Cutthroat Island (1995)
The game is based on the movie.
Character thrown overboard shakes fist angrily at ship, swearing revenge if it's the last thing he does
Referenced during the "Viewer's Thumb" segment.
Poster in video shop.
Leslie mentions it among pirate films he has seen.
mentioned in dialogue
sword fight music
DVD is shown.
"I'd hate to think what this scene would look like if it were in the hands of the people behind Cutthroat Island."
Mike Greenberg reads the list of the 8 biggest box office disasters of all time, as listed on Cheatsheet.com in 2013, adjusted for inflation
movie is reviewed
The mission in the pirate-themed level is called "Cutcheese Island"
Parodies the map tattoo idea.