Goofs
Factual errors
Dr. James Humes is depicted as an old man at the time of the JFK autopsy. He was 39 years old at the time.Share this
Jump to:
Anachronisms (14) |
Audio/visual unsynchronised (2) |
Boom mic visible (1) |
Character error (6) |
Continuity (7) |
Crew or equipment visible (1) |
Factual errors (11) |
Incorrectly regarded as goofs (5) |
Plot holes (2) |
Revealing mistakes (1)
Anachronisms
The spy camera shown, supposedly be used prior to the assassination, is a Minox C. This camera was not manufactured until 1969.
Share this
Share this
A banner that says "Louisiana: Tax-Free" is part of a late-1980's tourism campaign in Louisiana.
Share this
Share this
Scenes showing the railroad yard behind the wood fence show railroad cars painted and lettered for railroads that did not exist in 1963.
Share this
Share this
1980s clothes at the Mardi Gras parade.
Share this
Share this
During a flashback detailing the running of guns from Dallas to Miami via New Orleans, the Lake Pontchartrain Causeway is shown as a double span. As the time was pre-Kennedy assassination, the Causeway would have been just a single span - the second span was not open for traffic until 1969. Additionally, traffic going to Miami from New Orleans would not have traveled via the Causeway.
Share this
Share this
During the RFK shooting broadcast, Garrison is in the kitchen making a sandwich. On the counter is a jar of Hellmann's mayonnaise with a blue plastic lid. Hellmann's mayo had a metal "twist-off" lid in the '60s, not a plastic "screw-off" one.
Share this
Share this
After hearing of Kennedy's death, Guy Bannister proclaims, "Camelot in smithereens!" No one referred to Kennedy's presidency as Camelot until a week after the assassination, when Life magazine published Theodore H. White's interview with Jacqueline Kennedy, which made the link.
Share this
Share this
The advertising sign on top of the School Book Depository was not removed until 1979.
Share this
Share this
During a flashback to the scene at Dealey Plaza, just before the assassination, a 1964 Ford Mustang can be seen clearly in the background. That car did not come out until half way through the following year.
Share this
Share this
When Garrison is in the airplane with Senator Long we see upper hand luggage shelves already fitted with doors. At the time they were plain open.
Share this
Share this
When Donald Sutherland's military officer character is is in the airport in New Zealand on 22 November 1963, a Boeing 737 is visible taking off in the background, an airliner that did not enter service until 1968.
Share this
Share this
In Garrison's closing speech to the court in Clay Shaw's trial, he refers to the government proving the Magic Bullet theory with "some fancy physics and a nuclear laboratory" This neutron activation analysis of the bullet fragments was carried out by the House Special Committee on Assassinations in 1977 (some 8 years later)
Share this
Share this
When Lee Bowers' accident scene is shown, a train is passing in the background. Unfortunately, the type of train passing did not come into being until after 1980 - the scene took place in the mid-1960's.
Share this
Share this
A tracking shot on Camp St. In New Orleans has on the left side of the screen an image of One Shell Square in the background. This office building was not yet built during the film's time frame.
Share this
Share this
Audio/visual unsynchronised
When Ferrie is arguing in the hotel room with Garrison, his reflection in the nearby mirror seems to be talking when he is not.
Share this
Share this
When Jim Garrison and his assistant Lou are in the corner window of the Texas School Book Depository, Lou's line "...hasn't been used for two hundred years" doesn't sync with the movement of his lips, a mishap director Oliver Stone tried to correct by manufacturing an "echo" effect to lengthen the sound of dialogue.
Share this
Share this
Boom mic visible
When Ferrie is in the hotel room speaking to Garrison a boom mic can be seen in the mirror.
Share this
Share this
Character error
During his closing argument Jim Garrison misspeaks the famous phrase, "Of the people, by the people, and for the people." He instead says, "Of the people, for the people, and by the people."
