Murder, She Wrote (1984–1996)
6 user

The Murder of Sherlock Holmes 

Former English teacher Jessica Fletcher travels to New York to celebrate the success of her debut novel, but when an unwanted guest is murdered at a costume party, she wishes she'd stayed home.



(created by), (created by) | 5 more credits »

On Disc

at Amazon



Episode cast overview, first billed only:
Jessica Browne ...
Kitty Donovan
Peter Brill
Louise McCallum (as Anne Lloyd Francis)
Ashley Vickers
Dexter Baxendale
Chief Roy Gunderson
Rosanna Huffman ...
Eleanor Thompson
Lois Hoey


In this Pilot episode we are introduced to Jessica Fletcher, a recent widow, who lives in Cabot Cove, Maine. Jessica is an English teacher who becomes a mystery book author thanks to her nephew, Grady Fletcher. Grady submits his Aunts manuscript to a publishing company who loves it and publishes it immediately. It is a best-seller and Jessica goes to New York City to promote her new book. While there Jessica gets involved in a murder while at her publishers home for a costume party. When her nephew becomes a suspect of the murder, Jessica must find the real killer. Written by Anonymous

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis


Crime | Drama | Mystery





Release Date:

30 September 1984 (USA)  »

Company Credits

Production Co:

Show detailed on  »

Technical Specs



Sound Mix:



Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


Production Designer Hub Braden, early in his career, had been the scenic designer for a summer at the Kennybunkport Playhouse, in Maine. During his return to Kennybunkport for a vacation, he discovered an Atlantic ocean inlet bay which a main town road bridged over. The inlet has a very small sign on either end of the bridge with the inlet bay's name: Cabot Cove. See more »


When Jessica is harassed by the two guys on the street, she hits them with her purse and it is obviously a male stunt performer in a wig. See more »


[Police Chief Gunderson questions Preston Giles and his house guests]
Chief Roy Gunderson: Suppose you tell me what happened here last night, Mr. Giles. Folks don't go 'round gettin' half their heads blown off for no reason. I'm lookin' for motive.
Peter Brill: For killing Caleb McCallum? Surely you jest. Half the country had reason to kill him. The other half didn't know him.
Chief Roy Gunderson: Not funny, friend.
Ashley Vickers: But accurate. The Captain wasn't particularly well loved. Though I doubt that any of us despised him enough to kill him.
Louise McCallum: Except for me....
See more »


References Donahue (1967) See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

Jessica Fletcher -- born but not yet evolved
15 October 2011 | by (Minneapolis) – See all my reviews

The character of Jessica Fletcher hadn't quite come into focus yet when this pilot episode was written. She seems a bit "folksier," quick to dispense home-remedies for cleaning dress stains or curing corns on feet. She has as yet only a tentative grasp on what it means to be a best-selling author and too often seems a bit bewildered about life in the Big City. The later Jessica Fletcher grew in assurance and seemed to find strength in her Cabot Cove background rather than viewing it simply as a safe retreat from a troubling Outside World. This growth in her character probably helped account for the long-running appeal of the show.

While this pilot episode has the somewhat questionable advantage of greater length, it doesn't rank as one of the show's better offerings, but it certainly has a curiosity value and it does offer a pleasing array of guest stars: Arthur Hill, Brian Keith, Anne Francis, Raymond St. Jacques, Ned Beatty, Burt Convy, etc.

6 of 8 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you?

Message Boards

Recent Posts
Does anyone else hate the "tonight on murder she wrote" part? Jessie_C
Coziest episode? bsmale
What's your favourite end Jessica shot? btsmith_uk
Episodes that make you laugh Hockeydaze
Episodes with two or more of the same guest stars but playing different darthquincunx
Recurring Characters You Wish Made More Appearances george-adelman
Discuss The Murder of Sherlock Holmes (1984) on the IMDb message boards »

Contribute to This Page

Create a character page for: