Perry Mason: The Case of the Scandalous Scoundrel (1987 TV Movie) User Reviews

Enquiring Minds Want To Know Who The Murderer Is

[boblipton · 6/10 · 1 March 2019]

Susan Wilder is a writer for a National-Enquirer-like newspaper. It is run by Robert Guillaime. He fires her for pursuing serious stories. She goes to his estate to harangue him and leaves.... and he is found dead soon afterwards. Miss Wilder is on trial for murder, but fortunately she has Raymond Burr as Perry Mason for a lawyer, and Erle Stanley Gardner's lawyer-sleuth never represents a guilty client. Random witnesses confess on the stand Especially when you have a murder victim with lots of blackmail-style material in his safe, much of which vanishes after the death.

Rene Enriquez and Yaphet Kotto are two of the well-known actors who appear in this nicely ornamented episode in the series of TV movies in which Burr starred from 1986 through his death in 1993.

Yes! Yes! I did it! I did it! I killed him! And I don't regret it!

[sol1218 · 6/10 · 10 May 2011]

***SPOILERS*** Trying to become a respectable journalist despite working for a supermarket tabloid like the Confidential Informer reporter Michelle Benti, Susan Wilder, has this big story that she's dying to write about a major nursing home scandal that her boss the sleazy and unethical owner of the paper Harlem Wade, Robert Guillaume, is dead set against. It may very well be that Wade being the lowlife creep that he is may be a silent partner in the nursing homes that Michelle want's to report on and doesn't want the cat to come out of the bag in implicating him as well as the nursing home owners in bilking the old folks out of their life savings.

By not doing her job in digging up dirt on celebrities like her boss Wade wants her to and insisting to go full-tilt on reporting the nursing home scandal has Michelle get her walking papers from the Confidential Informer courtesy of her boss Harlem Wade. This later leads to an explosive confrontation between Michelle and Wade that evening outside the Wade Mansion by his swimming pool. Mchelle after giving Wade a piece of her mind and then driving away, at 70 MPH in a 50 MPH speed zone, Wade's body is later found dead by his head of security Nick Mortetti, Eugene Butler, with his skull split open floating in his swimming pool. Michelle in her being the last person to see Wade alive and not having anything good to say to him is later picked up by the police as the #1 suspect in Wade's murder.

Indited for the cold-blooded murder of Harlem Wade has Michelle's boyfriend Paul Drake, William Katt, get the person he works for as a private detective defense attorney Perry Mason, Raymond Burr, to defend in her upcoming murder trial. Perry soon finds out that whoever killed Harlem Wade deserves a medal and a ticker tape parade down Broadway not a jail sentence. Being the insensitive and ruthless creep that he was Wade hardly gets any sympathy from anyone in the movie but being that he had the goods, that he was going to publish in his rag, in his office safe on a number of important people in the news their all suspected in his murder including All-American hero the blood & guts and grab the enemy by the nuts General Sorenson,Yaphet Kotto.

As Drake is about to open, with a warrant from the court, Wade's office safe he's attacked by a guy with a silk stocking pulled over his head who's later identified as the Animal, Dennis Hayden, who works him over and then escapes with Wade's hot-file on a number of prominent people. Whoever paid the Animal to do this is obviously using that information to blackmail those in the hot-file that he stole. After being again confronted by the Animal and almost getting run over as well as getting his teeth kicked out Drake finally tracks down who hired the Anamil and it's non-other then reported Nick Connors, Dan Cooper, of the Confidential Informer the very paper that Michelle used to work for!

Rick heavily in debt hired the Animal to steal the files in order to blackmail for as much as $100,000.00 apiece each of those persons in them but only ended up getting the hell beat out of him by a group of tugs hired by international banker Oscar Otega, Rene Enriquez. Ortega was implicated in Wade's files for laundering drug and mob money through his bank. At Michelle's trial Perry Mason goes on a fishing expedition in not really knowing which of the persons that Harlem Wade was screwing was the one that did the sleaze-ball in!

***SPOILER ALERT*** It takes a while for Perry to come up, after almost being slapped with a charge of contempt by the trial judge, with someone who was not in Wade's hot-files at all but who in fact did in the gun-toting and obnoxious Wade in self-defense as he tried to shoot him the evening he was found dead floating in his swimming pool!

