 | Richard Joy | ... | Himself - Announcer (39 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Charles Bickford | ... | Captain Joel Kingdom / ... (8 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| Kim Hunter | ... | Anna Rojas / ... (8 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| Franchot Tone | ... | Allen Grant / ... (7 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| Peter Lorre | ... | Café Owner / ... (6 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| James Mason | ... | Hans Frick / ... (6 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Melvyn Douglas | ... | Ansel Gibbs / ... (5 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Barry Sullivan | ... | Capt. Schuyler 'Sky' Hobart / ... (5 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Diana Lynn | ... | Anne Gibbs / ... (5 episodes, 1956-1959) |
 | Katharine Bard | ... | Kate Keller / ... (5 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Patty McCormack | ... | Helen Keller / ... (5 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Elizabeth Patterson | ... | Aunt Ida / ... (5 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| Cliff Robertson | ... | Himself (host) / ... (5 episodes, 1958-1960) |

| Mary Astor | ... | Eileen Bavister / ... (5 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Nehemiah Persoff | ... | Pablo / ... (5 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Sterling Hayden | ... | Col. Rocky Templeton / ... (5 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Marc Lawrence | ... | El Sordo / ... (5 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Carl Benton Reid | ... | Judge / ... (5 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Rod Taylor | ... | Bob Castillo / ... (5 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Keenan Wynn | ... | Lou Myrick / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Jackie Coogan | ... | Bender / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| H.M. Wynant | ... | Henshaw / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1959) |

| E.G. Marshall | ... | Beria / ... (4 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Victor Jory | ... | Capt. Hume / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1959) |
 | Lawrence Dobkin | ... | Elbaum / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1959) |
 | Eddie Ryder | ... | Jake / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1959) |
 | Frank Lovejoy | ... | Himself - Announcing Next Week's Show / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1959) |

| Eli Wallach | ... | Rafael / ... (4 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Everett Sloane | ... | Col. John Templeton / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| Vincent Price | ... | Alex / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Dana Wynter | ... | Host / ... (4 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Leif Erickson | ... | Ben Riggs / ... (4 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Hedda Hopper | ... | Herself / ... (4 episodes, 1957) |
 | Robert F. Simon | ... | Brady / ... (4 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Tom Palmer | ... | Eaton / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| Van Heflin | ... | Bill Kilcoyne / ... (4 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| John Williams | ... | Lord Summerly / ... (4 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| James Whitmore | ... | Capt. Miles Shay / ... (4 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| John Hoyt | ... | Dr. Gordon Harper / ... (4 episodes, 1958-1960) |

| Celia Lovsky | ... | Madam Guibert / ... (4 episodes, 1958-1960) |

| Dick York | ... | Matthew Sherwood / ... (4 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Jack Palance | ... | Harlan 'Mountain' McClintock / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Art Carney | ... | Ernie Pandish / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Jane Darwell | ... | Annie Jackson / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Edmond O'Brien | ... | Al Preston / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Richard Basehart | ... | David Connelly / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1960) |
 | Mona Freeman | ... | Audrey Trowbridge / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Zsa Zsa Gabor | ... | Erika Segnitz / ... (3 episodes, 1957) |

| Sylvia Sidney | ... | Lulu Morgan / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | William Roerick | ... | Kellogg / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| John Kerr | ... | Capt. Neil Dameron / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Boris Karloff | ... | Guibert / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| Gary Merrill | ... | Louis / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Oskar Homolka | ... | Doctor / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1960) |

| Jack Klugman | ... | Lew Downs / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Richard Haydn | ... | Accountant / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Gladys Cooper | ... | Mrs. Allen / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Luther Adler | ... | Garvin / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Nina Foch | ... | Libby Hanneman / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Pamela Mason | ... | Marcia Lowe / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Joseph Sweeney | ... | Mr. Cherry / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Helen Kleeb | ... | Birdy / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1960) |
 | Arthur Batanides | ... | Van Dyke (3 episodes, 1956-1959) |

| Charles Bronson | ... | Andy Kovaric / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1960) |
 | Jason Wingreen | ... | Blair (3 episodes, 1956-1959) |

| Judith Anderson | ... | Aunt Bee / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Susan Oliver | ... | Ellie / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Mildred Dunnock | ... | Elsie Chiapetta / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Henry Jones | ... | Emmett / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Werner Klemperer | ... | Boris / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Vladimir Sokoloff | ... | Anselmo / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Hope Lange | ... | Alex Winter / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Richard Boone | ... | Col. Pleasants / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1960) |

| Terry Carter | ... | Wesley (3 episodes, 1958-1960) |
 | Larry Gates | ... | Henry Rogers / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1960) |

| James Gregory | ... | Chief Fuller / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1960) |
 | Vivian Nathan | ... | Annette / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1960) |

| Malcolm Atterbury | ... | Jim Hungerford / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Martin Balsam | ... | Captain Mantell / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Maria Schell | ... | Maria / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Milton Selzer | ... | Fernando / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Rip Torn | ... | Harold Rutland Jr. / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Jack Warden | ... | Joe Cushing / ... (3 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Mimi Gibson | ... | Celeste / ... (3 episodes, 1958) |

| Steven Hill | ... | Agustin / ... (3 episodes, 1959-1960) |

| Sam Jaffe | ... | Carpenter / ... (3 episodes, 1959-1960) |
 | Gary Crutcher | ... | Army chef / ... (3 episodes, 1959) |
 | Kenneth Haigh | ... | Gunner / ... (3 episodes, 1959) |
 | Harry Townes | ... | Gabe Brewster / ... (3 episodes, 1959) |
 | Evelyn Rudie | ... | Eloise / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Piper Laurie | ... | Kirsten Arnesen Clay / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Lloyd Bridges | ... | Earl Pfeiffer / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Anne Bancroft | ... | Isobel Waring / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |

| John Drew Barrymore | ... | James Keller / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |

| Viveca Lindfors | ... | Kathleen Moore / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Helmut Dantine | ... | Colonel / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1960) |
 | Larry Blyden | ... | Clarence / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Mark Roberts | ... | Bill / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Edgar Stehli | ... | Doctor / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Reginald Denny | ... | Dean / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Robert Lowery | ... | George Mesta / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Benay Venuta | ... | Marian Hunt / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Paulene Myers | ... | Louise / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Max 'Slapsie Maxie' Rosenbloom | ... | Himself- / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Shepperd Strudwick | ... | Charley Potter / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Jason Johnson | ... | Doctor / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | S. John Launer | ... | Airplane Passenger / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Lyn Osborn | ... | Photographer / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Jeanne Cooper | ... | Receptionist / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Jack Mulhall | ... | Editor / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Robert Preston | ... | Himself - Announcing Next Week's Show / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Kay Thompson | ... | Herself - Announcing Next Week's Show / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Jack Carson | ... | Al Mannix / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Mickey Rooney | ... | Himself - Announcing Next Week's Show / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |

| Laraine Day | ... | Florence Strickland / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1959) |

| Charlton Heston | ... | Charles Gray / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Ralph Bellamy | ... | Eddie Hanneman / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Eddie Cantor | ... | Himself - Announcing Next Week's Show / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Peter Lawford | ... | Himself - Announcing Next Week's Show / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Red Skelton | ... | Buddy McCoy / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Kim Stanley | ... | Mae D'Amato / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Richard Kiley | ... | Bob Lyttleton / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Robert Middleton | ... | Luke Crocker / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Hugh O'Brian | ... | Jason Merrick / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Teresa Wright | ... | Annie Sullivan / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |

| Leslie Nielsen | ... | Eddie Kirkley / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Betsy Palmer | ... | Emmy Verdon / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |

| June Lockhart | ... | Amy Matthewson / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Farley Granger | ... | Brat Farrar / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Barbara Hale | ... | Mrs. Julia Wiley / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Dan O'Herlihy | ... | Dr. Keller / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Janice Rule | ... | Karen Andrews / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Ricardo Montalban | ... | Teddy Green / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Stuart Erwin | ... | George Clay / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | John Ericson | ... | Johnny Hanneman / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Joan Blondell | ... | Helen Green / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| John Ireland | ... | Ben Hammond / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | David Opatoshu | ... | Ellis (2 episodes, 1957) |

| Walter Abel | ... | Mr. Wayde (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Felicia Farr | ... | Anne Murchison / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Tab Hunter | ... | Donald Bashor / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Romney Brent | ... | Professor / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Rene Kroper | ... | Ben / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Addison Richards | ... | Harker (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Charles Korvin | ... | Dr. Von Neff / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Phillip Reed | ... | Francis Wells / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Lee Remick | ... | Cecelia Brady / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Katherine Squire | ... | Katie / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1960) |

| Henry Daniell | ... | Hubbel / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1959) |
 | Onslow Stevens | ... | Gen. Burnside / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1959) |

| Jack Albertson | ... | Al St. George / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | James Dunn | ... | Jackson / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1960) |
 | George Keymas | ... | James Clark / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Thomas Gomez | ... | John Marin / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |

