IMDb > Édith et Marcel (1983)

Édith et Marcel (1983) More at IMDbPro »


IMDb Holiday Movie Guide

Overview

User Rating:
6.0/10   152 votes
MOVIEmeter: ?
Down 22% in popularity this week. See why on IMDbPro.
Director:
Writers:
Claude Lelouch (writer) and
Pierre Uytterhoeven (writer) ...
more
Contact:
View company contact information for Edith and Marcel on IMDbPro.
Release Date:
13 April 1983 (France) more
Genre:
Plot:
The world's most popular entertainer and Europe's greatest boxer: the film puts the love affair of these... more | add synopsis
Plot Keywords:
User Comments:
Piaf may have been the sparrow, but here she's a tiresome, childish, selfish, jerky, squawking parrot. more (5 total)

Cast

  (Cast overview, first billed only)
Evelyne Bouix ... Edith Piaf / Margot de Villedieu
Jacques Villeret ... Jacques Barbier
Francis Huster ... Francis Roman
Jean-Claude Brialy ... Loulou Barrier
Marcel Cerdan Jr. ... Marcel Cerdan
Jean Bouise ... Lucien Roupp
Charles Gérard ... Charlot
Charlotte de Turckheim ... Ginou
Micky Sébastian ... Marinette Cerdan
Maurice Garrel ... Margot's Father
Ginette Garcin ... Guite
Philippe Khorsand ... Jo Longman
Jany Gastaldi ... Momone
Candice Patou ... Margot's Sister
Tanya Lopert ... English Teacher
more
Create a character page for: ?

Additional Details

Also Known As:
Edith and Marcel (USA)
more
Runtime:
USA:170 min | France:162 min | Argentina:168 min
Country:
Language:
Color:
Color (Eastmancolor)
Sound Mix:
Certification:
Company:

Fun Stuff

Trivia:
Dedicated to Patrick Dewaere, who committed suicide in the beginning of the shooting. He was replaced by 'Marcel Cerdan Jr'. who plays the role of his own father, the boxer Marcel Cerdan. more
Soundtrack:
Je n'attendais que toi more

FAQ

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.
4 out of 9 people found the following comment useful.
Piaf may have been the sparrow, but here she's a tiresome, childish, selfish, jerky, squawking parrot., 12 August 1999
3/10
Author: Darragh O' Donoghue (hitch1899_@hotmail.com) from Dublin, Ireland

It's easy to laugh at Claude Lelouch, and most critics do. He is blissfully devoid of genius, but not necessarily of interest. His biggest problem is that he has humble skills, but grand pretensions. He's seen, like the rest of us, great movies, and thinks that if, say, Ophuls used a particular tracking shot, that if he completely replicates it, he'll be great too, not realising that the initial shot belonged to a fully-worked out style designed to convey meaning, and a particular view of the world. It's not that Lelouch is all style and no substance - the usual complaint; he doesn't know that style IS substance.

And yet audiences flock to his pictures (apparently he is the most successful 'foreign-language' (what a horrible term) filmmaker in English-speaking countries), and dozens of important stars with little sense (or just a great deal of cynicism) queue up to decorate them. Edith and Marcel is an exception. There are recognisable faces (especially a humiliating turn by the once sublime Brialy), but they are relegated to the margins of the film's great thesis: Lelouch On Piaf.

To his credit, Lelouch does try to tackle the Piaf myth, and her status as symbol, saint, essence etc. of the French people. For instance, many of her greatest love songs are third person narratives, and so he mingles her most notorious love story with that of an imaginary couple, one of whom is played by the same actress as Piaf, as if to suggest that Edith and Marcel are only larger-than-life embodiments of all the passions, pains and loves of France.

Unfortunately, to adequately contextualise Piaf, one would need a firm grasp of French history, something Lelouch spectacularly lacks. Like many of his films, Edith and Marcel has a significant historical backdrop, in this case World War II. But it's not a World War II you or I might recognise - no savage Germans, no concentration camps, no collaborators; indeed, military prison seems like a hoot. Edith's and Marcel's 'symbolic' resistance is glossed over in a couple of offhand lines, leaving one dissatisfied and suspicious.

This failure of history extends to Piaf's music. What should be the glory of the film is ruined by 'artistic' distortions, fatuous contextualisation, and the sacrilege of getting some heinous impersonator to 'do' Piaf to Francis Lai's more 'contemporary' (arf!) music, both unforgivably denying history, and suggesting that Piaf could be improved upon.

None of this would really matter if the film was entertaining. Some of Lelouch's monstrosities are so preposterous as to become compelling. But here - in contrast to Piaf, whose songs were compact, passionate, melodramatic, melancholic, tragic; packed with gangsters, whores, young lovers: the outsiders - the film's story is laborious; the insistent, self-satisfied, handheld camerawork is tiresome; the barrage of showy shots for their own sake is wearing; the confusion with beauty of the most ghastly bad taste is embarrassing; the film's hurtling sense of momentum when there is actually nothing moving is exasperating; the replacement of acting with mannerism is infuriating.

That a film about such an extraordinary woman, about that most cinematic of sports - boxing; with so much hysteria and shrieking and talk about love and the Eternal; with so many quotes and allusions to classic movies, books and music, should be so passionless, cold and dull is unfathomable. The film's only redeeming feature is the cameo by Charles Aznavour, as sad and self-effacing as ever (playing his youthful self as an old man 35 years later!), singing some narratively pointless, but beautiful songs.

Was the above comment useful to you?
more (5 total)

Message Boards

Discuss this movie with other users on IMDb message board for Édith et Marcel (1983)
Recent Posts (updated daily)User
soundtrack Edith et Marcel rdl-4
Where Can I get this Movie tonyg-16
Did you ever wander who sings the soundtrack? frhum
more

Recommendations

If you enjoyed this title, our database also recommends:
- - - - -
Rendez-vous La peau douce Professione: reporter And Now... Ladies and Gentlemen... Marquise
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
Show more recommendations

Related Links

Full cast and crew Company credits IMDb Drama section
IMDb France section Add this title to MyMovies

You may report errors and omissions on this page to the IMDb database managers. They will be examined and if approved will be included in a future update. Clicking the 'Update' button will take you through a step-by-step process.