IMDb > The Mad Hatter (1940) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
The Mad Hatter More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 2 reviews in total 

Especially Enjoyed The Hat Designers

9/10
Author: richard.fuller1
23 November 2013

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Sometimes I really enjoy these less exaggerated human characters, not so much in the form of Elmer or Yosemite Sam, but natural looking, then engaging in the ridiculous antics. Such was the case here, especially in Maisie's running to catch the bus and sitting at her desk reading all day, eating chocolates, and her hearty lunch which was an ice cream sundae.

The makeup job didn't stay bad, and the joke was just making fun of women who do wear too much makeup, which we see even today.

But the subtlety of the joke about crazy people in padded cells making women's hats was very amusing.

Strange to think this idea would have been better done by Disney or WB, but they probably didn't consider an entire cartoon about hats at random to be worth touching.

As it turned out, it was. And very well done here.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 8 people found the following review useful:

Perils of realism in a mediocre cartoon

Author: lor_ from New York, New York
19 May 2011

Animation is an art form, perhaps more popular than ever today thanks to the creativity of new styles like the Pixar approach, that thrives on the fantastic. With MAD HATTER this typical theatrical program filler is far too steeped in reality, especially considering that the audience went to movies to escape.

Sid Marcus, an animator whose career evolved into directing Pink Panther cartoons and later forgettable TV episodes, does a prosaic job limning the travails of Maisie, a well-named Ann Sothern type whose daily routine is just that, routine.

Featuring all human characters, normal situations merely exaggerated for effect, and in fact a mean-spirited presentation, this forgotten short emerges as anti-entertainment. Quite frankly, I would have appreciated a (precursor of course back in 1940) noir or even neo-Realist approach to animation if one was interested in a dreary cartoon. In fact, an animated spoof of the great Italian classics of the late '40s like SHOESHINE, BICYCLE THIEF or PATH OF HOPE would be quite amusing.

The nastiest (and most pointless) scene here comes early on when Maisie, late for work, slaps on her makeup and looks more like Emmett Kelly than a normal girl. It's a pure case of making fun of her -wanting the audience to laugh at her as a figure of ridicule. Starting from Betty Boop on through Jessica Rabbit, the fans want and deserve beauty and alluring female characters -Marcus missed the boat.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Plot summary Ratings External reviews
Plot keywords Main details Your user reviews
Your vote history