Share this
Share this
Mr. X tells Garrison that the entire cabinet was on a trip to the Far East at the time of the assassination. Several cabinet members, including Robert Kennedy and Robert McNamara, were in Washington at the time.
Share this
Share this
Jim Garrison tells the jury that Dr. James Humes destroyed the notes he took at the JFK autopsy. He actually burned his first draft of the autopsy report and turned the notes over to his commanding officer. They subsequently disappeared.
Share this
Share this
Mr. X says that "we had one-third of a combat division returning from Germany in the air above the United States at the time of the shooting." He suggests they were to be used for riot control. In October 1963, the 2nd Armored Division flew from Fort Hood to Germany, to take part in maneuvers. All but 550 of the division's personnel returned during 12-21 November. By 4 December, they all were home. Armored troops are not as well suited for riot control as infantry is.
Share this
Share this
Garrison tells his staff that "nothing was done" when William Walter, an FBI security clerk, claimed that he received a Teletype from FBI headquarters, warning of a possible assassination attempt against Kennedy 5 days before he was assassinated. In reality, the FBI instituted an investigation at each of its 59 offices, which yielded no evidence indicating the existence of such a Teletype.
Share this
Share this
Garrison says "Back and to the left" repeatedly. Kennedy's head actually goes forward two inches (indicating a shot from behind) and then back and to the left (indicating a shot from the front).
Share this
Share this
Continuity
Clay Shaw's lawyer rises to hear the verdict twice.
Share this
Share this
On the DVD edition, when Jim Garrison and his assistant Lou are in the corner window of the Texas School Book Depository, there is an additional piece discussing more CIA connections. They mention "Clay Shaw" although his real name has not yet been discovered.
Share this
Share this
When Garrison begins his discussion with Willie O'Keefe, Willie puts the cigarette in his mouth twice.
Share this
Share this
At the end of the movie when the trial is going on, Lou Ivon's suit changes from one color to another then back again.
Share this
Share this
Willie walks into Clay's house with his jacket on, but before being greeted by the butler he bumps into him with his jacket now off.
Share this
Share this
In the final courtroom scene, When Liz Garrison enters the courtroom with their son, her hair is up. But by the time Jim Garrison's speech is over, Liz is seen with her hair down.
Share this
Share this
Crew or equipment visible
As Oswald is being taken out of the Texas Theater and into the police car, a boom operator in shorts can be seen, as well several other members of the crew in modern dress.
Share this
Share this
Factual errors
Opening scene supposedly takes place in 1962. Car shown is a 1965 Chevy.
Share this
Share this
When Garrison is in the airplane with Senator Long, it is implied that he looks out the window at the White House below. No civilian airplanes have been allowed to fly within three miles of the White House since World War II.
Share this
Share this
On his flight with Senator Long, Garrison is reading The Washington Post that is dated, Wednesday, 7 November 1966. In 1966, 7 November falls on a Monday.
Share this
Share this
Garrison's assistant is shown asking why someone like Oswald would order a rifle through the mail. Garrison says that Oswald did not order the rifle, that the order was made by others to "frame him obviously." In real life, Oswald's Mannlicher rifle was mailed to A. Hidell. A. Hidell was Oswald's alias. Oswald was carrying an A. Hidell ID in his wallet when he was arrested by the police.
Share this
Share this
Garrison shows a sketch drawn by Robert Groden of JFK and Connally in the presidential limousine in which Connally is seen seated directly in front of Kennedy. Garrison then makes fun of the magic bullet. In reality, Connally was seated to Kennedy's left front.
Share this
Share this
Garrison is shown taking two assistants to the corner of Camp and Lafayette streets and pointing out that the office address Oswald used on his Fair Play for Cuba leaflets was 544 Camp Street in New Orleans. Garrison then notes that 531 Lafayette Street, the address for Banister's office, is around the same corner in the same building and "both addresses go to the same place, Banister's office upstairs." This is not true. Joe Newbrough, a private detective, told Frontline in 1993 that 544 Camp Street and 531 Lafayette had totally separate entrances and were about 60 steps apart.
