IMDb > Senior Prom (1958) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
Senior Prom More at IMDbPro »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 4 reviews in total 

6 out of 8 people found the following review useful:

Entertaining B Columbia Musical co-produced by Moe

Author: lzf0 from United States
15 October 2009

"Senior Prom" is a real movie musical comedy. It is nothing like the early Rock 'n Roll movies made by Columbia, as well as other studios, during this period. There is a Broadway quality score with music by Don Gohman and lyrics by Hal Hackady. Hackady was a good theatrical writer who never seemed to be able to hit it big on Broadway. His work compares well with other Broadway writers of this period. The film is filled with integrated musical numbers performed by Jill Corey, Jimmie Komack, and Barbara Bostock. The plot isn't much. Singer Paul Hampton, in his first real acting role, has recorded a song, but it hasn't received much of a push. For a subplot, Tom "Billy Jack" Laughlin is trying to get Louis Prima and Keely Smith to appear at his prom. Hampton is a bit stiff as an actor and weak as a singer. Jill Corey, as his romantic interest, sings well (as always), and is quite natural as an actress. It is a shame that she did not appear in any other film. Jimmie Komack, who was a hit as the Alfred E. Newman look-a-like in "Damn Yankees", has the major comedy role. He is quite good, even though he doesn't have the best material to work with. Komack later became a successful producer-director-writer, especially for television. Somewhere in the film there are incomplete cameo musical appearances by Bob Crosby, Toni Arden, Mitch Miller (playing the oboe), an older Connee Boswell, and Freddie Martin and his orchestra. Here we are cheated. I only wish these performers had been given full numbers. During the show sequence, Jill Corey sings a new pop song by Lee Pockriss and Peter Udell that should have been a hit, but they did better with "Itsy Bitsy Teeny Weeny Yellow Polka Dot Bikinis Sealed with a Kiss"!

The strangest aspect of the film is its time and music. It should be using early Rock 'n Roll, but luckily for us, we get a Broadway style score with big band style pop interpolations. The setting of the film seems more like 1948 than 1958. However, it is a pleasant way to spend 85 minutes.

Was the above review useful to you?

7 out of 10 people found the following review useful:

Pleasantly surprised & Entertained; Nice little late 50s Musicfest

6/10
Author: spencer benedict from United States
15 October 2009

When i tuned into this unfamiliar film on TCM today, i had not planned on sticking around long for at first glance it appeared to be your run-of-the-mill 50's boring Leave It To Beaveresque high school Love/Crush romp. And besides it only scored 2 out of 4 stars on the cable film guide but what i found is that i never wanted to change the channel.

I must say it was pretty cool seeing Tom Laughlin in an early role as i was a big Billy Jack fan when i was a kid (still am). He showed the same raw intensity in this film as Carter Breed the 3rd, steely eyes and gritting teeth, as he did in his 1971 landmark part Indian role as the karate sheriff/punk ass kicking Billy Jack.

The film is filled with entertaining and memorable cameo musical performances by entertainers of the era. Seeing Ed Sullivan in his small cameo presenting an award in a seemingly half scripted, half ad-libbed sort of way brought a smile.

I made my entrance expecting to mill about for a short time and quickly depart for more exciting filmdom adventure but found the atmosphere quite appealing and cozy so i stuck around longer than was expected to the happy end. All around good natured light hearted fare to pass a little time.

Was the above review useful to you?

Jose Melis is the Real Highlight...

8/10
Author: kidboots from Australia
22 March 2013

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

....with his amazing piano skills and he really wows the crowd at a concert with "El Cumbanchero"!! Top stuff. This movie reminded me more of the type of "youth musical" they were making in England at the time eg "Jazz Boat". Maybe this movie jinxed the careers of the two star singers, pretty Jill Corey who as the rich girl, Gay Sheridan, was given the romantic ballads (of which there were many) and the very talented Barbara Bostock as the wacky Flip who handled the upbeat novelty songs. Her songs were standouts - "Now is the Time" and "I Hear Music" which took place on a beach and where Flip and Dog kidded the love scene in "From Here to Eternity". I thought "whatever happened to Barbara Bostock?" but when I went researching, the answer was not much. Either way there was small pickings for Bostock and Corey after this film, an uneasy blend of teen movie and musical comedy which had the players bursting into unforgettable songs at the drop of a hat. I thought surely Bostock had a Broadway career because she didn't do many films or television work, but all I could find was "Silk Stockings" where she was buried as a dancer. Such a waste of her talents.

The film could have gone with a dramatic theme but that was passed over in favour of lightweight entertainment. Rich, beautiful Gay Sheridan loses her heart to humble singer, Tom Harper (Paul Hampton), part of a combo that is hired to perform during the intermission of a sorority party. Tom, an aspiring singer, who has already cut a forgotten (but not for long) single when he was struggling in New York, is at college on a scholarship and runs up against snooty rich kid Carter Breed Third ("you mean there are two others like him running around"!!) (Tom Laughlin, in a very intense performance). Carter has promised a stellar lineup of performers for the Senior Prom but finds he cannot deliver.

One of the problems is that the lead singer is just not that great and it is also pretty hard to believe that he bests husky Carter in a fight which finishes in the Sheridan pool. And Mrs. Sheridan (Frieda Inescourt) is not impressed - she had hopes that Gay and Carter would someday be married and Tom's poverty and lowly status do not find favour. I remember Frieda Inescourt from the golden age of Hollywood, usually playing shy, refined types (she was just terrific with Lucille Ball in "Beauty For the Asking") but in this she was so stilted - as if she'd rather be anywhere than on this particular set.

In fact it is Tom who comes through with the stars - Bob Crosby, sounding very much like Bing, Connee Boswell proving she could still belt out a song after 30 years in the business ("When the Saints Go Marching In") and the hit of the Prom, the irrepressible Louis Prima and Keely Smith make memorable "Old Black Magic".

An interesting experiment, the young talent were good but the songs weren't that memorable and there were too many. Also the big name guests (apart from Louis Prima) only sang portions of their songs, giving one the feeling that they were filmed separately and that they weren't at the Prom.

Still Recommended.

Was the above review useful to you?

4 out of 11 people found the following review useful:

None o'dat rock and roll!!!!

1/10
Author: bux from Tecumseh ok
19 October 2009

Yeah, I can see the producer pitching this one..."And there will be none of that damn Rock and Roll in MY picture...we'll feature REAL music!" Of course the "real" music is hammed-up show tunes with warmed over melodies and lyrics, sung by actors(?) that came straight off of Hollywood's D list.

Now they did have Louis and Keely, but you had to suffer through to the bitter end to see them. And who the hell were all the other "big names" that appeared at the prom? I was in High School in '58 and didn't recognize many of them...maybe Ed Sullivan.

And the biggest curse of all in this lame little loser? Tom (Billy Jack) Loughlin getting his butt whipped by some fair-haired fairy dude.

How did MST3K miss this one?

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Ratings External reviews Main details
Your user reviews Your vote history