Reviews & Ratings for
Qing cheng zhi lian More at IMDbPro »

3 out of 3 people found the following review useful:
A little bit of history, 10 February 2005
Author: Harry T. Yung (harry_tk_yung@yahoo.com) from Hong Kong

The "fallen city" is Hong Kong during the Japanese occupation in WWII, but most of the story revolves around the time just before the actual falling. While the plush hotel at Repulse Bay where most of the story takes place has been restored and still carries its colonial flavor, the story belongs to another time. This was a time when Pai Liu-So (Cora Miao), a divorcée approaching thirty, was frowned upon for being way ahead of her time. "Don't think legal papers of divorce would give you the right to everything", yells her brother who took her back into her family (together with her money that he quickly lost in reckless speculation in the stock market), "laws are made and unmade every day. It's traditions that really count".

Fan Liu-yuan (Chow Yun-fat), a westernized, financially successful playboy whom she encounters in Shanghai and then again in Hong Kong sees in her the "perfect Chinese woman". Most of the story takes place at the hotel in Hong Kong where Pai accompanies generous family friends on a trip. Typically helpless and introvert, scantily educated Pai nevertheless is witty and proud, enough so to deeply attract Fan, who idealizes her despite his abundant experience with women. Pai, who would probably make a successful professional or business woman at a different time in a different place, is practical and looks for a secured relationship in marriage. The seesaw between them goes on until the war and the fall of Hong Kong, when struggling for survival finally brings their souls together, so to speak.

Brought back as one of the week-long Valentine TV specials, Love in a Fallen City is not one of the sweet romances along the line of You've Got Mail or Sleepless in Seattle. It's from a troubled era when western influence challenged traditional values. Even more unique is the pre-WWII colonized world of Hong Kong. Director Ann Hui captures all these elements while moving along this love story that would have been so natural, but for an uncertain, changing world that warped everything.

Miao has the air of silent defiance that is perfect for the role of Pai. A recent stage production of the story, however, portrayed Pai's character as more positive and cheerful, which I like even better. Chow has all the charm and flamboyance needed to make Fan believable. The excellent rapport between them further confirms the great casting job.

Love in a fallen city, 22 May 2009

Author: ky_chong

Set in Hong Kong and Shanghai in the early 1940s (1941 to be exact), this 1984 film by Ann Hui is an adaptation of an Eileen Chang novella. Liu-Su, a young divorcée turning thirty, is heavily ostracized by her traditionally-minded Shanghai family who constantly badmouths her in order to get her to move on to another man. Eager to get out of her family, she meets Liu-yuan, a rich Malayan businessman and playboy who follows her back to Shanghai and brings her to Hong Kong during the Japanese invasion of China and Hong Kong.

"Love in a Fallen City", a Shaw Brothers production, is fairly successful but not entirely without its faults. Like what Ann Hui said later in her career, the movie appears too concerned with storytelling and far less with maintaining atmosphere. That the film is extremely talky doesn't help matters. (The scriptwriter appears to be trying to transpose all the dialogue from the novel to the film.) The set production and design leave a lot to be desired - although the film is set in 1941 Shanghai and Hong Kong, the entire film seems to be shot in 1960s Hong Kong. The Shanghai milieu is not convincing, while the Hong Kong side of the production, naturally, looks more realistic simply because the movie was shot in Hong Kong in the 1980s.

Chow Yun-Fatt does well in his sweet-talking playboy role. His constant attention to Cora Miao's Liu-Su marks one of his best romantic performances to date. However Cora Miao appears to be miscast. Her mousy portrayal of Liu-Su leaves us with little empathy for the divorced widow, and oftentimes, Miao appears out of her depth. However, her performance is still not downright disastrous and she does have some chemistry with Chow, so the romantic elements of the film still remains largely watchable.

"Love in a Fallen City" trails off somewhat towards the end. The last 20 minutes concerning the Japanese invasion of Hong Kong is important for narrative accountability, but overall the film feels somewhat vacant by this point. Ann Hui made (probably) a superior Eileen Chang adaptation in "Eighteen Springs", but this 1984 movie still remains watchable if as a sort of dress rehearsal to the later 1997 film.

Couldn't reflect the spirit of the original novel, 12 February 2005

Author: from Hong Kong

The movie couldn't totally reflect the depth of the original novel. In the original novel, Laoyuen is the guy who didn't want to settle down and full of hesitation about the relationship with Liuso.

Liuso was the woman who sought for the psychological shelter which can protect her from the harm of family pressure due to the failure of her first marriage and financial contribution to her family. She would like to get the certainty for the relationship from Laoyuen but she dare not to tell her real feeling to him due to the social pressure? (most probably) At the time of the story background, women even have to suffer all of their sorrow without any complaint even the life was really difficult. Liuso was in paradox: on the one hand, she have to suffer all of sorrow without complaints and on the other hand, she sought for the breakthrough for her life.

Miao could take her part to interpret the sentiment of Liuso but the acting skill was unnatural.

Chow could reflected the characters and attitudes of Laoyuen: easy-going, unstable, irresponsible and hesitating.

The presentation skills of the conversation are weak. Supposed the conversation should be presented in serious tone but Chow made it just like a comedy (a bit like Stephen Chau's style of pretending serious at the time of talking joke).

Add another review

Related Links