IMDb > The Green Wall (1970) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
The Green Wall More at IMDbPro »La muralla verde (original title)

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 6 reviews in total 

10 out of 12 people found the following review useful:

Must see

10/10
Author: Rafael Coquis from Texas
24 March 1999

This is one of those films that absorbs you from the very beginning. The narrative, juxtaposing time, place and themes at wish, is a delight to view.

The camera works is excellent. The angles for the scenes (Lima: the stairs to the lawyers office) are so unusual and though well chosen as they described the inner thoughts of the characters.

Very excellent film.

Was the above review useful to you?

6 out of 6 people found the following review useful:

Based on the personal experiences of the director, who made his home in the Peruvian jungle.

Author: burningviolin from San Jose, California
27 March 2001

This film is based on the personal experiences of Armando Robles Godoy who, like the protagonist, abandoned big city life to "colonize" the Peruvian jungle in the 1960s. The director's brother, Mario Godoy, was the cinematographer. Julio Alemán, the Mexican actor who plays Godoy, won a prize for this role. It helps the viewer's understanding of this movie to know that it is based on an episode in the director's life. Surely it was cathartic for him to have told it. I hope it brought him closure to this deeply felt tragedy.

Was the above review useful to you?

7 out of 8 people found the following review useful:

Haunting story of love, life and survival in the forests of Peru.

Author: Deidra Egan from Wisconsin
15 September 1998

Taking his cue from the lush and complex wilderness of Peru, the director surrounds the audience with profuse and fertile images & sounds that will live in memory forever after viewing this film. Time is neither linear not static in this movie; instead events and people pass one another connected merely by the bonds of memory or sensual beauty. This award-winning film from 1972 is as evocative and mesmerizing today as ever with a story that will remain true for as long as civilization competes with the natural world. See this in 35 mm if you can and allow yourself to be surrounded by The Green Wall.

Was the above review useful to you?

7 out of 9 people found the following review useful:

"A masterpiece!" (Roger Ebert).

10/10
Author:
8 November 2005

Based on the experiences of director Armando Robles Godoy as he established his homestead in the Peruvian jungle, The Green Wall is "a bitter and beautiful movie," in which "Godoy translates his experience into film poetry rather than flat reportage and uses the physical environment (exquisitely photographed by his cameraman brother, Mario) as a great natural mystery, idyllic but cruel, rich but unyielding to the will of a handsome young settler (Mexican star Julio Aleman, in a vibrant performance) who is determined to survive there with his family." The idyll is broken both by the bureaucracy in far-off Lima, and at the film's end: "The blow comes from the rain forest near their house, where father and son have constructed a mock city of clay as a symbol of the civilized stupidity they sought to escape. The film's final sequence, an almost wordless funeral, is masterful movie making, a haunting glimpse of humanity that lingers in the mind" (Pauline Kael, The New Yorker). "A masterpiece!" (Roger Ebert).

Was the above review useful to you?

4 out of 4 people found the following review useful:

Urban and rural living collide in this tragic drama.

Author: kilomaster (kilomaster@yahoo.com) from Chicago, Illinois
4 May 2000

This film is mostly about the rural living of a family who moves out of the city. The young boy, Romulo, does not know what the "big city" looks like and he uses his imagination to make his own out in the jungle. His family must deal with their decision, which sometimes brings terrible consequences. The editing and juxtaposition of images make this a true statement between what is right and wrong with the governments of Latin-America. The non-linear way of storytelling is used at it's best, which makes this film all the more interesting.

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 8 people found the following review useful:

Interesting yet confusing movie

Author: (d4dawnie) from Illinois
3 April 2000

I have mixed feelings about La muralla verde. I thought the ending tied the whole move together, but it was painful to sit through the rest of it. Things didn't make sense until the end of the movie, and for me that is too late. There were many flashbacks, and sometimes there was nothing to tell you that it was a flashback. The juxtaposition with the scenes in the jungle and the scenes in the city was done nicely. The differences between the 2 were striking, especially when placed back to back like that. However, some of the camera shots were distracting and irritating, so much so that I had to look away. I found this movie to be interesting because I couldn't imagine a family " roughing it" in the jungle and giving up city life. However, I think this movie was just too distracting and distorted to enjoy watching it and get the whole effect. It definitely shows the major contrasts between the city and the jungle, which is good for learning, but it could have been less confusing and still would have had the same effect.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings Awards External reviews
Plot keywords Main details Your user reviews
Your vote history