This is the only Perry Mason episode or TV movie where the killer was probably the real hero with him doing away someone, Harlem Wade, who really got exactly what was coming to him. In fact Wade got just what he deserved since he was about to kill his intended victim, with no provocation on his part, who ended up turning the tables on him! I for one feel that Wade's killer would have gone free, maybe he did at the conclusion of his trial, if he just stood up and told the truth about his actions which in anyone's mind who saw the movie were totally justified!

Perry Mason: The Case of the Scandalous Scoundrel

[coltras35 · 6/10 · 18 May 2023]

Magazine publisher Harlan Wade has become rich and powerful by printing malicious stories about the rich and famous, it has also left him the target for murder. The police and popular press have a prime suspect for the deed - but the accused calls in Perry Mason.

A rather entertaining Perry Mason TV movie with a nice selection of guest stars. This time the victim is a sadistic editor of a National Enquirer-type of rag, dishing the dirt on people, mainly the fictional kind, and naturally he has a long list of well wishers who would like to plunge a dagger into his gizzard. But a young journalist he fires is accused, mainly as she was the last to see him and her finger prints are on the statue which was used to cave the creep's head in. Robert Gulliume plays the creep and does really well in his portrayal. William Katt does the usual running around. It's gloriously fun 80's-90's fun. Nice soundtrack by hard rock/AOR band Silent Rage. It ends with standard courtroom reveal and it's a grabber.

Above average Mason revival TVM.

[jamesraeburn2003 · 16 April 2018]

Perry Mason (Raymond Burr) is representing a young journalist called Michelle Benti (Susan Wilder) who has been accused of murdering her employer, the reviled media baron Harlan Wade (Robert Guillaume), who owns a controversial daily tabloid called The Confidential Informer. Michelle had been fired after her professional ethics in journalism clashed with those of her boss who wanted to publish nothing but sleaze. The police believe they have her bang to rights because he was killed on his estate following a party and the guests had all gone home. She was seen arriving and leaving by the security staff who discovered Wade's body just minutes later. In addition, Michelle's fingerprints were found on what is assumed to be the murder weapon, a marble statuette, which has traces of Wade's blood on it. As is usually the case whenever he defends somebody accused of murder, Perry discovers a long list of people who had reasons for wanting Wade dead; including Oscar Ortega (Rene Enriquez), a banker who feared ruin because Wade was about to publish a damaging story about his bank being involved in money laundering and his clients being drug dealers. The respected Vietnam war veteran, General Sorrenson (Yaphet Kotto), was also a target for Wade because of an alleged scandal that suggested he had sold medical supplies on the black market. Someone has stolen some files from the murdered man's safe, which supposedly contained damaging evidence against prominent people whom he was looking to ridicule in his paper, so it looks as if the killer is one of the people named in those files. But who are they and which one of them did it?

Above average Perry Mason revival TVM with a strong plot line that offers an engaging insight into the world of journalism and its ethics. Perry's client, Michelle Benti, was arbitrarily sacked from her newspaper because she stood up for her principals by refusing to cover a story about prominent people supposedly involved in illicit love affairs regarding it as "pure sleaze". She had pleaded with her boss to allow her to do a story about certain nursing homes and their mistreatment of elderly citizens; something that was important to her. We also get an insight into how some in the legal profession feel about the sleazy tabloid for whom she worked. In court Perry makes his impassioned case for Michelle to be granted bail describing her as "a professional journalist with strong ties to the community." He is interrupted by his opponent Michael Reston (David Ogden Stiers) who screams "Journalist! Your Honour, this young woman is a procurer of libelous misstatements and innuendo for a weekly tabloid that mocks the First Amendment while it pads its corporate wallet". He strongly urges the Judge to deny her bail. He risks allowing his personal dislike of The Confidential Informer to cloud his judgement, but Perry points out that it is Michelle who is on trial for her life and not the newspaper despite its reputation.

William Katt does his usual action man bit as Paul Drake. Here, he is on the trail of a violent safecracker known as 'The Animal' and in his usual dogged determination he nearly gets blown up, crushed to death by a pick up truck and beaten up while having to contend with Michelle insisting on helping him nail his man, and while she is a friend of his, he resents her meddling. There is some amusing comedy moments in his scenes with Wilder too.

