 | Bud Collyer | ... | Himself - Host (400 episodes, 1956-1968) |

| Kitty Carlisle | ... | Herself - Panelist / ... (359 episodes, 1957-1968) |

| Tom Poston | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (296 episodes, 1959-1968) |

| Polly Bergen | ... | Herself - Panelist (165 episodes, 1956-1961) |
 | Peggy Cass | ... | Herself - Panelist / ... (156 episodes, 1960-1981) |
 | Bern Bennett | ... | Himself - Announcer / ... (128 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| Orson Bean | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (106 episodes, 1963-1968) |
 | Hy Gardner | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (94 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Don Ameche | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (84 episodes, 1957-1961) |
 | Johnny Olson | ... | Himself - Announcer (67 episodes, 1960-1968) |
 | Ralph Bellamy | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (66 episodes, 1957-1962) |

| Betty White | ... | Herself - Panelist / ... (39 episodes, 1958-1963) |

| Johnny Carson | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (37 episodes, 1960-1962) |
 | Robert Q. Lewis | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (28 episodes, 1958-1966) |

| Dina Merrill | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist / ... (22 episodes, 1961-1963) |
 | Barry Nelson | ... | Himself - Panelist (15 episodes, 1962-1967) |
 | John Cameron Swayze | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (14 episodes, 1957-1960) |
 | Gene Rayburn | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (14 episodes, 1962-1965) |

| Jackie Cooper | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (13 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Sally Ann Howes | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist / ... (11 episodes, 1962-1964) |

| Ann Sheridan | ... | Herself (10 episodes, 1963-1965) |
 | Phyllis Newman | ... | Herself - Panelist / ... (10 episodes, 1963-1964) |

| Jayne Meadows | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist / ... (8 episodes, 1957-1961) |

| Joan Fontaine | ... | Herself / ... (8 episodes, 1958-1966) |
 | Hildy Parks | ... | Herself - Panelist (7 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| Merv Griffin | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (7 episodes, 1958-1963) |

| Betty Furness | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (7 episodes, 1957-1964) |
 | Monique van Vooren | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (6 episodes, 1959) |
 | Abe Burrows | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist / ... (6 episodes, 1957-1964) |
 | Faye Emerson | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist / ... (6 episodes, 1960-1961) |
 | Sam Levenson | ... | Himself / ... (6 episodes, 1961-1964) |
 | Eamonn Andrews | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist / ... (5 episodes, 1957-1963) |
 | Tom Ewell | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (5 episodes, 1958-1962) |
 | Jim Backus | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (5 episodes, 1958) |

| Dick Van Dyke | ... | Himself - Panelist / ... (5 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Mimi Benzell | ... | Herself - Panelist / ... (5 episodes, 1962-1963) |
 | Jack Paar | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (4 episodes, 1957) |
 | Mary Healy | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist / ... (4 episodes, 1957) |

| Chester Morris | ... | Himself / ... (4 episodes, 1959-1964) |
 | Jim Fleming | ... | Himself - Substitute Host / ... (4 episodes, 1960) |

| Betsy Palmer | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (3 episodes, 1957-1965) |
 | Julia Meade | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist / ... (3 episodes, 1959-1960) |
 | Kyle Rote | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1963) |

| Martin Gabel | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (3 episodes, 1957-1963) |
 | Peter Donald | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (3 episodes, 1959) |
 | Margot Moser | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist / ... (3 episodes, 1961-1962) |

| Pat Carroll | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist / ... (3 episodes, 1961) |
 | Allen Ludden | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (3 episodes, 1962-1963) |
 | Henry Morgan | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist / ... (3 episodes, 1963-1967) |
 | Bess Myerson | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (3 episodes, 1965-1967) |
 | Arthur Schwartz | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1958-1960) |
 | Sonny Fox | ... | Himself - Substitute Host (2 episodes, 1959) |

| Mitch Miller | ... | Himself - Contestant / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Conrad Nagel | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1958) |

| Mike Wallace | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Baby LeRoy | ... | Himself (2 episodes, 1957) |

| Celeste Holm | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1958) |

| Keenan Wynn | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1958) |

| Dana Wynter | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Joyce Davidson | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1961) |
 | Peggy King | ... | Herself - Guest Panelist / ... (2 episodes, 1961) |
 | Dorothy Kilgallen | ... | Herself / ... (2 episodes, 1962-1965) |
 | Peter Lind Hayes | ... | Himself / ... (2 episodes, 1962-1964) |
 | Elliott Reid | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist / ... (2 episodes, 1963-1964) |

| Ossie Davis | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1963) |

| Eli Wallach | ... | Himself (2 episodes, 1963) |
 | Peter Lake | ... | Himself (2 episodes, 1964-1966) |
 | Bill Cullen | ... | Himself - Guest Panelist (2 episodes, 1964-1965) |