Custer of the West (1967)

Director:

Robert Siodmak

Writers (WGA):

Bernard Gordon (written by) and
Julian Zimet (written by) (originally as Julian Halevy)

Release Date:

24 January 1968 (USA)

Genre:

Biography | Western

Tagline:

A man too big for legend - A motion picture too big for any screen except CINERAMA [UK theatrical]

Plot:

George Armstrong Custer's love of the heroic traditions of the Calvary and his distaste with the coming of industrialization leads him to his destiny at the Little Big Horn.

Plot Keywords:

Little Big Horn | Log Flume | General Custer | Congress | Desert

Cast

Robert Shaw	...	Gen. George Armstrong Custer
Mary Ure	...	Elizabeth Custer
Ty Hardin	...	Maj. Marcus Reno
Jeffrey Hunter	...	Capt. Benteen
Lawrence Tierney	...	Gen. Philip Sheridan
Marc Lawrence	...	The gold miner
Kieron Moore	...	Chief Dull Knife
Charles Stalmaker	...	Lt. Howells (as Charles Stalnaker)
Robert Hall	...	Sgt. Buckley
Jack Gaskins
Jack Taylor
John Clark
Fred Kohler Jr.		(as Fred Kohler)
Bill Christmas
Luis Rivera

Also Known As:

A Good Day for Fighting (short version)
Custer (USA) (working title)

Runtime:

140 min | USA:143 min

Country:

USA

Language:

English

Color:

Color (Technicolor)

Aspect Ratio:

2.20 : 1

Sound Mix:

70 mm 6-Track (70 mm prints) (Westrex Recording System)

Certification:

Singapore:PG | West Germany:12 | UK:U | Finland:K-16 | Norway:16 | Sweden:11 | USA:G | Canada:G (Quebec) | Canada:PG (Ontario)

Filming Locations:

Almería, Andalucía, Spain

Company:

Cinerama Productions Corp.

Trivia:

Originally to be directed by Akira Kurosawa, but he pulled out.

Goofs:

Continuity: During the Indian raid of the town Fourth of July celebration, we see the attackers swarm into the saloon, where there's a plain wooden wall centered behind the bar. A moment later, a large mirror appears on that same plain wall and falls on an Indian, revealing the scene we just saw a few seconds earlier, which just tells us that the shots were edited out of sequence.

Quotes:

Gen. George Armstrong Custer: War isn't just killing, you know. It's a contest. It's a man against a man.
[indicates a Gatling gun]
Gen. George Armstrong Custer: That's a machine! Personal courage wouldn't count. Honor, duty, loyalty - everything a soldier lives by - would be wiped out. All you would have left is statistics. How many men would the machine murder today? One hundred? One thousand? Ten thousand? If this is the future, I don't want any part of it.

Soundtrack:

FOLLOW CUSTER

Curiously interesting film has only a little to offer.

An unusual cast was gathered for this tribute to a western hero whose accomplishments in real life are dubious to say the least. Scholars and history buffs can argue the facts and merits of General George Armstrong Custer. This review pertains to the actual film. It begins with a very odd credits sequence in which Shaw and Ure are billed as starring, then the title comes up and then zilch. No other actors or crew are mentioned. Then four years of Civil War battles are represented by years popping up on screen as Shaw tears across what looks like the same field on horseback while cannons blast continuously. So much for establishing his war record...from this he basically outran some cannons for four years straight! He gets new orders from superior Tierney (brandishing a very contemporary accent that's just as jarring as Shaw's own British-tinged one) and is soon headed out west to rid the land of Indians. First, he is reunited with his wife (in real life as well) Ure in a series of brief, strange vignettes as they travel to his new post. Once there, he is greeted by a haggard-looking Hunter (who would be dead in real life within a year) and fit, yummy Hardin (miscast as a drunkard.) In fact, the film ties with "Ride the Wild Surf" as having the most cast members change their usual looks for their roles. Brown-haired Shaw goes blonde, blonde Ure goes auburn, Hunter's hair is longer and bushy with fake gray highlights and Hardin's blonde locks are brown and he sports a huge moustache. Ryan, as a soldier who deserts to find gold, pops in long enough to show up everyone else and display what good acting can be. The film details Shaw's struggle to solve the "Indian problem". The government wants rid of them, yet he sees, to an extent, their plight. Unfortunately, the film is so episodic and disjointed in it's scripting that it can't build very much momentum or create a memorable story. Though it is long, the audience never really gets to know the characters very well. A lot of time is spent on rather elaborate set pieces (some of which are impressive) like a wagon wreck, a ride down a log flume, an attack on a train and the final stand off. Another chunk of time is wasted in ludicrous Washington scenes which include a cheaply done speech by Shaw before Congress and a (deliberately?) horrible stage show. (Shaw wrote the lyrics of one of the songs himself!) One of the best sequences involves Shaw's attempt to show his men who is boss through a rigorous training exercise in which all but one fall down completely. One major asset is the wide-screen photography which shows off some nice scenery and a few inventive compositions. The finale, with its horde of Indian warriors, is surely best seen in the letterboxed format. It's surprising to see such an old fashioned us (Cavalry) vs them (Indians) approach in a 1968 film, four years after "Cheyenne Autumn". Aspirations to tell a complex version of the tale are done in by sketchy characterizations and poor performances by some of the supporting cast (including Moore as the primary Indian chief.) The score is distracting and often overly loud. The acting is uneven. The editing is profanely awkward. In the end, the audience has not been enlightened to any degree and has watched a two hour and twenty minute film in which Hardin didn't even take his shirt off once!