|Page 1 of 5:||    |
|Index||44 reviews in total|
63 out of 77 people found the following review useful:
As Good As It Gets, 28 July 2003
This is only the second film I've checked out on IMDB and both have had negative user comments. In this case the person contributing comments was a tad chauvinistic and appeared to be strongly biased against French movies. I am English and can't get enough of French movies,but I also can't get enough of GOOD movies, be they English, American, French, Italian, whatever. Whichever way you slice it Le Cercle Rouge is a masterpiece, shot by a director at, as the cliche has it, the height of his powers. Cool, stylish, slick, professional,call it what you will, it's a winner. Everyone is on top of their game,not least Bourvil in a rare attempt at straight acting - he is best known as a zany comic in a series of box office smashes that don't translate well into English. The Melville schtick, a set-piece, is a doozy this time around, a jewellery heist on the Place Vendome, carried out in total silence in a nod to Rififfi and if anything surpassing it. The sombre,muted tones, embody the sense of cool and also the melancholy that informs the film making anything other than a downbeat ending unthinkable. Like the man said, if you only see one movie this year make it this one.
36 out of 44 people found the following review useful:
The circle, 19 February 2006
Author: jotix100 from New York
Not having seen this film in quite some time, we caught with it not
long ago in the nicely transferred Criterion DVD. "Le cercle rouge" is
a film that owes a lot to other movies, as it keeps reminding us about
"Rififi", "The Asphalt Jungle", among others, because they all deal
with capers that take center stage in the movie and reproduce it in
great detail. Unfortunately, one knows that old adage that crime does
not pay, and from the start, these men involved in it are doomed from
Jean-Pierre Melville was a director of few words. He didn't fill his pictures with a lot of dialog, as it's the case here. Yet, for not being "talky", they had a style of their own as proved with "Le Dolous", "Le Samurai", and his masterpiece, "Bob le flambeur", among others. Mr. Melville had a sense of style that comes across in everything he did. In this film, working with his cinematographer, Henri Decae, he takes us along for a ride through the streets of Paris that shows the vibrant city mainly at night and the bleak winter in France. The score is by Eric Demarsan that emphasizes a jazzy music that accompanies most of the action.
Although the film shows Alain Delon, as Corey, at the center of the action, it is however, the smart inspector Mattei who is the real hero of the movie. As played by the great Bourvil, he is a man that shows a lot of patience because he has figured from the beginning how to catch Vogel, and in the process he gets involved in the investigation of the jewel heist in which he knows the escaped man he is tailing looms large behind it. Bourvil gives an enormously satisfying performance as Mattei showing equal parts of determination and tenderness, as it's the case with the three cats he adores.
Alain Delon always responded with interesting performances his appearances in Mellville's pictures. In here he is Corey, the man who is first seen leaving prison and promising himself he won't go back, but he cannot pass a good thing when he decides to go ahead and participate in the robbery. His association with Vogel and Jansen, pays off in the way they get the job done, but it will also prove a mistake in the way they will not be able to dispose of the loot as the fence they have relied on has a change of heart.
Gian Maria Volonte and Yves Montand are seen as Vogel and Jansen, respectively. They were excellent actors who blend well in the action of the film. Both actors were at their best moment when they took the roles in the film and it shows. Mr. Montand has the more complex character to play as we witness him in his first moment in front of the camera as a man with many demons inside his head.
Jean-Pierre Mellville got wonderful results from his cast and crew in a film, that although feels a bit longer, but still succeeds in showing his style in one of the most memorable pictures from the director.
31 out of 37 people found the following review useful:
Existential doom, 7 December 2006
Author: Camera Obscura from The Dutch Mountains
THE RED CIRCLE (Jean-Pierre Melville - France/Italy 1970).
This might be the coolest film ever made, in the most literal sense of the term. The men here never lose control and never - not once - show their emotions. No dramatic outbursts in this film. Everyone is cool all the time. It's an abstract dream-world, where the men live by their own code, a gangster code with the values of the outside world conspicuously absent. In this masterfully filmed heist saga, Melville tackles the American crime thriller in his distinctly dark and desolate style, yet made in grand fashion with a hefty budget of ten million dollars and with four of the greatest French stars at the time. Alain Delon as the master thief, Yves Montand as an alcoholic ex-cop, Italian star Gian-Maria Volonté as an escaped criminal and André Bourvil in an atypical role as the cynical police chief.