Share this
Share this
Garrison says, "We have the epileptic seizure around 12:15 PM ... distracting the police, making it easier for the shooters to move into their places. The epileptic later vanished, never checking into the hospital. But the individual in question hardly "vanished"; his name was Jerry Belknap a man who suffered from fainting spells after being hit by a car several years earlier. He was located by the FBI on May 26, 1964, and to prove his identity, he produced his receipt for the $12.50 he paid for his ambulance ride to Parkland Hospital. He explained that he had left Parkland without registering because he felt better after being given a glass of water and an aspirin. Moments later, the President's motorcade pulled into the hospital's parking lot, and Belknap realized he was not likely to see a doctor anytime soon anyway.
Share this
Share this
Jack Ruby did not shout "Oswald!" when he shot Lee Harvey Oswald. He didn't yell anything.
Share this
Share this
David Ferrie's "confession" in Fountainbleu Hotel never happened. Ferrie went to his death denying any knowledge of Oswald or the plot to kill JFK.
Share this
Share this
Garrison talks about hobo arrests and implies that they conspired to kill Kennedy. The three tramps had no connection to the assassination. Their names were Harry Doyle, John Gedney, and Gus Abrams.
Share this
Share this
Garrison says there were three cartridges lying "neatly side by side in Sniper's Nest". The cartridges were scattered.
Share this
Share this
Incorrectly regarded as goofs
When Garrison is speaking with David Ferrie, Ferrie's wig frequently changes position from high on his forehead to low, almost to the eyebrows. He's doing this intentionally with his hands because he is nervous.
Share this
Share this
Garrison's assistant tells him that it "takes a minimum of 2.3 seconds to recycle this thing {the Carcano}." The HSCA concluded that it was possible to fire the rifle within 1.66 seconds using the open iron sights, but it was not formed until 1976, seven years after the Shaw trial. The Warren Report, published in 1964, five years before the Shaw trial, stated that at least 2.3 seconds were required between shots.
Share this
Share this
Jack Ruby tells Chief Justice Warren, "My life is in danger. If I am eliminated , there won't be any way of knowing any bit of the truth." In his actual testimony before the Warren Commission Ruby said, "there was no conspiracy." (In the interrogation document Ruby says: "Gentlemen, my life is in danger here. Not with my guilty plea of execution. Do I sound sober enough to you as I say this? ")
Share this
Share this
Garrison says Oswald was "interrogated for 12 hours and nobody made a record of it". The Warren Report itself states that Oswald's interrogations were not recorded by court reporter or tape recording. The report includes several reports of these interrogations, made after they were over. Most of them were made after Oswald's death.
Share this
Share this
Garrison claims that Oswald's statements while in custody would be inadmissible in court. Because this assertion in based on a contrary to fact condition, it can never be verified. Neither can the assertion that Oswald's statements made while in custody would be admissible. In 1964, the Supreme Court ruled Danny Escobedo's murder confession to be inadmissible, because he made it in police custody after his requests to obtain a lawyer were refused. If Oswald had been tried, if he had chosen not to testify and if the courts held that giving him only brief opportunities to find a lawyer and continuing to question him after his efforts were unsuccessful constituted a denial of his right to counsel, his statements in custody would have been inadmissible.
Share this
Share this
Plot holes
The audience is told that JFK was killed by professional assassins. What professional assassins would draw attention to themselves by parking halfway up on a curb on a street heavy with traffic?
Share this
Share this
In Garrison's version of the assassination, the rifleman in the Dal-Tex Building rests his rifle on a metal frame. No one experienced with rifles would rest one on a hard object when firing it. If he did, the vibrations of the barrel would make the rifle jump up, throwing the aim point off the target.
Share this
Share this
Revealing mistakes
(at around 50 mins) A long shot of Dealey Plaza shows only a small number of people waiting for the motorcade. The actual crowd was much larger.
Share this
Share this
