Monica is promoted from search & rescue, and receives her first assignment from Tess. She is to help a boy living with his father, whose mother ran away after her daughter died. Monica bungles her assignment, but she does reunite the family
Monica substitutes at a school for the history teacher, and also becomes the assistant coach for the baseball team. A student on the baseball team needs help with his game. Monica helps him as well as the stubborn coach.
Monica and Tess arrange an accident on a deserted road for two friends Megan and Sasha, who are dating the same man. The Angels create a house, where the two friends, and Megan's husband have Thanksgiving dinner.
The angels help with a social event for a well-known doctor, his wife and mother. A young child shows up at their home, claiming to be the child they agreed to sponsor. The wife welcomes the child, but the doctor and his mother are worried.
Monica must help Joey, who has a mental condition, deal with the fact that his friend Serena is dying from a heart condition. Serena was to be the angel at the town's Christmas pageant. When she dies, a bright light leads Joey to the play.