Melville described LE CERCLE ROUGE as his penultimate film and it is indeed a masterfully stylized policier. He also claimed he wanted to shoot a film noir in colour and in many ways he succeeded. The two primary influences for this film were John Huston's 1950 heist movie THE ASPHALT JUNGLE and Jules Dassin's RIFIFI (1955). But unlike these films, where we learn much about the background of the individual gang members, with all their petty needs and worries that motivate them, making clear these are not just ruthless underworld types, but ordinary individuals engaged in a world of everyday worries and human endeavour, Melville, though, tells us almost nothing about his criminals. Why was Corey (Alain Delon) in jail? Why was his associate, Vogel (Jean-Marie Volonté) arrested in the first place? Or why the ex-police marksman Jansen (Yves Montand) left the force, was it his alcoholism? We never learn the motivations behind their actions and never find out what drives these men. Women are even more absent than in his earlier films, with the "emotional" ties exclusively between men. They don't even seem to have personal lives. A sort of an emotional twilight zone and although the setting is not as abstract as in his earlier LE SAMOURAI (1967), Melville still sketches a very eerie world. Melville's favorite actor, Alain Delon, is perfect and almost outdoes himself in coolness, if imaginable.
Deliberately paced and with a length of over 140 minutes, Melville takes his time to tell the story, but its slow pace and length seems a perfect way to show the desolate world these men live in. Nothing is ever out of place in Melville's films and here it's no different, every little detail seemingly of pivotal importance for the story. Although LE SAMOURAI remains my favorite Melville film, even up there with the greatest films ever made, this one also belongs to the very best.
Camera Obscura --- 10/10
23 out of 30 people found the following review useful:
A return to silent majesty?, 24 April 2006
Author: Polaris_DiB from United States
Everyone likes the coolly created, memorable heist movie. Alain Delon
provides the antihero, Melville provides the cool, and a handful of
other great talent (Yves Montand, Gian Maria Volonte, and Andre
Bourvil, mostly) arrives to add a crisp engaging movie...
...with very little dialog. This is great, because one certain aspect of the genre tends to be a lot of dialog involving the quick-witted and their various repartees. This movie, however, could be watched with the sound completely off and not too terribly much would be missed. Not to say the sound is bad, oh no, the jazzy soundtrack and the crisp audio catching the little movements makes the slow, patient deliberation of the patients very compelling.
What's also really neat about this film is that the color cinematography is pretty fantastic. Usually when it comes to cinematography, black and white movies tend to stick out in my mind, but this film has some very strong and beautiful imagery that makes the movie pure visual pleasure to observe.
29 out of 43 people found the following review useful:
Don't Sleep: Melville is the Man!, 18 February 2001
Author: Morris Benjamin from Union Square West
Jean-Pierre Melville is one of the most slept on directors of all time. A little too old to ride the crest of the French New Wave, Melville was respected by Godard, Truffaut and the rest but never caught the attention of the international film community like those who followed him did. Melville's crime tales are directed perfectly straight forward without the hipness that permeated the French New Wave . His protagonist of choice Alain Delon had the ability to portray either cop or crook and the audience would always side with him. "The Red Circle," is one of Melville's best collaborations with Delon--not as good as "Le Samourai" (1967) but superior to "Un Flic" (1971). Nowadays cats tend to say "they don't make movies like that anymore" but "they" weren't making films like Melville during his time--over thirty years ago. Don't sleep on Melville, he's the real deal. To put it simply, Melville was and still is the man.
18 out of 24 people found the following review useful:
One of my new favorite heist pictures: a smooth success for Melville and his cast, 14 January 2004
Author: MisterWhiplash from United States
Jean-Pierre Melville is a director I've only recently gotten acquainted
with (I need to see Bob le Flambeur and Le Samourai again to fully
grasp them), but in watching Le Cercle Rouge (The Red Circle,
supposedly based on a saying in Buddhism) I realized I was watching as
skillful and absorbing a crime film as I had seen in a quite some time.
