Sacred Silence (1996) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The priest
jotix10025 July 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Father Lorenzo Borrelli's church is located in the Sanita quarter of Naples, one of the worst neighborhood in the city. Father Borrelli has seen enough death among the young people that are recruited by the Camorra, the local mafia, that is behind most of the crimes committed in Naples. This righteous man's voice speaks against all the injustices he sees stemming from the evil doings of the Camorra, yet Father Lorenzo is a man that hides a dark secret in his heart: he is gay and a pedophile.

Into this milieu arrives Nunzio Pianese, a young boy in Father Lorenzo's confirmation class. Nunzio, himself, is a young man that is different from the other hoodlums running around in this dangerous part of Naples. Nunzio, who has a beautiful voice, is seen as he sings for one of the local stations; he loves interpreting those romantic ballads that are so Neapolitan.

Perhaps it's inevitable that Lorenzo and Nunzio will become lovers. After all, Lorenzo has had another long term affair with the handsome Gigi, who is older now. Gigi must see in Nunzio what he went through during the times he had sex with the priest. At the same time, Father Lorenzo is never seen threatening Nunzio, as it appears their relationship is mutual.

The Camorra wants to get to Father Lorenzo in any way it can. They choose to work through Nunzio because the young man is vulnerable where the priest is resolute. The priest has two strikes against him, he is opposing the local mafia, plus his homosexuality, if known, will certainly destroy his reputation, and it will mean the bad guys have won the struggle while they sideline their opponent.

Antonio Capuano directed and wrote the screen play of this film. He uses a ploy to have the different characters in the movie introduce themselves giving us, the viewers, a bit of information as to where, and when they were born. This aspect doesn't do much to advance the story, something we found a bit distracting.

The acting in general, by non professional actors, fits the movie well. Mr. Capuando sets the action for his film in the streets of the Sanita district. Fabrizio Bentivoglio, is basically the only known face in the large cast. Mr. Bentivoglio shows a great range, as he becomes furious against the Camorra, to a tender side one sees when he is in the company of Nunzio, who he evidently adores passionately. His scenes with Nunzio show a restraint that speaks volumes about the director of the film, Antonio Capuano, who decided not to go for cheap shots. Emanuele Gargiulo is seen as the sweet Nunzio.

Antonio Capuano directed the film with an eye for detail, something that his cinematographer, Antonio Baldoni, captured Naples seamy side in all its splendor. Mr. Capuano makes us think about the role of this priest and his church in our society and how a gay man has to live in order to conform to its unspoken rules that discriminate men like Lorenzo to hide behind his role as a priest.
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Priest as a Villain and Hero
Havan_IronOak23 July 2001
In Naples a priest begins a campaign against the Camorra. He's particularly vulnerable in that he has a "relationship" with 13-year-old Nunzio an alter boy, semi orphan and talented singer.

The priest in this film is both a hero in his fight against the Camorro and a villain in his abuse or molestation of Nunzio. Lest the priest be too sympathetic a character there is Gigi an older boy who apparently was the priest's last protégé who appears at the beginning of the film and complains that the priest doesn't seem to have time for him anymore. `Things change' he's told.

The audience is left to judge for themselves as the priest seems to harbor no guilt about his actions and the boy says that he enjoyed the affection. This is another of those films that deal with morality at the uncomfortable border between what is rightfully the business of a society and what is better left as a private matter between consenting partners.
18 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Big Disappointment italian Movie!
javierubio29 June 2020
This type of film that begins in a way in all places and ends without any fixed concept only the theme of an adult being (The priest) who falls in love with an altar boy of 13 years and honestly the way this story was presented was Too subjective with a lot of information from all sides and without any specific message. Until the end it was without substance or I could not understand why this Director wanted to present a topic as controversial as this and in the way he did. It is a shame because I have seen other Italian movies with very good directors
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
mutual consent
boyzmi11 January 2006
While most of the above comments pretty much describe the film, I saw one thing though, that I don't agree with. I didn't see the priest as molesting the very handsome Nunzio. They seemed to have a mutually consensual relationship. The boy went to the priests room, and is seen "flirting" with the priest at dinner. While Nunzio had a young girl friend, and spoke with friends about girls, he also seemed to care for the priest, and never tried to turn down the advances. The fact that he was not ready to cooperate with the investigation on the priest also shows me his concern for their relationship. The city street scenes and music I thought all lent to the validity of the time and place in the film. Even if the subject matter is not to ones liking, it is still an interesting film for the scenes, music, and other personalities in the film.
21 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Controversial movie about love, abuse and society.
ninoguapo11 December 2005
Sacret Silence is shoot in an unique way as many of the characters talk directly to the viewer. It almost seems that as if nothing else is happening around them – and it is only you they want to share their troughs with. This method adds a documentary atmosphere to the movie, which I believe will be appreciated by everyone who likes the serious European cinema.

Sacret Silence is a movie about society and the way it can be blinded by its own perceptions or by people who want the others to see the world through their eyes and refuse to accept that there are other ways to think about an issue than their own.. That is why the priest is fighting with Camorra (the mafia ) – it is just that sometimes in life there is more to loose than to win.

