Hors la vie (1991)A French photograher is kidnapped and held hostage in a war-torn Beirut. Slowly but surely his integrity and self-respect is broken. Director:Maroun Bagdadi |
|
| 0Share... |
Hors la vie (1991)A French photograher is kidnapped and held hostage in a war-torn Beirut. Slowly but surely his integrity and self-respect is broken. Director:Maroun Bagdadi |
|
| 0Share... |
| Cast overview, first billed only: | |||
| Hippolyte Girardot | ... |
Patrick Perrault
|
|
|
|
Rafic Ali Ahmad | ... |
Walid 'Chief'
|
|
|
Hussein Sbeity | ... |
Omar
|
|
|
Habib Hammoud | ... |
Ali 'Philippe'
|
|
|
Majdi Machmouchi | ... |
Moustapha
|
|
|
Hassan Farhat | ... |
Ahmed 'Frankenstein'
|
|
|
Hassan Zbib | ... |
Fadi
|
|
|
Nabila Zeitouni | ... |
Najat
|
|
|
Hamza Nasrallah | ... |
'De Niro'
|
|
|
Sami Hawat | ... |
Hassan
|
|
|
Sabrina Leurquin | ... |
Isabelle
|
|
|
Roger Assaf | ... |
Farid
|
|
|
Nidal Al-Askhar | ... |
Khaled's Mother
(as Nidal Ashkar)
|
|
|
Fadi Abou Khalil | ... |
(as Fady Abou Khalil)
|
|
|
Ninar Esber |
|
|
A French photograher is kidnapped and held hostage in a war-torn Beirut. Slowly but surely his integrity and self-respect is broken.
The first 15 minutes is some of the best modern warfare footage I've seen, expertly showing the insanity of the war in Lebanon.
We follow a French photographer as he documents a war in which everyone is turning on everyone. Then the photographer is kidnapped, and we spend most of the film watching the horrors of life as a hostage.
Scene by scene it's beautifully done. His captors are a very varied bunch, some sympathetic, some psychotic, although we never get to really know any of them, and they do fall into 'types' a bit.
My biggest problem with the film was the lack of a bigger political context. Unlike, for example, 'Four Days in September', we never really understand what the captors want. For a while that Kafka-esque confusion is interesting, but by the end, it makes the film seem a bit limited in vision. The captors almost all seemed childlike, and not very bright. There was a touch of what almost felt like racism, very odd, considering the film-maker is himself Lebanese.
In the end, this was tense and exciting as a docudrama (it was based on a real case), but by not having more scope, just missed the chance to be a truly great film.
That said, it's well worth seeing, and I intend to re-visit it.