Though his film has dialog, it is mainly to keep the film's scenes
rolling along, adherent to the plot. What kept me on the alert, even in
seemingly mundane scenes/sequences, was the emphasis on the characters'
movements, or behavior patterns. Melville has his story laid out, and
he is careful to take his time to tell it (this could seem boring to
some, but it does seem to work since he puts a little more emphasis on
the weight of the characters/environments over plot).
Yet look at each of the four main players: Alain Deleon as Corey (just released from prison, scheming a new heist), Gian Maria Volonte as Vogel (escaping & on the lam from hand-cuffed custody, meets Corey by luck), Yves Montand as Jansen (an aged pro with many years of experience with weapons, a friend of Vogel), and Andre Bourvil as Mattei (an experienced investigator, who is on the look-out for Vogel, and on his toes with internal affairs). Each of these actors plays their parts with precision, detachment, and they each have their own kinds of moments that indicate to the audience what their personalities might be besides as criminals and cops. The heist sequence gives little hints, for example, like how Vogel cops-a-feel off a female statue while passing down the halls, or how Jansen takes out a flask and merely has a whiff of the contents (and what a dream this guy creates). Even Corey's movements involving a photograph of a woman arouse interest.
As absorbing and cool the story becomes, and as great the skills were to make it happen (via cinematographer Henri Decae, the editing, and the musical score by Eric Demarsan), it's the people on the screen that gain fascination, in how they stay true to their natures and ideals. Not a film to be missed by French new-wave enthusiasts, and modern-day crime movie buffs might want to take the 140 minutes to soak up the atmosphere of Melville's work. A suave piece of film-making that still ranks as one of my all-time favorites.
26 out of 41 people found the following review useful:
John Woo, please, change your mind., 4 April 2005
Author: Rodion_Raskolnikov from Russia.
I decided to write a comment on this amazing movie because here on IMDb
it is cited that John Woo, a mediocre director who made some decent
films back in his pre-American years but totally ruined his reputation
by his latest, made in US films, plans to remake it. Well, here are a
couple of reasons why it is one of the stupidest ideas for a remake
ever: The plot of the film is simple and even clichéd by today's
standards, but what makes the film a masterpiece is acting by the four
leads, unique direction by Mellville, cinematography, music and its
style. There is no way any director today can make such film, it is
impossible to create such an atmosphere in a movie in today's
Box-office targeted movie business.
John Woo did make a more or less decent film which borrowed from Melville's Le Samourai - The Killer, but remember, it was made when the director was not spoiled by big budgets and expensive (in salaries) but cheap (in acting merits) actors. So what I'm saying is that this is one of the greatest films ever made, together with another film by Melville - Le Samourai. Watch it. And even if the remake will be made, try to avoid it before seeing the great original first.
16 out of 24 people found the following review useful:
While "Le Samourai" had one great lead performance, this has four, 24 December 2006
Author: TimothyFarrell from Worcester, MA
While its not the masterpiece that "Le Samourai" was (I've accepted by
now that Jean-Pierre Melville was never able to top that classic), I
find "Le Cercle Rouge" to be much better than "Bob le flambeur". I felt
that "Bob le flambeur" was an above-average and influential b-film, but
still a b-film. "Le Cercle Rouge" proves that as a filmmaker Melville
improved as he continued. John Woo is a massive fan of Melville, even
though their film-making style differs. While Woo uses fast-motion for
shootouts and an operatic sense of violence, Melville has a minimalist
style that suits him very well. He wasn't interested in creating
quickly paced action films but more meditative crime thrillers. In that
department, he was one of the best.
"Le Samourai" is still his best work, mainly because it has more character development than this, but on a technical level they're probably equal. Besides, while "Le Samourai" had one great lead performance, this has four. Alain Delon is once again an ultra-cool gangster on the prowl - this man's silence is fascinating. Bourvil is superb as the police inspector on the case of the heist and escaped con. He steals every scene he is in, and proves that he was a skilled dramatic actor (in France he is best known as a slapstick comedian in the mode of Buster Keaton). Yves Montand is great also as the shaky and paranoid gun expert. Gian Maria Volontè (a regular in spaghetti westerns) is overshadowed by his three co-stars but still does an adequate job.