Traditional Italian songs are used for the soundtrack of Sacret Silence; most of them are performed by the 13-year-old Nunzio. I come to appreciate this music as it is evident that he feels the music – just look at his facial expression while he is singing.

The movie focuses on a whole range of moral issues. The relationship between the priest and Nunzio is only one of them – at first I thought that I can understand the priest – his love for Nunzio, but at the same time his past is flashing through the eyes of the other boy who comes to visit him – and this past seems to be disturbing.Yet another issue is to be able to decide for yourself who is committing the biggest crime in this movie – it is the priest , or the mafia or may be as often happens these days the crime committer is the police itself ?
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A very, very Italian film
cmmescalona9 August 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Others have the spoilers already, so I'll try to make this a different thing: Nunzio is almost fourteen and really handsome. He sings for TV and a record company. He plays the organ at the local parish. He's the current lover of Father Lorenzo.

Lorenzo is a priest that fights the Camorra. He opens the doors of his church for the ones who need it.

The Sanità neighbourhood is as violent as it comes.

Naples is under siege by the same kind of violence the Camorra has always been praised for... the southern version of the Mafia.

Capuano, who wrote and directed this and his previous film, does an amazing job. Each character has the depth needed to understand the surroundings and the sad situation of a troubled neighbourhood in one of the world's most controversial cities.

He shows the power of many things that are not a standard for us, and maybe because of that, we don't understand. Examples of his Latin creativity and point of view, are the silent scenes that were shot hand-held where most of the murders are shown. The delicate way of portraying a difficult subject. The utter precision and realism of Catholic rituals with his own amendments.

The underlying truth of life in Naples through brief but poignant phrases. The political situation that still runs in Naepolitan life. The words used in the songs Nunzio sings. The terribly painful reality of lives that struggle with everyday life where the "bosses" roam seldom leaving society unscathed.

The really peaceful moments you can rob Naples just walking a few blocks away from downtown knowing that the sea is for you.

The switching from dialect to language on the fly when you have both parties at the same table. The small talk on coffee as is in real life, everyday in Naples... and the bursting city that is always on the brink of something, under the clouds of mighty Vesubius.

A film which stares inside the people who know the main character. All in all, a very Italian film with a lot to learn from. Don't miss the rest of Capuano's films!
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Refreshing portrayal
ricrisci14 August 2011
This is the very timely story of the relationship between a priest and a teen who wants to be one in modern day Naples. It is portrayed as a pure, honest, innocent relationship on the part of both.

While most of the people close to either of them are aware of the relationship after Nunzio moves into the church, it is refreshing to see how they treat it in an almost matter-of-fact manner. There is some minor ribbing by some acquaintances but nothing like the mean-spirited harsh torture a boy in modern America who willingly participated would be subjected to.

When Fr. Borelli refuses to compromise his morals and silence his campaign against the camorristas (mafia), a campaign is launched to have the boy denounce him.

This is one of the most sympathetic portrayals (better than L.I.E., up there with Man Without a Face) ever shown on screen, and is also commendable as showing how social workers and those in one's environment can pressure youths into denouncing even those seen as close friends. An important film in its genre. 9 Caution: explicit scenes but no full frontal nudity.

DATE: 2002-07-18 " - ricrisci
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Intergenerational relationships cannot be compared with child abuse.
dsangari27 November 2009
Warning: Spoilers
For Gods sake, The priest is not a child molester! Why does everyone keep saying that? When two people have consensual sex, morality does not come into it. I don't get this whole new hatred and paranoia if two inter-generational lover decide to express their desires sexually? All love is the same, emotional blackmail, games and little tiffs are always involved, whether one partner is 13 or 33, does not in the end matter so much. Upon seeing this film I felt that the priest had some admirable traits and was basically a good Samaritan caught up in a web of politics and mafia. When his enemies chance upon his sexual preference (and the fact that he as a catholic priest had sex)they use it as a tool to sideline and destroy his reputation. I felt that the film, far from being some moral conundrum is actually a good attempt at showing the hypocrisy of the times we live in. One thing though, the acting (having been done by obvious non-pros) is about average.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Gritty, documentary quality
sergepesic16 June 2008
Warning: Spoilers
"Sacred silence" reminds me of grainy, gritty black and white neo-realist Italian movies of the 1950' and 60'. It has the same natural, almost documentary quality, like filming life itself. The people in this movie are hardened, with worn and deeply lined faces. Their lives are nothing but hard work and barely getting by. Even the hero of this story, priest with courage to fight the gangs of Napoli is a sinner. He manipulates Nunzio, the 13-year old with the soul of 25-year old, into sexual relationship. This movie dares to tell us a story about a child molester who has some admirable qualities. He isn't just some devious animal who corrupts the innocents, but he is much more complex, as most of human beings are. In the end you feel morally appalled by his actions and in the recesses of your soul even little sorry for him. Brave and powerful movie that clings to us long after we've seen it.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed