Incident in a Small Town (1994 TV Movie) User Reviews

The third and final in the series.

[planktonrules · 7/10 · 23 May 2022]

"Incident in a Small Town" is the third and final TV movie in a series starring Walter Matthau and Harry Morgan as Harmon Cobb and Judge Bell...two lawyers who go into practice with each other. "Incident" came out in 1990, "Against Her Will: An Incident in Baltimore" in 1992 and, finally, this film in 1994. All three feature some terrific acting and the movies are set in the 1940s and early 50s and are well worth seeing.

When the story begins, Judge Bell announces that he's going to see his estranged daughter, a woman he hasn't seen in 13 years! When they meet, she is a bit cold towards him and he learns that he has a grandson! As for Cobb, he comes along for support...and ends up defending both the Judge AND the daughter in a murder trial!! What this is all about you'll need to see for yourself.

This is a very good made for TV movie....just not as good as the previous two. The reason I didn't enjoy it quite as much is that the murder mystery took too many twists...to the point where it became increasingly difficult to believe the story. Still, the excellent acting alone make it worth your time.

Someone I used to know.

[mark.waltz · 6/10 · 4 May 2023]

A pictures of his estranged daughter (Stephanie Zimbalist) brings on rare emotion from tough small town judge (Harry Morgan), previously rival to attorney Walter Matthau and now his best friend. Probably his only friend. It's by coincidence manipulated by the teleplay that at that moment, Zimbalist and son Nick Stahl are confronted by the supposedly deceased ex, Stahl's father, David Nerman, who wants to create a relationship with her son, even though Zimbalist insists that he's no good. The illegitimatacy of Stahl is the reason for the estrangement, and Morgan must put aside his judgments when his daughter comes to need him. Soon Nerman is dead and Morgan is on trial for his murder, defended by Matthau.

Not as strong as the others I've seen of the Matthau/Harmon Cobb series, simply because the premise isn't as complex even though both Matthau and Morgan are a terrific team. Even with a twist at the trial, the film is way too predictable and has some far too convenient plot points. Lori Hallier is great as a lady prosecutor, giving the film some feminist touches ahead of their time. Bernard Behrens as the judge in this case is even more irascible than Morgan was when he was the judge which seems sort of manipulative to the audience. Others in the series of other films weren't as soap opera like as this one, dealing with much more serious issues that affected society at large rather than just a family having all of their dirty laundry aired out to be exposed.

You need to have BEEN there!

[johnclark-1 · 10/10 · 19 April 2010]

Ever been in Family Court? I have, more than once.

You need to have been there to appreciate this film, which goes into the complex relationships and differing points of view of the participants in our legal system. What goes on behind the scenes?

You also see why our legal system doesn't work. It has little to do with the subject, the protagonist. In murder trials, they are never there because they're always dead! But they do move the story along. Meanwhile, the antagonists are, really, all the rest of the cast, and we see how they make a lot of money realizing their successful careers (how much is never mentioned, of course.)

Director Del Mann and writer Cindy Myers know their way around this material, and make full use of this knowledge. And it was cast beautifully.

Notice the jealousy and rivalry between the judges, who claim proprietary ownership of "their" courtrooms. Notice the conflicts of interest that infects everything that takes place, especially between the lawyers. They all wear their masks. Here we see judges who become part of the case!

So, watch this film, and LEARN, if you're about to seek a restraining order. I was able to see my own case in a different light because of this film. The principles of Greek drama are fully utilized, and the innocent members of the public will be in for surprises and enlightenment.

You may be left with the feeling, if you reach catharsis, that there must be a better (and not illegal) way to settle family disputes. You will also be left with the resolve to stay away from lawyers, judges, and courts, if you're looking for closure.

Nice TV whodunit movie

[mlazic · 10 January 2004]

The TV film is about man who raped girl and after 13 years comes to see her and son again. The plot is about who killed him, girl's father, known judge, girl herself or son.Walter Mathau is lawyer who is involved in defending them in court.

More Like Incidents is Memorable Drama ****

[edwagreen · 10/10 · 12 December 2010]

Walter Matthau and Harry Morgan made some combination as a lawyer and judge, respectively.

When Morgan's daughter, living in Illinois, calls after a 13 year separation from her father to report that her former beau, the father of their child, is back in town. She had lied to her son stating that he had been killed during World War 11. She never would admit that the boy was conceived via a rape.

When the father is soon killed, Grandpa Morgan is arrested as he had made threats to the guy. As in a domino case, he is soon found to be covering for his daughter. The domino goes on and you will understand if I don't reveal the real killer here.

Matthau still struts that swagger of his when he walks around. Nonetheless, he gives a restrained performance and is equally matched by Morgan, who while older, is as restrained as they come.

Did anyone notice the resemblance between the prosecuting attorney and Hillary Clinton?

Pointless and dull

[bob the moo · 11 December 2005]

Lily and her son John live alone in a small town as her husband has been killed fighting the war in France. Or at least that is what she told John, but the arrival of Frank back in the town leads him to find out that she not only has been lying about that but also about the fact that she never married him. When Frank tussles with Lily in her yard she applies for a restraining order, calling on the help of her father (the esteemed judge Stoddard Bell) and his partner (lawyer Harmon Cobb). The case fails and when Frank is found murdered later that night Stoddard is arrested and Cobb has a defence case on his hands.

I decided to watch this film because I quite like TVM mysteries like Columbo and Perry Mason so I figured this courtroom drama would have some of the good qualities I enjoy; also the cast implied that it must have something going for it. The story appears simple enough and indeed that is just what it is – the "twists" are dull and the whole thing lacks urgency or indeed any tension or interest. The slow pace and country swagger wouldn't have been a problem if the story had had any depth or vale but it didn't. It is so predictable and obvious rather I assumed that the detail and character must have been important but it wasn't either. A pretty poor outing all round.

The cast that offered so much potential turned out to be unable to raise the material. Matthau essentially trades on the easy, grumpy charm that he always has and is actually enjoyable despite looking as bored by the whole thing as I was. This was his third outing as this character and on the basis of this film I can understand why he threw it in after this. Morgan is OK but is pretty much on autopilot while Zimbalist is reasonably good if not totally convincing. The only one that the script requires to deliver emotions is a young Stahl, who does deliver and is actually pretty good. Hallier attempts to get a chemistry with Matthau (perhaps to ensure she comes back had the series continued) but she falls flat and gives an ordinary performance at best.

Overall this is a poor film. The case has no mystery, tension or urgency and just drifts along slowly. The detail and character is lacking as well, with only the emotional impact on John being interesting. The cast may be famous but only Stahl impresses while Matthau is just reliable. All round a fairly pointless and boring film.