Once again, Melville's direction is superb. Taking equal influence from both American crime thrillers and the French new wave, the man always seems to know the best shots and angles to choose. This is more slowly-paced than most caper flicks, but it really pays off by the end. "Le Cercle Rouge" is a bit short of being an absolute classic, but is still one of the best heist flicks ever made. Tarantino must've seen this before making "Reservoir Dogs". (8/10)
6 out of 7 people found the following review useful:
Down-To-Earth Heist Movie, 26 August 2009
Author: Eumenides_0 from Portugal
*** This review may contain spoilers ***
Jean-Pierre Melville's Le Cercle Rouge follows the lives of two
criminals: Vogel (Gian Maria Volontè), a murderer who gives the cops
the slip while he's being transferred from one city to another by
train; and Corey (Allain Delon), a thief just released from jail. Fate
decides to join these two men to pull off a spectacular heist. In the
background there is Matei (André Bourvil), the detective Vogel escapes
from, implacable in his pursuit and sometimes ruthless in his methods.
Along the movie the viewer meets other minor but fascinating
characters, the best of which is Jansen (Yves Montand), a disgraced
ex-cop and an excellent marksman.
Melville has such a unique style one doesn't need to watch many of his movies to catch on. Le Samourai, Un Flic and Le Cercle Rouge are clearly made of the same cloth: the symmetrical angles; the long shots; the silences; the coats and hats and cigars; the quotes at the beginning; the amazing heists, the fatalism; the unglamorous and inglorious criminal life. Everything that's great in Melville is present here in top form.
And his shortcomings didn't bother me so much this time: the illogical, perplexing behavior of his characters and confusing storytelling, which hurt my enjoyment of his other movies, are almost invisible here. Since Le Cercle Rouge preceded Un Flic that doesn't mean he got better with time; perhaps I'm just getting more used to it and reaching a mindset where it doesn't bother me anymore.
Melville made unique crime movies. As old as they may be, they show more ingenuity, realism and grace than the modern techno-thrillers in which cool thieves use computer systems and James Bond-esquire gadgets to pull off impossible crimes. Melville's criminals aren't cool: they're lonely, socially awkward and probably aware they're not good for much more than planning heists. They're society's unwanted, living in the night, always one step ahead of the police in a game they know they'll lose eventually. There's nothing romantic about them.
Amazingly for a movie of this type, the cops aren't complete idiots either. Matei is smart, crafty, patient and even compassionate. He's not an unlikeable villain or a cliché, he's just an old man doing his job and doing it right. He knows when to use force and when to use brains. Many movies could learn from him.
It's this down-to-earth, unromantic style that makes Melville's movies such a joy to watch and puts him on a special pedestal as one of cinema's great crime masters.
3 out of 4 people found the following review useful:
Melville's masterpiece?, 6 September 2010
Author: JasparLamarCrabb from Boston, MA
*** This review may contain spoilers ***
One of the best heist films and arguably Jean-Pierre Melville's masterpiece. Recently sprung con Alain Delon teams up with recent escaped con Gian Maria Volonté and ex-cop Yves Montand to rob a jewelry store. Things would be as smooth as silk if it weren't for André Bourvil's policeman relentlessly pursuing Volonté. Melville's exceptional thriller takes its time unfolding but is never dull. Delon and Volonté have great chemistry and Montand is terrific as a world weary drunk (he actually hallucinates while drying out; it's a really creepy scene). The bleak cinematography by Henri Decaë captures a gloomy Paris in winter and there's a stunning, albeit sparsely used, music score by Éric Demarsan. The supporting cast includes André Ekyan as one of Delon's sleazy cohorts and François Périer as a very reluctant informer. Bourvil, who died before the film's release, steals the show as a wily modern day Inspector Javert.
|Page 1 of 5:||    |
|Plot summary||Ratings||Newsgroup reviews|
|External reviews||Parents Guide||Plot keywords|
|Main details||Your user reviews||Your vote history|