IMDb > Children of Heaven (1997) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb
Bacheha-Ye aseman
Quicklinks
Top Links
trailers and videosfull cast and crewtriviaofficial sitesmemorable quotes
Overview
main detailscombined detailsfull cast and crewcompany credits
Awards & Reviews
user reviewsexternal reviewsawardsuser ratingsparents guide
Plot & Quotes
plot summarysynopsisplot keywordsmemorable quotes
Did You Know?
triviagoofssoundtrack listingcrazy creditsalternate versionsmovie connectionsFAQ
Other Info
box office/businessrelease datesfilming locationstechnical specsliterature listingsNewsDesk
Promotional
taglines trailers and videos posters photo gallery
External Links
showtimesofficial sitesmiscellaneousphotographssound clipsvideo clips

Reviews & Ratings for
Children of Heaven More at IMDbPro »Bacheha-Ye aseman (original title)

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Page 8 of 14: [Prev][3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [Next]
Index 137 reviews in total 

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

An emotional display of humanity and optimism.

10/10
Author: manendra-lodhi (manendra.lodhi@gmail.com) from India
16 July 2012

This is one of those rare films which teach people as how to live their lives with optimism. I was amazed at the innocence of the children. The film portrays the poor life of people which definitely is not a new subject but the way it has been shown is definitely superb. Once after 20 minutes when I understood what the film would be about, I was astounded at the marvelous script. What makes this film superb is the fact that it is explores the nature of humans. All other things related to the film are simple but the characters are the fuel for the film which makes it the favorite for many. Human emotions are portrayed at their best. The acting by the cast has to be applauded. But the backbone of the film is two cute and innocent kids and a beautiful script. In my opinion the film teaches a lot of things with love as a sweetener. It conveys a lot of important messages. One important message imbibed in it is to never lose faith even when there are a lot of problems. I have always liked films which are on the path of changing the attitude of the people in the world. Because every character in the film is shown kind hearted and that is a positive wave missing these days in people. One such film was Kiki's Delivery Service, which also portrayed human struggle but also has shown that people in the world are not bad. To me, films like these are revolutionary and help in generating faith in people when everything is lost. The film is one of my favorite now.

"A must watch for everyone regardless of anything."

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Simply Powerful and Classic!!!

Author: Venkatraman J from India
29 June 2012

The movie starts with a cobbler mending a pair of shoes and this goes on for about a good 3 minutes. One wonders why the director would choose to show something like this for 3 mins. But this gave me a sense of assurance that I am gonna watch a gripping and a solid movie. And yes, it was more than what I'd expected. This is one movie that I don't miss mentioning in any discussion about movies among friends.

The movie's beauty is in its details, the mood set for the plot, the simplicity of its narration, the characterization and of course the performances. The story is simply this. Bro loses the pair of shoes of his kid sis. Disappointed sis agrees to share the pair of bro's sneakers fearing their father's reaction to the lost shoes / empathizing with father's helpless financial situation. Rest of the movie is just about how they manage with one pair of sneakers.

The movie would have been half as decent without the details delved in to in some of the simpler things - right from showing a typical day in the life of the boy, details of how impoverished the family is and the several hints / dialogues pointing to that, sis chasing a sneaker that fell in the gutter, camera tracking the sis and bro all the way from and to school every day showing the busy streets, the distance, etc., the sis looking at the shoes worn by other students during the prayer session at school and her mental preoccupation with the shoes while other kids have fun playing around. The director has taken every possible effort to totally impress upon the viewer a few things - the family's financial situation, the kids' camaraderie and their respect and love for each other, their ability to empathize and manage. Any shortfall in impressing these premises would have just not lead to such an impact from the movie.

About the performances. The kids' expressions speak volumes!! Right number of dialogues fitting the innocence and responsible nature of the kids. Emotions have been dealt with absolute clinical precision. Right mix of innocence, subservience, love, anger, empathy, frustration, etc. The change of moods in a split second whenever the kids' discuss the pair of shoes just brings goosebumps and tears. There are many occasions when the sis loses her temper over the bro for having lost her shoes and warns him about complaining to their dad. She however holds high regards for her bro (which she displays beautifully) and listens to him on why she should not do that. From fury it gradually mellows down to anger-with-respect to frustration to helplessness and to childish joy from reassuring comfort provided by bro. All in 1-2 mins. Any more or less dialogues than what they are would have just screwed it all up.

Background score does its bit judicially. It supports the screenplay and performances by not distracting the viewers with music everywhere just for the heck of it. Background is more of sounds of the world around.

