Second Fiddle (1957) Poster

(1957)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Elvey's last!
JohnHowardReid11 September 2016
Warning: Spoilers
At least the unusual advertising background gives this little romantic comedy a bit of interest and the splendid efforts of the support cast do largely overcome the lethargy induced by Maurice Elvey's tired and totally uninspired direction. This was Elvey's 195th and final movie. He died in 1967. He was formerly a Broadway actor and stage director. He started directing movies way back in 1913. So it's a real shame he didn't go out on a better note than this! Admittedly, the lead players in this movie, namely Thorley Walters, Adrienne Corri and Lisa Gastoni, are disappointingly colorless – though some of the minor players, particularly Richard Wattis and Bill Fraser, certainly give attractive accounts of their screen characters – and production values are similarly mediocre, especially the uncompromisingly drab photography contributed by Arthur Graham.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
uninspiring supporting feature
malcolmgsw26 September 2016
This is a fairly undistinguished supporting whose only point of interest is he fact the working women were expected to give up their careers when they got married.There was no protection for women against being fired for this reason.Adrienne Corrie is so brilliant that Bill Frasier convinces his board of directors to change their policy.Incidentally at this time Frasier was having a great success on TV as Sergeant Major Smudge in The Army Game.His is the best performance followed by Richard Wattis.Adrienne in an early role is reasonable enough as the ambitious advertising executive.This film is pretty unphotogenic and could have been easily made as a radio or television play.Clearly no expense was incurred in the making of this film.The direction can at best be called perfunctory.This is proof of the fact that the better supporting features were thrillers.No wonder the director retired after this.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Here's to the women who earn mens beer money"
ygwerin125 February 2020
Warning: Spoilers
A point missed in reviews for this film is the perennial social division in society, between men and women.

It starts with an Advertisement Agency that only employ single women, why?

Because of the patriarchal attitude of men being head of the family. When women were expected, to just be wives and mothers.

The company changed their minds only because, they couldn't afford to lose their best employee when she got married.

My point is that the attitudes towards women remained, even after they get their well deserved promotion.

Women are still expected to be the homemakers there to ensure, their husbands dinners are cooked and shirts have buttons replaced.

When Deborah gets her well earned promotion in the States, Charles nose is put out of joint. He is jealous that its his wife getting promoted, and not him. And when everyone else but him hears about her every move, he can only think of how he is effected.

When Deborah returns home to tell husband Charles she is pregnant, and talked about stopping work. Charles is more concerned about how soon after the birth she will be able to return to work.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Devil's Elbow
richardchatten22 February 2020
Set in the 'glamorous' world of advertising and marking the unique pairing of Adrienne Corri & Thorley Walters both cast well against type as bright-eyed & bushy-tailed young newlyweds. This would-be sophisticated comedy sinks under drab photography and perfunctory direction by the justly neglected and by now decidedly elderly Maurice Elvey whose final film it marked before his well-earned and long overdue retirement.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Romance in the advertising world
louiseculmer25 February 2020
Quite an amusing story set in the world of advertising. Deborah (Adrienne Cori) and Charles (Thorley Walters) both work for the same advertising firm and are soon to be married. But the firm is old fashioned, and does not employ married women, it seems Deborah will be fired when they marry. But the firm changes its policy so Deborah can stay on. Predictably this leads to some problems, with both trying to keep up with office and housework, not to mention Charles getting jealous when Deborah seems to be having more success, and Deborah getting jealous when a glamorous blonde at work seems to have her eye on Charles. I found it all quite entertaining,
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
And then he slipped away, unnoticed
boblipton5 March 2006
Maurice Elvey's last film is a brittle comedy with a serious theme as an old-line British advertising firm finally decides to not automatically fire women after they get married.... and the newly married leads find out that progress has its costs.

Elvey had a long career in British films, forty-four years behind the camera and almost two hundred films, sometimes head of production at his studio, but he seems to have been the forgotten man of the British cinema. With a few exceptions, his works are not well remembered and even his best-known successes, such as HINDLE WAKES have their flair attributed to others. Part of this is that he has no easily recognized style: his choices always serve the picture, rather than changing the picture to suit his style. Critics, film students and reviewers always like it when you can tell who directed a film without actually having to read the credits. Elvey was too canny for that. Let's look at a couple of tricks he pulls out of his pocket that you might not notice if you weren't looking for them.

In this movie, Elvey's camera is largely still; the few sequences in which it moves - in particular, a scene in which the wife is about to leave on a business trip -- the camera moves only to maintain composition.

This being a working class comedy, even if the people are upper class workers, Elvey has an air of depression and cheapness in the details, from the annoying radio jingles to the way doors sound when they close, to the way that water heaters refuse to work properly. This is a very accomplished rendition of what could have been another meaningless programmer, like so much of Elvey's work.

The film industry was collapsing, not only in Britain, but over the world. Someone had to retire, and who better than a seventy-year-old back number like Elvey? People never knew what they missed.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed