trenet sings five or six tune ,the title tune twice,the first time on the streets with three buskers ,and the second one as a grand finale on stage .The screenplay is not very interesting ;Edith Piaf's " étoile sans lumière" had a much better script and it predated that of "Singing in the rain" at that!

Trenet portrays a working class young man whose longing is to become a great singer.His mother (Sylvie ,in a part unworthy of the great thespian) does not want him to become an artist cause his father...And his sister has dangerous liaisons.And she cannot see the love and tenderness Trenet's pal (Jean Tissier) feels for her.And Trenet's girlfriend does not want to marry an artist!

As for Jean Boyer ,you'd better pick his "circonstances atténuantes" (1939) where Arletty and Michel Simon sang " Comme de Bien Entendu" ,except if you are a Trenet fan of course!

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

A mesmerising musical a la francaise

Author: (jameswtravers@netscapeonline.co.uk) from London
22 July 2001

Georges Gauthier is an ordinary working class young man who lives with his mother and sister but who dreams of becoming a professional singer. His dreams are dashed when his sister elopes with her boyfriend, leaving him to look after his mother. Then he gets an audition at his local music hall. Impressed, the director engages him and Georges embarks on a successful career, under the name "Papillon". Fearing that his fame and success will upset his mother, his girlfriend and his best friend Jules, Georges must keep his singing career a secret - but for how long...?

One of the most famous and best-loved of French film musicals, Romance de Paris is probably the closest that French cinema managed to get to recreating the glamour and charm of the traditional Hollywood musical of the 1930s and 40s. It was directed by Jean Boyer, the best (if not the only) French director of the genre. The film musical is not well represented in French cinema-lack of popular appeal for the genre meant that there was never going to be the funds to compete with the Hollywood films which starred the likes of Fred Astaire and Gene Kelly. However, the few musical films which were made in France, mostly in the 1940s, are generally well made and have a whimsical Gallic appeal.

With its enchanting airs and loveable characters, Romance de Paris is one of the most uplifting and enchanting films made in France in the 1940s. This is quite remarkable when you consider that it was made during France's darkest hour (during the first year of Nazi occupation). It is a good example of the light, diverting kind of film which was popular with the French nation during this bleak period. The film's popularity was heightened by giving top billing to Charles Trenet, a stroke of genius as it turns out.

The ginger-haired, blue-eyed Trenet, the "fou chantant" was among the most popular of singers at the time and today has an international reputation as one of the great entertainers of the Twentieth Century. Romance de Paris is one of the few films Trenet starred in, probably his best. He is both convincing and enthralling as the typical working class lad who has a lucky break and who is not corrupted by his success, a latter day fairy tale which, despite its naïve simplicity has genuine warmth. It is interesting to note how close his character in the film resembles the real-life Trenet - both being passionate about music, both respecting the bonds of friendship and family, both shunning needless publicity. To a very good approximation, Charles Trenet and Georges Gauthier are one in the same person.

Although he is clearly the star of the film, Trenet works well with his co-stars particularly Jean Tissier and Sylvie, who play respectively Trenet's friend and mother in the film. The three lead characters have a pleasing rapport, and Tissier's performance is very nearly as entertaining as Trenet's.

Although perhaps overshadowed by the monumental, more sober films which were made at the time, Romance de Paris deserves its place in French cinematic history. With its ceaseless optimism, it served as a cheerful antidote to the penury of everyday life, a distraction from the grotesque business of war. It is no less effective when watched today, a testament to the genius of Jean Boyer and Charles Trenet.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Plot summary Ratings Main details
Your user reviews Your vote history