El detective y la muerte (1994) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Dark as well as weird film with very good cast , nice performances but including complex plot
ma-cortes12 July 2014
This rare picture with supernatural elements deals about an old man (Hector Alterio as Death or La Muerte) who hires a detective (Javier Bardem) to find the duchess (Charo Lopez) . The detective is accompanied by a brutal killer (Carmelo Gomez) who relentlessly kills people and even a baby . Along the way the Detective meets Maria (Maria de Medeiros) , a damsel in distress , both of them track down Duquesa .

Cold and strange film with a confuse plot , twisted intrigue , thrills , fantastic events and colorful images . The film relies heavily on the relationship among Javier Bardem , Carmelo Gomez and Maria De Medeiros ; it results to be a little bit boring , including with no sense dialogs , absurd situations and embarrassing screenplay . Offbeat writing credits by Azucena Rodriguez and same filmmaker Gonzalo Suarez with plenty of ridiculous and absurd deeds , adding supernatural frames ; being based on a story by Hans Christian Andersen . Magnificent main cast and great supporting roles such as Maria de Medeiros as María , an unfortunate mummy , Carmelo Gómez as a tough murderous , Héctor Alterio as G.M. a cruel wealthy old man , Charo López as Duquesa , Mapi Galán as Laura , Francis Lorenzo as D. Luis and Paulina Gálvez as Ofelia . Brilliant cinematography by Carlos Suarez , director's brother ; being filmed on location in Warsaw, Mazowieckie, Poland and beach scenes at the beginning shot in Llanes, Asturias, Spain , where director Suarez often shoots his movies . Thrilling and intriguing musical score by Suso Saiz , adding opera songs at the ending .

Direction by Gonzalo Suarez is mediocre ; however , he shows his skill for edition , realizing long shots with crowd who moves easily and including some action scenes . Gonzalo Suarez was born in Asturias , he is a good craftsman who has directed several films from the 60s . He excelled at bringing to life tautly written tales about strange characters facing difficult circumstances and dealing with thought-provoking , brooding stories . Throughout his career he regularly alternated hits with misses . He has stylistic trademarks , but also been criticized for his slow-moving films , though his best flicks remain exciting to watch . Among his most important pictures , mostly dramas , are the following : Oviedo Express , 1994 The detective and death , 1992 La Reina Anónima , 1991 Don Juan en Infiernos ,1988 Rowing with the wind , 1984 Epílogo ,1977 Parranda , 1977 Reina Zanahoria , 1976 Beatriz , 1975 La Regenta , 1974 La Loba y la Paloma .
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A strange film with great actors
earendil-110 May 2001
It's a strange Spanish thriller filmed in Poland; the performances of its protagonists are very good, so the film has a great cast of actors (the Oscar-nominated Javier Bardem, Carmelo Gómez, María de Medeiros...). But people uses to find this film very strange by the violence scenes and the supernatural presence of the roles of Javier Bardem and Carmelo Gómez. It's a recommendable film if you like odd films.
9 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Death becomes the detective
jotix1006 December 2009
Warning: Spoilers
This obscure film from Spain showed recently on cable. Director Gonzalo Suarez, who has been involved in Spanish cinema as a writer, an actor and as a director, bases his film on a Hans Christian Andersen's tale. He sets the story in a middle European country, which remains unnamed, but it is actually Poland, to set this strange story. The film is pretentious and obscure. It is easy for the viewer to get lost in a narrative that doesn't offer much and deals in the supernatural without much success.

Our main interest in watching the film was to watch Javier Bardem. Alas, even in spite of having won the best actor award in the San Sebastian Film Festival, he does not bring much to the film, although he has to show a lot of himself as he appears naked as the picture begins. Carmelo Lopez, also shows up. He has worked with the director in better made films, "El Portero", being one of them. Mapi Galan, a beautiful actress also 'bares' it all for our benefit. Hector Alterio and Charo Lopez do what they can. Maria De Medeiros' character is annoying.

This is one of the blackest films we have seen in recent memory. The screenplay and adaptation are credited to Mr. Suarez and Azucena Rodriguez.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed