(at around 59 mins) Just as Karla and Julie enter the room where the tanning bed is, Karla says, "Come on Julie it's better than a day at the beach girl," yet her mouth does not move until the next shot.
(at around 1h 5 mins) After Julia explains about what happened two summers ago and that she didn't want to drag anybody else into it. Karla mouths, "It's too late for that now," but all we actually hear is, "It's too late for that..."
At the end there is a tombstone that says "Julie 1998" which is wrong because although the movie was released in 98 the actual characters should of been living in 1999 or later, because the beginning of part one takes place in 1997 (at the pageant they say it's 1997) then one yr later (98) the killer returns to seek revenge, part one ends... THEN it's at least 1-2 yrs later before part 2 takes place.
(at around 34 mins) At the bar, Nancy says, "What you guys want is a Dark and Stormy." She then lists the ingredients as "Vernon's rum, a little ginger beer, a splash of Tabasco". This is not a Dark 'N' Stormy. A Dark 'n' Stormy is a highball cocktail made with Gosling's Black Seal rum (the dark) and ginger beer (the stormy) served over ice and garnished with a slice of lime. The name "Dark N Stormy" and the corresponding recipe is a trademark of Gosling's Brothers Ltd.
When Willis pulls out his hook to kill someone, it makes the stereotypical sound of metal against metal. However, the hook would need to be sheathed to make such a sound; furthermore, a curved hook is unable to be sheathed to make such a sound.
(at around 16 mins) In the film, Karla Wilson wins a radio contest after answering "Rio de Janeiro" to the question "What is the capital of Brazil?" The capital of Brazil since April 21, 1960 is Brasilia, not Rio de Janeiro. (Rio de Janeiro served as the capital city from 1763 to April 21, 1960 when the capital status was officially relocated to Brasilia.) But this is explained later in the film (at around 1h 9 mins) that no matter what answer she gave she would have won regardless if it was right or wrong as the trip was a set-up.
As Julie and her group arrive, the hotel grounds are brimming with other guests. However, when they check in and encounter the hotel manager seconds later, and when Ben Willis arrives and starts killing, the hotel is totally deserted leaving us only with the main characters. Apart from the fact that all other hotel guests seem to have vanished in an instance, it also is highly implausible that even during 'off season' there wouldn't be at least a few guests left. Surely Ben Willis didn't just kill everybody off?
(at around 32 mins) When Ray is in hospital and his ECG flat-lines everyone panics thinking that he's dying when in fact he's unhooked himself and jumped out the window. ECG monitors have a warning message on the screen similar to "Leads Off" to indicate that the leads are not longer on the patient avoiding panic like it caused in the film.