Five Red Herrings (1975– )

Stars:

Ian Carmichael, Glyn Houston, David Rintoul

Cast

Series cast summary:
Ian Carmichael	...	Lord Peter Wimsey (4 episodes, 1975)
Glyn Houston	...	Bunter (4 episodes, 1975)
David Rintoul	...	Jock Graham (4 episodes, 1975)
David McKail	...	John Ferguson (4 episodes, 1975)
Roy Boutcher	...	Henry Strachan (4 episodes, 1975)
Michael Elder	...	Sergeant Dalziel (4 episodes, 1975)
Russell Hunter	...	Matthew Gowan (3 episodes, 1975)
John Junkin	...	Mr. Alcock (3 episodes, 1975)
Clive Graham	...	Michael Waters (3 episodes, 1975)
Susan Macready	...	Gilda Farren (3 episodes, 1975)
Jake D'Arcy	...	Hammond (3 episodes, 1975)
Robert James	...	Sir Maxwell Jamieson (3 episodes, 1975)
Julie Peasgood	...	Fenella Strachan (3 episodes, 1975)
Michael Sheard	...	Inspector MacPherson (3 episodes, 1975)
Donald Douglas	...	Hugh Farren (2 episodes, 1975)
James Copeland	...	Wully Murdoch (2 episodes, 1975)
Ann Scott-Jones	...	Mrs. Alcock (2 episodes, 1975)
Sally Kinghorn	...	Betty (2 episodes, 1975)
Irene Sunters	...	Mrs. Smith-Lemesurier (2 episodes, 1975)
Elaine Collins	...	Helen McGregor (2 episodes, 1975)
Jan Wilson	...	Miss Selby (2 episodes, 1975)
Eileen McCallum	...	Miss Cochrane (2 episodes, 1975)
Elizabeth Sinclair	...	Jeanie (2 episodes, 1975)

Storyline

---

Plot Keywords:

tv mini series | based on novel | number in title

---

Details

Country:

UK

Language:

English

Release Date:

19 December 1976 (USA)

Also Known As:

Lord Peter Wimsey: Five Red Herrings

Filming Locations:

Big Water of Fleet Viaduct, Dromore, Gatehouse of Fleet, Dumfries & Galloway, Scotland, UK

Company Credits

Production Co:

British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC)

Did You Know?

Trivia

None of the stations shown are the real locations as the railway line closed in 1965.

---

Connections

Follows The Unpleasantness at the Bellona Club (1972)

User Reviews

It's a clever "fairplay" puzzle mystery set in southern Scotland

If you like to pit your own wits against "Lord Peter" this is your chance. Dorothy L. Sayers shows you everything "his lordship" knows, so you ought to pick out the culprit as soon as he does, maybe even sooner. Along the way you'll get some delightful looks at the Scottish landscape, hear a lot of broad Scots dialect, and meet some really interesting, not to say often delightful characters, well interpreted by a sterling cast.

That said, I would have to agree with the critics over the years, who have rated this mystery of Dorothy's as not quite up to her usual standard. It's, in the novel at least, just a trifle too complicated, possibly boring at times, with all the emphasis on railway timetables and such. The BBC has foreshortened much of this. You won't be bored, I am sure, with this TV film version. Briefly, the story involves the death of a curmudgeonly Scottish artist named "Campbell" and six suspects known to have possible reasons to kill him. Only one can be guilty, hence there are five who are "red herrings". In the U.S. at one time, this novel was published as SUSPICIOUS CHARACTERS.

In the course of solving the mystery for the Scottish constabulary, "Lord Peter", and "Bunter" travel over a good bit of the landscape southeast of Glasgow in "his lordship's" Bentley (Yes, I know Dorothy said he drove a Daimler. I wonder why the BBC changed it. Better to advertise the home product perhaps?), and sometimes via bicycle and "shank's mare".

By the time "Lord Peter" exposes the culprit you will have ample opportunity to judge how well Ian Carmichael has realised "Lord Peter" for you. Physically, about 15 years later, Edward Petherbridge has physically presented what I think is a more authentic "Lord Peter". He gives us, though, a much more dour and brooding character than what I imagine Dorothy intended. Iam Carmichael, although he doesn't look like my conception of "Lord Peter", does seem to show the insouciance and "whimsical" charm that the character displays throughout the novels.

There are many lovely little cameos sprinkled through this film. The women especially shine. Irene Sunters simpers wonderfully as "Mrs. Smith-Lemesurier", the clinging vine who is painter "Jock Graham's" nemesis. And Julie Peasgood as "Penella Strachan", 15 years old going on "30", will surely knock you over. I don't think there is a bad performance in the lot.