Die Gebrüder Skladanowsky (1995)

User Rating:

6.4/10   

Director:

Wim Wenders

Release Date:

28 November 1995 (Germany)

Genre:

Biography | Drama

Plot:

A rare gem of cinematic storytelling that weaves docudrama, fictional reenactment, and experimental photography into a powerful...

Awards:

1 win

Cast

Nadine Buettner	...	Gertrud Skladanowsky
Lucie Hürtgen-Skladanowsky
George Inci	...	Russian dancer
Udo Kier	...	Max Skladanowsky
Otto Kuhnle	...	Emil Skladanowsky
Bodo Werner Lang	...	Postman
Christoph Merg	...	Eugen Skladanowsky
Alfred Sczczot
Rüdiger Vogler
Wim Wenders	...	Milkman

Also Known As:

A Trick of Light (International: English title)
A Trick of the Light
Brothers Skladanowsky

Runtime:

79 min

Country:

Germany

Language:

German

Color:

Black and White | Color

Certification:

Brazil:Livre | Finland:K-3

Company:

Hochschule für Fernsehen und Film München (HFF)

Movie Connections:

Features La sortie des usines Lumière (1895)

abstract movement

Wenders amuses himself, and in the way reflects about some general principles of cinema as an art. Several times he has made interesting films that are themselves cinematic objects and reflections on the nature of the cinematic object. His primary concern is the images. Whenever he deepens the complexity of his narratives, he is aiming at highlighting images. Those are the cases of the very recent Palermo Shooting and the remarkable American Friend: images which illustrate a story about images. When he takes out that intelligent narrative, directly sensitive to the medium, we are left with meditations purely based on images. Sometimes they work, sometimes they drag.

Here it half-works, because the project, intentionally, lacks a bigger form other than that of the interview the old Skladanowsky gives. All the black and white bits are built as episodes and inside those episodes we find other episodes (the original Skladanowsky films). Apparently this started as an academic project, so that would explain the lack of a bigger form, as well as the inaptness of some short bits. That does not explain the almost unbearable ending.

But something interested me here. Wenders picks on something left behind almost at the beginning of cinema. Images as abstract motion pictures, detached of narrative. That's something i think is worth some time exploring, and obviously so did Wenders. So, among all the old remakes of the pioneering films, i was interested in the dance bit. Curiously enough, it is the bit which gets more attention even in the child story of the black and white flashbacks. It is the film that has to be remade. The clothing of the dancers help the effect. It's remarkable, how it works in the eye. I've been spending time watching experiences like that. Besides that, there's little else to see here. And i found totally misused the contrast between black and white footage and the color bits of the interview, which had an uncomfortable video look which put me off. The b&w was already grainy and looked old, they didn't need to look for such a contrast to make the point.

My opinion: 3/5

http://www.7eyes.wordpress.com