Reviews & Ratings for
The Assassin More at IMDbPro »Da ci ke (original title)

12 out of 12 people found the following review useful:
THE ASSASSIN - Wang Yu as a conflicted swordsman hero in old China, 21 May 2001
Author: Brian Camp from Bronx, NY

THE ASSASSIN (1967) is one of a series of swordplay adventures starring Jimmy Wang Yu made at Hong Kong's Shaw Bros. studio in the 1960s. This one is less bloody and action-packed and more austere and character-driven, closer in tone and style to the Japanese samurai films of the era but with a very Chinese flavor in terms of the visual look and melodramatic feel.

The emphasis is on the conflict between ambition and obligation with the latter playing a key role here in the life of a valiant swordsman in old China (2300 years ago!). Wang Yu plays Nieh Cheng, a champion sword-fighter who is forced to go into hiding when his school is attacked by political rivals and his teacher and all his fellow students killed. A year later he is sought out by Yen, a minister-in-exile (Tien Feng) who requires his services in a political assassination, one that will enable Nieh to avenge the death of his teacher. Despite the offer of great payment and a ceremony in which he becomes the minister's sworn brother, Nieh declines the job because he's the sole support of his mother and sister. Years later, after his mother has died and his sister is married, he seeks out the minister and accepts the job. But first he has to locate his old sweetheart (Chiao Chiao) to provide her with gifts, which she at first tearfully declines, and spend a night with her before he goes off on what is essentially a suicide mission.

In the course of the film's two-hour length, there are really only four fight scenes, two of them quite short. The final action scene, as Wang Yu attacks the Palace to get at the Prime Minster is a bit far-fetched as he slashes his sword through dozens of soldiers and they are unable to stop him. He even does some high leaping and short flights in the air, a power he didn't display earlier in the film.

Still, it's a compelling and rich film with strong characters, excellent acting and fascinating interplay of characters' social roles and the accompanying little rituals and ceremonies. It's all very well acted and beautifully photographed on a mix of studio sets and outdoor backlots. Viewers who like Japanese samurai films, many of which offer less action in favor of characters and relationships should like this also. It's not as bloody and stylized as other Shaw Bros. movies of the time nor is the melodrama as overwrought. HK action fans will probably prefer such later Wang Yu films as ONE-ARMED BOXER, BEACH OF THE WAR GODS and BLOOD OF THE DRAGON, although this one boasts a stronger story and more complex character.

The only real problem here is a curious patched-together music score with some lyrical Chinese melodies and one lovely choral song intercut with a persistent annoying guitar riff, loud drum rolls and entire cues lifted wholesale from John Barry's score for the James Bond film YOU ONLY LIVE TWICE (also 1967). The Tai Seng VHS edition of this film is in Mandarin with English subtitles with a full-frame transfer that cuts off the subtitles on the sides, making some lines of dialogue a challenge to decipher.

Addendum: (10/6/07) I have since watched the restored/remastered letter-boxed Region 3 DVD of this film from Celestial Pictures. It's beautiful. Seeing in its proper aspect ratio allows one to appreciate the formal qualities of the direction, the attention to visual detail and an eye for color, lighting and composition that weren't always given such free reign in Chang Cheh's numerous other films. Also, being able to read the subtitles in their entirety allows one to appreciate the concise, elegant writing (also by Chang Cheh) and the distillation of each dialogue scene to its essential points, establishing each character's position clearly and believably as a story of moral, filial and romantic obligation takes on epic proportions. All this is most evident in the scenes between Nie Zheng (as his name is spelled in the new subtitles) and the various women in his life, most notably his sweetheart, Xia Ying (Chiao Chiao), his sister, Nie Rong (Li Hsiang-Chun), and his mother (an actress I haven't been able to identify). Seeing it again, in this high-quality version, and being moved by it even more deeply, compels me to consider it one of the finest Shaw Bros. productions ever.

As for the music, the original soundtrack does indeed contain the music cues from YOU ONLY LIVE TWICE, but they didn't bother me at all this time. Perhaps the restoration process involved smoothing over rough spots in the soundtrack as well, since the different parts of the score blend in so much better here and don't sound "patched-together" at all.

THE ASSASSIN has something in common with Zhang Yimou's HERO (2002) and Chen Kaige's THE EMPEROR AND THE ASSASSIN (1998). All were based on incidents from Chinese history taking place around 300-400 B.C., and recorded in the early Chinese historical text, "Records of the Great Historian," by Sima Qian.

2 out of 3 people found the following review useful:
One of the greatest Shaw Brothers productions, but it's very serious stuff, 7 June 2010

Author: roegcamel from United States

THE ASSASSIN probably isn't what you're looking for if you're seeking a fast-paced, fight-laden kung fu flick. It's a long, deliberately paced film with more emphasis on drama and character interaction than on-screen fighting, but it does manage to deliver on that level (to put it mildly) in the third act. Prior to that, expect to see very little action.

That said, this is a masterpiece. It's one of the smartest and most dramatically impressive films of the entire Shaw cannon and patient viewers will find it to be a rewarding and thoughtful film. Jimmy Wang-Yu (rarely better) stars as the assassin of the title, a young warrior whose life's ambition is to kill the leader of a militia group that is responsible for the killings of his fellow students, among others. He falls in love with his childhood sweetheart, but even her pleas for him to stay with her can't supersede his desires to get bloody. To say more would be criminal.

Again, this is not an action film, but the finale is something to behold for fans of such movies. Is it worth the wait? Definitely. Does Wang-Yu display his martial arts abilities? Here and there, but you'll have to wait for the final act to see him really explode. It's stunningly well made (after all, it was directed by the great Chang Cheh, and it's one of his best films) and the script is dynamite.

Don't miss THE ASSASSIN. However, if it's wall-to-wall action you seek, you might look elsewhere. This one's for serious filmgoers.

Add another review

Related Links