"Great Performances" The Innocents Abroad (TV Episode 1983) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Reasonably Good Film - But Not Twain's Masterful Attack on "Superior Foreign Culture"
theowinthrop22 December 2005
Samuel Clemens had made his newspaper reputation on the west coast by being on the scene in Honolulu when tales of a terrible shipwreck occurred. Shortly after he returned to San Francisco, Twain published his classic short story, "The Celebrated Jumping Frog Of Calaveras County". Soon he was getting offers from eastern newspapers. He took up one offer for a trip to Europe and the Holy Land (one of the first tourist trips) on board the ship "Quaker City". Sam was to write up his reactions to the sites and sounds of the trip. He left in 1867, and sent back accounts of his visits in the various stops (and how he constantly got under the skins of the tourists guides - when shown the tomb of Columbus in Spain, he asks the guide, "Who was he" and "Is he dead?"). The results of the long trip was finally polished up and published by Clemens as "The Innocents Abroad". It was the first successful book of Mark Twain.

I strongly recommend reading this wonderful travel book, certainly one of the best travel books by an American. Twain actually had a growing theme in the book, and one which still bothers Americans (and to a lesser degree Europeans). He insisted that we should not feel inferior to the Europeans for not having such a history or culture as they could produce. He kept showing the shoddy side of the tourist-produced sites, the commercialism involved, that was frequently ignored by others. He also notes that some sites were not as magnificent as had been suggested. When going through Palestine, he was distinctly unimpressed by the locations, the deserts, and the bodies of water: His comment regarding the sea of Galilee was it was not as wonderful as Lake Tahoe. In short, America had wonderful, even better sites than the old world did. Keep in mind that Twain is not condemning the old world - he is being very realistic.

Twain's book was not the first American book to look with jaundiced eye to Europe. Nathaniel Hawthorne had spent several years in England in the 1850s as our consul in Liverpool, and he wrote a book "Our Old Home" about how bad things were in England. But Hawthorne's book was aimed at one country, and Anglo-American rivalries had been going on since the American Revolution and the War of 1812. Furthermore, Hawthorne's book was a type of answer to Charles Dickens' "American Notes" (1842) where Dicken attacked Americans for the hypocrisy of claiming to be the land of the free while having slavery.

It would not be the last travel book by Twain. In 1872 he would write the sequel, "Roughing It", about the American west. In 1880 he would do "A Tramp Abroad", where he went through northern Europe and France. In 1882 he did what can be considered his best traveled book, "Life On The Mississippi", wherein he wrote from love of the great river that he had served as a riverboat pilot. Finally, due to financial pressures, he did a two year trip around the globe of stage appearances in a one man show. The results were his last travel book, "Following The Equator" (1897), which is his longest travel book - but probably his least read one.

The 1983 television film was part of a two or three year series of films made for Public Television. These versions were not perfect copies of the original stories (for example, "The War Prayer" was tacked on, rather well, to "The Private History Of A Campaign That Failed"). Here the story's truthfulness (the hiring of Sam/Mark to go on the Quaker City trip) was mingled with a romance he gets into with fellow tourist Julia Newell. This did not happen. Nor was there a resulting triangle with Sam's friend, ship's doctor "Doc". And the Captain of the ship did not try to sabotage Twain's contract by withholding the mailing of his copy to his newspaper.

The acting was very good, in particular Craig Wasson as Sam/Mark, Brooke Adams as Julia, and David Ogden Stiers as the really nice fellow "Doc" (miles away from Major Winchester). As the Captain of the "QUAKER CITY", Barry Morse was excellent as a religious bigot and hypocrite. Also of note was Gigi Proietti as "Fergusson", the nickname Twain gives to all the various befuddled tourist guides he meets in the trip - Proietti played all of them, constantly wondering what he had deserved to have this crazy "dumb" American as his current client.

Not as wonderful as the book, but an enjoyable film to see before you read the book.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Lovely enjoyable film
ninja301222 June 2005
I watched this film recently but had read it's bad reviews, however I was pleasantly surprised as I rather liked the film. The main characters were funny and well played and the locations were lovely. I don't know how close it resembles the book but I loved it and it was a film that was easy to watch. I particularly enjoyed David Ogden Stiers as the ship's doctor. He portrayed a character that was different from some of the other roles I have seen him in and as a fan of his, I was also pleased to see that he was in a lot of scenes. I'd recommend people watch the film but it's worth buying if you're a David Ogden Stiers fan.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Don't waste your time
hieronym1 June 2002
This was a complete travesty. I *like* Twain's written work a great deal, and this movie was unbearable because it bore only a scenic resemblance to the work. There was a BBC-produced movie made in 1991, but I haven't seen that one yet.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The writer of the teleplay should hang his head, or have it hung for him.
eliasen4 March 2002
_The Innocents Abroad_ is one of my favorite books in the world. The humor is fresh and alive 130 years after it was written. Any page has an amusing scene that could be recounted to good effect.

Enter the teleplay writer of this doomed project, Dan Wakefield. Not a single scene in the movie remains free from his butchering. Not a quote isn't "improved" or completely twisted into a totally different scene. Without any reason or logic, every memorable piece of the book is replaced by some moronic slapstick routine, or a complete rewrite (in what one guesses was an attempt at humor, but is inevitably painfully unfunny.) Every bit of anticipation that I had when I sensed a favorite part of the book about to be recounted was destroyed by an inexplicable rewrite. Someone should have sat down with the screenwriter and suggested that he wasn't improving Twain by his hackish efforts. The other half that was purely invented was even worse. There were even 3 fight scenes which were gratuitously added. I fully expected a car chase to break out at any time. Painful.

The redeeming qualities of the film are the fascinating scenery, filmed in Greece, Paris, Egypt, and Rome. Somebody did at least a little bit of research to bring in the characters of Julia Newell and Mary Mason Fairbanks, (who are never once mentioned in the book.) David Ogden Stiers does a good job as the ship's doctor, but in the end, all of the characters come off as irritating and distasteful because of the horrible script. Of course Wakefield had to invent an engagement proposal between the Doctor and Julia. (The Doctor, Abraham Jackson, was married at the time, although he did marry Newell 4 years later after his wife died.)

Whoever allowed Wakefield's moronic teleplay to see the light of day wasted a whole lot of money, and utterly ruined a chance to make an underappreciated work into a great film. A monkey could produce a better screenplay. Blindfold him, make him point at a page in the book, and quote it directly. It doesn't have to be a particularly literate monkey, either.

One imagines Wakefield at his typewriter, thinking "wouldn't it be funnier if Huck Finn decided not to help Jim gain his freedom, but instead had a wacky pie-fight on the raft? I'm so brilliant!"
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed