The residents of Collinwood become exasperated with Elizabeth for employing Jason. Roger tells Carolyn her father's leftover possessions are locked in the mysterious room in the basement, so she becomes obsessed with finding the key.
While Sheriff Patterson responds to Sam's report of claiming to have seen Maggie, Barnabas locates her and imprisons her inside his coffin in the mausoleum for the night as a punishment for leaving the house.
Dr. Hoffman tells Dr. Woodard Maggie's condition is the result of a brush with the supernatural. Burke questions Julia's motives for investigating the Collins' ancestry. Sarah reveals to David Maggie isn't dead.
Julia speculates that Barnabas may have willed Sarah to return from the dead. Elizabeth becomes suspicious of Julia's work. Victoria accepts Burke's proposal and formally announces their engagement, much to the disgust of Barnabas.
Victoria comes to the realization that the mysterious young Sarah may be able to shed light on many unanswered questions concerning Maggie's amnesia. Also, Victoria and Burke quarrel over his investigation of Barnabas.
David awakens from a nightmare that he was about to be eaten by Barnabas, so he confides fear of his cousin to Burke. Barnabas, meanwhile, fears Maggie will expose him, so he makes plans to eliminate her.
Julia assures Barnabas a letter exposing him will be turned over to the authorities if she or Maggie turn up dead, but Willie is unconvinced that her ruse was successful. Meanwhile Maggie is comforted by Sarah's doll.
A psychiatrist analyzes David. Elizabeth informs Burke that there's a clause in an old family will which prevents her from selling him the house. Dr. Woodard decides to take another look at the mausoleum.
Barnabas and Julia are each perplexed by Dr. Woodard's investigation into Barnabas's affairs. Meanwhile Elizabeth offers to reopen the west wing of the family mansion for Victoria and Burke to live in.
Dr. Woodard breaks into Julia's room and steals her notes on the treatment of Barnabas. Meanwhile Roger has a conniption fit over Elizabeth's decision to let Burke and Vicki live in the west wing of the family mansion.
Sarah tells David that Dr. Woodard has died, so Carolyn tries to console him by telling of her childhood friend. As Burke prepares to leave for a business trip, everyone's perplexed when David says his final goodbyes.
Julia's treatments backfire and Barnabas shows his true age, so she suggests he replenish his blood with Victoria's. Meanwhile, Carolyn begins to have doubts that David was making up stories about Barnabas.
Feeling David is psychologically disturbed, Elizabeth plans to send him away, so Carolyn takes it upon herself to investigate the basement of the old house. Meanwhile Julia offers to let an aged Barnabas suck her blood.
Dr. Julia Hoffman suggests that they hold a séance to contact Sarah Collins. Barnabas objects, but joins the ceremony when he realizes it can't be stopped. Victoria goes into a trance, and Sarah speaks through her.
1795 time period. Victoria panics when she sees Matthew Morgan lookalike Ben Stokes. Joshua threatens Ben and then tells Victoria that Millicent will marry Jeremiah. Angelique makes Ben help her in her plans for Josette.
Natalie tells Andre that they in the presence of a force for evil. Andre confronts Jeremiah over his meeting Josette.Natalie's tarot cards revel to Naomi death and betrayal. Naomi sees Jeremiah and a woman in a dream.
1795 time period. Natalie convinces Barnabas and Josette to marry immediately but Angelique casts a spell on Josette while helping her with her wedding dress. Ben tries to kill the cat but Angelique stops him.
1795 time period. Barnabas searches for Josette while Angelique schemes for his love. She refuses to use a love spell on him but she does send him a stranger in a vision. Barnabas finds Josette's veil.
Taped 12-12-1967. 1795 time period. Natalie consults her Tarot cards to learn where Victoria is. She tells Nathan and Barnabas and Angelique that Trask has Victoria. Angelique burns the tree after Nathan and Barnabas rescue Victoria. Angelique burns the tree.