Overall a must watch for every movie connoisseur and particularly for those who love family drama genre. Movies that come close in terms of impact created and brilliance in film making are bicycle thief, life is beautiful, pursuit of happiness, hachiko, shwaas (marathi), kanchivaram (tamil) and parts of colour of paradise (from the same director as children of heaven). I'd rate this 10 on any day!! Very glad I watched this movie.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Beautiful story

9/10
Author: billcr12 from United States
14 May 2012

Ali is sent to pick up his sister's shoes from a repair shop and when he puts them down while at a produce stand, a garbage man picks them up and throws them away. The boy frantically searches for the shoes with no luck, and so he asks his sibling, Zahra, not to tell their parent's because they are very poor, even being several months behind in their rent.

The kids devise a scheme to share Ali's pair of Converse, with the two alternating school classes between mornings and afternoons. He is late because of the trade off in an alley and his principal warns him to be on time.

Ali's father, desperate for money, takes his son along with gardening tools to a wealthy neighborhood, looking for work. They find a mansion and the owner's grandson plays with Ali as his father landscapes. On their way home, they fall off their bike and are slightly injured.

Ali hears of a race with one of the prizes being a new pair of sneakers, so he decides to run in order to win the footwear for his sister. The ending is charming and so are the the two kids who play the brother and sister. Children of Heaven is proof that a big budget is not needed to make a great film.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Bondage

8/10
Author: shouvik_mcet from India
16 January 2012

The most amazing thing which I found about this movie was it was just based on a pair of shoes which a boy named Ali loses it unfortunately. With that simple base, a master piece has been created by Majid Majidi. Emotions depicted to its best. The depth of love and understanding between brother and sister has been portrayed perfectly. The blend of comedy in between the hard fought life of Ali's family was more than welcome. You very easily get reminded of your childhood memories which binds you more to the movie. Though being kids, they have acted to perfection. A very simple but a beautiful movie to watch and would suggest other users to watch as well.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

tears in my eyes and smile in my face

9/10
Author: clone-cloak from Nepal
13 January 2011

Relationship between brother and sister portrayed like a Da Vinci painting. This movie is a piece of gem and I recommend it to everybody who love a story about relationships and hardships. The kids are perfect in their respective roles and the movie itself is as close to reality as it can be. Human innocence is perfectly shown through the children by artist of an director. Hats off to Majid Majidi for writing it and then directing it to perfection. The movie shows how simple things in life can change us as human beings and how a desire the grows from the depths of a pure heart can change us as an individual.

I recommend this movie to those who love a story that reflects life as it is.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Made me smile from start to finish

9/10
Author: Tweekums from United Kingdom
9 December 2009

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

Until a fortnight ago I'd never seen an Iranian film and assumed any film from their would just be religious or political propaganda... perhaps there are films like that but having just watched this film and "Offside" it is clear that they also make fantastic character based films that are a delight to watch.

On the face of it a film about a poor boy losing his sister's only pair of shoes doesn't sound the basis for a film that is both interesting and a joy to watch but it works. With his mother too ill to work and his father in a low paid job young Ali promises his sister Zahra that he will get her shoes back if she doesn't tell their parents about the loss. When he fails to find them he offers to share his own footwear; an old pair of trainers. This means that as soon as her school is over Zahra must run through the narrow back streets to get the shoes to Ali so he can go to his school, even though he runs he is slightly late each day and is getting in trouble.

Director Majid Majidi did a great job getting such natural performances from his two stars, both of whom were young children. It is surprising that the children didn't go on to star in further films as they were both a joy to watch and made the viewer really care for their plight. The film might sound a bit boring and depressing but it isn't, there are a few sad scenes but for the most part it is a film that had me smiling from start to finish, I'll have to look out for more films from Iran.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Perfect Family Film

8/10
Author: EXodus25X from United States
19 July 2008

From Iran comes a wonderfully unique and family friendly film. Unique in the portrayals of it's children characters, children who act and feel like real children. Their acting is great and their emotions pull you right along with them. This film is a great example of simple storytelling that works in a grand way. This would be a great film for younger kids to see, much better for them and their young minds then some of the Hollywood trash that's pumped into their face. The subtitles are relatively easy to read and the story is simple and easy to follow. The camera work gives you a great feel for the area of Iran and it's people at the time. All said a unique and original film and in all the right ways.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Incredibly Good!!

