Johnny meets Kate, an NYPD mounted cop, and dates her. But after meeting her family and discovering that her dad and her brothers are also cops, he decides to break it off. But he sees them wherever he goes, he thinks they're stalking him. And Trudy learns from Marie about Cuban bras for sale.
While riding the subway on his way to a Halloween costume party, Jonathan meets the girl of his dreams dressed in a Cinderella costume. Jonathan places an ad in the newspaper and rides the subway to find her again. Russell studies for a law exam.
An artist wants to debut his latest creation which he dubbed "The Virgin" at Trudy's gallery. So she asks Johnny to get it. Russell tries to get together with his girlfriend but can't find a place where he can. When Johnny arrives at the artist's, he is met by a woman. She comes onto him. But Trudy calls telling Johnny, she is the virgin and not to let anyone get to her. But she comes on to Johnny. And the artist arrives to reveal what his plan is.