The chemistry between Burr and Barbara Hale is there too. In this episode Della is puzzled as to whom is sending her expensive gifts - flowers, champagne - anonymously at their hotel. In the end it turns out that it is Perry who has been sending them. Performances are generally good all round with Guilaume convincing as the ruthless media boss Harlan Wade who does not care whom he hurts or whose lives he ruins as long as he can sell papers. Susan Wilder is very good as the young journalist accused of murder displaying real passion in her quest for good ethical journalism. Yaphet Kotto, who is best remembered as the Bond villian Kananga in Live And Let Die, is quite good as the Vietnam veteran who was a target of Wade and his papers too.

It works as a murder mystery with the clues and red herrings in Anthony Spinner's script running smoothly into each other to reveal a logical and satisfying denouement.

Boring only because of the acting

[harloon-68278 · 5/10 · 13 October 2020]

Unlike the original series of the late 1950s and early 1960s, that featured many highly respected motion picture actors, these made for TV movies instead draw upon the very limited talents of soap opera performers. The result is precisely what might be expected. The soap opera actors perform according to a formula without subtlety or nuance. The result is what would be expected - stiff performances played according to formula. These TV films are okay but only for soap opera aficionados. Even Ray Burr seems to have lost his edge

Standard Perry Mason courtroom story with the usual ending

[bob the moo · 24 August 2002]

An editor in charge of a gutter tabloid (Harlan Wade) has many enemies dues to the many rumours and secrets he has on many powerful people. When he is killed at the end of a garden party all clues point to Marianne Clayman who had just been fired by Wade that day. However Mason takes the case and realises that many people had opportunities and motives, while Paul Drake digs behind the scenes.

I have happy memories of watching Perry Mason TVM's in summer holiday weekday afternoons on BBC1 with my Dad who loves these things. I think I've seen the majority of them and they all go the same way – the obvious suspect in any murder is defended by Mason who doesn't so much defend his client as go and find the real killer, eventually forcing them to confess in a courtroom with a shout of `wasn't it you……etc….Wasn't it?!'. They're all the same but they're all semi-enjoyable.

The story here allows for more suspects but is a weakness of the film. Drake's investigation is sidelined more than usual as we have Mason doing the rounds instead to no real benefit to the story. The overall effect is that this drags a bit and lacks action or excitement. The usual twist is nobody you would have suspected but still doesn't make it feel exciting. However if you enjoy these films then you'll know what to expect and be happy with it as I was.

The cast has some famous faces in support. Burr is the same as ever in a role that is like a second skin, as is Hale and William Katt despite that terrible perm thing he has! Hayden is one of the terrorists from Die Hard and is one example of the many faces you'll recognise from other programmes. The biggest let down for me was Yaphet Kotto who only had a small role where he failed to show his quality in the way he can. Don't know why he did this as he was more than famous at this point – and look at the wig they make him wear (please tell me that's not his real hair!). He looks absurd but at least Katt looks pleased that he hasn't got the worst hair in the place!

Overall it's average Saturday afternoon entertainment for most people. However if you like the Perry Mason films then you'll find all the usual things repeated here to good effect. If you like one you'll like them all.

After All Perry and Della Are Two Consenting Adults

[bkoganbing · 4/10 · 20 July 2008]

Perry Mason: The Case of the Scandalous Scoundrel finds the famous defense attorney almost a victim himself here of blackmail. The blackmailer in question is the scandalous scoundrel in this case played by Robert Guillaume.

Guillaume is the publisher of the National Informer one of the more notorious supermarket rags who's got himself a blackmail racket and the means to make good for threats of exposure.

When Perry gets retained by a potential victim, Guillaume actually goes to try and get dirt on him and Della Street. I mean, come on people, we are talking about two very consenting adults who are way past the age of consent. That part I found just a tad too ridiculous so this particular entry in the Mason film series.

But this turns to murder when Guillaume is killed with a blunt object and of course given his profession there are a lot of suspects. The police of course focus in on Susan Wilder a disgruntled former employee of the Informer and she retains Raymond Burr as all innocent folks do.

The three leading blackmail candidates seem to be General Yaphett Kotto, international banker Rene Enriquez and cheating wife Morgan Brittany and her older husband George Grizzard and all give a good account of themselves.

David Ogden Stiers is the worthy successor as DA Michael Reston to the famous Hamilton Burger. But strangely enough James McEachin who appeared in a few Mason films is cast as a caterer here. He has a key role in the homicide in fact though he's not aware of it. I think I can safely say he wasn't the culprit. I guess the writers thought he had not firmly established his presence as Lt. Brock yet.

It's one of the weaker entries in the Mason series, but still enjoyable for the devoted fans of Erle Stanley Gardner's famous lawyer/sleuth.