9/10
Author: Gaurav Srivastava from India
11 April 2007

Innocence and purity are the words that come to your mind after you have watched this movie. I got this movie from my local DVD library(God knows how they had such a masterpiece) and just to bide my time stared watching this movie. But what started as an innocuous plot finally turned out to be one of best movies I have ever watched. The story evolves around the brother and sister Ali and Zara.A bolt of bad luck causes Ali to loose Zaara's shoes, therefore the kids come up with a plan to share the only pair of sneakers that they have. What follows is then a heart warming tale of brother and sister trying there best to cope up with the situations that crop up and in the mean time keeping there secret. The plot of the movie is quite simple but is full of beautiful moments. These moments become more beautiful because of the great acting by the lead pair of brother and sister. Both the children have done extremely good acting and this itself is a tribute to the director of this movie. This movie is like a new born child, as you go along the movie you start sharing there emotions, feeling bad for there misfortune and hoping internally that everything turns out fine with them. The movie is full of positive energy and watching this movie leaves u with a hopeful and enthusiastic state of mind and heart. One other good aspect of this movie is the way in which it showcases Iran's culture. It shows quite boldly that Iran and other Arab countries are not just about Mullahs and hardliners and the people there are no different from the rest of the world. They also essentially share the same spirit of humanity. Overall a great movie and must watch for any avid cinema follower.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Beautiful Poetic Imagery

9/10
Author: iterlongum from United States
5 March 2007

Children of Heaven is a simple movie, but creative in its imagery and symbolism. The story is about a boy who loses his sister's shoes and his fierce determination to get his sister a replacement pair. The most poignant scene that illustrates the boy's desire to help his sister and bring her comfort is shown in the marathon race around the lake in a modern downtown city in Iran.

Ali enters a marathon race to win third prize, which is a new pair of sneakers, for his sister, Zahra. The race begins and Ali is in the middle of a pack of boys, all around his age. A few times, Ali trips and falls to the ground, causing him to fall behind the other boys in the race, losing his place. Every time he falls down, he picks himself back up with a look of fierce determination on his face and charges back into the race. He is breathing heavily and fatigue begins to show on his face, but he only thinks of his sister and his promise to get her a new pair of shoes. This show of fierce family loyalty is so moving, especially from one so young.

All around him there are birds chirping and trees moving past him, with a large lake behind Ali in every take. This reference to a garden, water, and Ali's promise are striking allusions to the Islamic religion on which this movie is based. The lake is an Islamic symbol for purification, alms, and the Will of God. Water is an unstoppable force that cannot be avoided just as God is an unstoppable force that is always affecting man's everyday lives. The trees and the sound of the birds singing is another allusion to God through nature. This nature is a representation of the Garden of Eden from which all of mankind derived and will one day re-enter.

This movie ties together to Islamic tradition of family helping one another in times of need and the will and power of God in their everyday lives. This is definitely a movie worth seeing if you love simple and beautiful imagery, straightforward story line, and the determination of man to overcome adversity.

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

The Portrayal of Poverty

9/10
Author: Brendan Jeffrey from United States
14 February 2007

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

This film was something very different for me to view. Coming from an American movie watcher's point of view this movie had a very stark contrast to the usual films that I would see at movie theaters. This wasn't a bad thing it made the film that much more interesting because of the way the story was portrayed.

The basic plot revolves around a pair of shoes. These are the shoes of Zahra the sister of, and one of the main characters, Ali. After Ali has these shoes repaired he ends up losing them because a trash collector, thinking that they were garbage, picks them up. Throughout the movie Ali attempts to track down the shoes while having to share his shoes with Zahra. Their father cannot afford new shoes because they live in poverty. It is very interesting to see what happens while searching for the shoes.

This plot may seem kind of boring, but it the film took this seemingly boring story and actually made it very interesting, even for an American Audience base. Some of this was due in part to the mystery surrounding the whereabouts of the shoes. There was quite a bit of symbolism throughout the entire film. The idea that anytime water is flowing, or you see water, signifies the Will of God or just God himself comes to mind in the context of the Muslim faith. The Muslim faith believes that water symbolizes God and the Will of God. The way the film shoots the water scenes show that it is the will of God to not regain the shoes and in the end to accept that they have been lost. No matter how the children attempt to fight this it keeps coming back to them in new forms. Ali signifies rising up against injustice and even he, the one who will take a stand against oppression, cannot fight the Will of God.

The actors portrayed the roles very well. Even being children, without much acting experience, you believe the portrayal. Also the way in which the film was edited made it seem a bit slower than American films. As well as the camera work and lighting, the film had a feeling of poverty and being in the busy city while the characters sometimes felt out of place.

In the end Children of Heaven is a film which is something that most Americans may not understand, unless given some background. That set aside it is a very good movie. Without some cultural knowledge people may miss some of the symbolism, but the story will still come through to the people who aren't as cultured. The film portrays the struggles of poverty and everyday city life in Iran and puts the world in context. A pair of shoes is more important to these children than being to school on time, looking fashionable or even winning. Something that Americans would find to be trash is something that is cherished and loved by these children.

Was the above review useful to you?


Page 8 of 14: [Prev][3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [Next]

Add another review


Related Links

Plot summary Plot synopsis Ratings
Awards External reviews Parents Guide
Official site Plot keywords Main details
Your user reviews Your vote history