Orfeo (1985) User Reviews

Excellent filmed version of history's first great opera

[jshaver-1 · 9/10 · 14 December 2007]

Monteverdi was the first great opera composer and L'Orfeo was his first great opera. The subject of the musician Orpheus whose love for Euridice was so great that he went down to Hades to persuade Pluto to return her to earth by playing the lyre for him has been a favorite subject of countless operas. Haydn and Gluck both wrote operas on the subject (along with numerous minor composers such as Landi.) Offenbach created a delightful burlesque. This quasi-filmed version (somewhere between a stage production and a film) captures the drama inherent in Monteverdi's version and is pleasant to behold. Gino Quilico is excellent in the title role both as a singer and actor. It is a must for lovers of early opera and recommended viewing for those who don't think they like anything before Mozart.

what a mess!!

[karlericsson · 2/10 · 15 September 2019]

I mean the Music or what is supposed to pass for it. It's recitatives, one after the other and no arias whatsoever. It may be the first opera but what a mess! Disharmony upon disharmony - incredibly boriing! I bought the blu-ray because of Claude Goretta and there's nothing wrong with the performers or direction. What it lacks is taste, a taste to determine between Music and farting. Unfortunately, Goretta is not alone in lacking such determination, alas.