Un frère (1997)

User Rating:

6.2/10   

Director:

Sylvie Verheyde

Writer:

Sylvie Verheyde (writer)

Release Date:

26 November 1997 (France)

Awards:

2 wins & 2 nominations

Cast

Jeannick Gravelines	...	Loic
Emma de Caunes	...	Sophie
Nils Tavernier	...	Vincent
Emmanuel Nicolas	...	Tony
Ann-Gisel Glass	...	Cristelle
rest of cast listed alphabetically:
Jean-Philippe Baltel	...	Pierre
Serge-Robert Bedrines	...	André
Mustafa Benia	...	Karim
Aurélie Berrier	...	Vero
Hélène Delpuech	...	Le grand-mère
Roselyne Delpuech	...	Mother
Jean-Marc Fiess	...	Rapha
Fahrni Gabteni	...	Abdul
Cyrille Hertel	...	Le type costaud 1
Frédérique Lopez	...	Fille fan
Katerina Mechera	...	Brenda
Manu Nicolas	...	Nicolas
Christophe Pasquier	...	Alex
Christian Portron	...	Alain
Thierry Revel	...	Gérard Dahan
Marie Riva	...	Grande fille bariolée
Karole Rocher	...	Virgine
Xavier Russel	...	Léo
Anthony Souter	...	Le moustachu
Philippe van Herwijnen	...	Le type costaud 2

Also Known As:

Brother

Runtime:

100 min

Country:

France

Language:

French

Color:

Color

Certification:

Singapore:R(A)

Company:

Persona Films

Glossy angst (possible spoiler)

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

Loic and Sophie are siblings living with their mother in a block of flats. The impetuous, promiscuous Loic is a talented photographer about to make it to the big time, but being pulled back by loyalty to his best friend and ex-lover, both junkies. Sophie, a schoolgirl on holidays, is quietly undergoing a sexual awakening, observing from a distance Loic's milieu; she begins an affair with his business partner to Loic's quasi-incestuous disapproval. Loic is spotted by a prominent editor, but becomes increasingly unhinged, by his friend's violent struggles with dealers, by his lover's demands, by Sophie's 'betrayal', by his own 'demons'. Tragedy inevitably strikes.

The final move of the film into the country, wide open spaces, 'natural' light is, if not cathartic for the characters, a release for the viewer after a film whose overriding metaphor is the urban labyrinth. Characters are trapped, not only in their own personalities and in destructive relationships and loyalties, but in the city, in poky flats with tiny bedrooms, in fenced parks, in crammed nightclubs. Even outdoor scenes play like a massive maze, as characters are cornered, or run away from trouble.

By focusing on a 'youthful' subject matter, this film is particularly difficult to understand and follow, such is the profusion of slang. I don't know how authentic or otherwise this is, but the difficulty of comprehension is crucial, because slang is a way of belonging to a certain group, keeping distant from the outside world, because this is a film concerned with characters who want to belong to something or other, but are held back by outside pressures.

This is visualised in the structure of the film, which begins with a series of doubles (brother/sister; friend/friend; lover/lover; artist/partner etc.), trying to extend into triangles, to fatal effect, rather like Sartre's 'Huis Clos', where any relation between two of the trapped characters is foiled by malevolent third - hell is other people. The film can't really find a way out of this impasse - it closes with another triangle, an escape from the labyrinth, but the last grouping is the brother and the sister, suggesting a retreat, an admission of failure to engage with the outside world, as much as of reconciliation, when the characters seem to be reaching out for freedom.

As one might expect from a 'youth' movie, the acting is as self-conscious as the dialogue, but new actress Emma de Caunes (daughter of Antoine) is lovely as the quiet, spiky, Celine-reading teenager coming to terms with her sexuality, under threat from within her own family - her private dancing has the air of sacred rite. The dramatising of male angst is much less convincing, and strays close to self-pity, even parody. The direction, however, puts paid to any emotional response - smothering its traumas in a golden glow, it seems to take its visual cue from its photographer hero. Every shot is as smoothly framed and lit, every movement is as smoothly choreographed as an advertisement, which makes the drugs subplot rather hard to take.