| Billie Burke | ... | Mrs. Purcell / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Marian Seldes | ... | Kate Sullivan / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Stephen Wootton | ... | Castle-Benac / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |

| Jay C. Flippen | ... | Happy Gallant / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Alexander Scourby | ... | Harvey Diedrich (2 episodes, 1959-1960) |

| Fay Spain | ... | Annamay Paul / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Edgar Barrier | ... | Count / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Doro Merande | ... | Miss Hammer / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Frank Puglia | ... | Cardinal / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Wallace Ford | ... | Mule Rogers / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Philip Tonge | ... | Dean Parkington (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Raymond Burr | ... | Charles Bent / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Jack Mullaney | ... | Cuppy Vale / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1959) |
 | Ben Wright | ... | Harold Bond / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Arnold Stang | ... | Allencamp / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Bert Freed | ... | Blick / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |

| Charles Ruggles | ... | Dean Damon / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | David J. Stewart | ... | Ignatiev (2 episodes, 1958-1960) |
 | William Bryant | ... | Calhoun / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Martha Wentworth | ... | Mrs. Cowznoski / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Ned Glass | ... | Bartender / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| William Schallert | ... | Capt. Kingsley - Defense Attorney at Court-Martial (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Harvey Stephens | ... | Dr. Adams (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Buster Keaton | ... | Charles Blackburn / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Paul Lambert | ... | Al Capone / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |

| Inger Stevens | ... | Gail Lucas / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1959) |

| Burt Reynolds | ... | Ace / ... (2 episodes, 1959-1960) |
 | Bartlett Robinson | ... | Capt. Handley / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1959) |

| Dan Blocker | ... | Lewis (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| David Lewis | ... | Lanier (2 episodes, 1956-1959) |
 | Robin Morse | ... | Charles Fischetti (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Howard Price | ... | McKenna (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Karen Sharpe | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Don Murray | ... | Bob Munson / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1960) |

| Barbara Rush | ... | Clara / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1960) |
 | Peter J. Votrian | ... | Billy King / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1960) |
 | John Baragrey | ... | John Parsons Cook / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Red Buttons | ... | Himself / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Lee J. Cobb | ... | Al Bengsten / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Jack Lemmon | ... | David Poole / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Margaret O'Brien | ... | Annie Brookes / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Tony Randall | ... | Gus Taylor / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |

| Robert Vaughn | ... | Earl Randolph / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1959) |
 | Joe De Santis | ... | Dr. Max Bronstein / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Charles Drake | ... | Albert / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Ben Gazzara | ... | M. Paul / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Gale Gordon | ... | Ed Keller / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Darryl Hickman | ... | Herbie / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Earl Holliman | ... | Capt. Volodney / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| DeForest Kelley | ... | Lambert (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Jack Lord | ... | Homer Aswell / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Patricia Neal | ... | Margaret / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Ian Wolfe | ... | Eduard Wingate / ... (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Dan Barton | ... | Cpl. Joe Kelson / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |

| Dana Andrews | ... | Leo Bass / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1960) |

| Don Gordon | ... | Borotta / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1960) |

| Shirley Knight | ... | Betty / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1960) |
 | Fletcher Allen | ... | Orderly (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Tige Andrews | ... | Frank Nitti (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Charles Bail | ... | Cavalry sergeant (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Paul Burke | ... | Farley Mathews / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Robert Cass | ... | O'Meara / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Patricia Cutts | ... | Mavis Greenop / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Paul Douglas | ... | David Ringler / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Buddy Ebsen | ... | Froelich / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Clegg Hoyt | ... | Army Officer / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Henry Hull | ... | Bishop / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Eugene Iglesias | ... | Pancho Rivera (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Sandy Kenyon | ... | Martinson / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Angela Lansbury | ... | Hazel Wills / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Richard LePore | ... | Cotton House Man / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Ken Lynch | ... | Sgt. Reese (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Nancy Marchand | ... | Mrs. Yarbrough / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Inga Swenson | ... | Maria / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | Ann Todd | ... | Lady Diane Goodfellow / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |
 | James Westerfield | ... | Mack Harris / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Michael Wilding | ... | Chris Hughes / ... (2 episodes, 1958-1959) |

| Patricia Barry | ... | Jordan Baker / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Russell Collins | ... | Walter Hinch (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Dennis King | ... | Clyde Winter / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Dayton Lummis | ... | Col. Brecker / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |

| Geraldine Page | ... | Addie / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Ainslie Pryor | ... | Beloit / ... (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Willard Sage | | (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Robert Crawford Jr. | ... | Richard / ... (2 episodes, 1959-1960) |
 | Gina Gillespie | ... | Cathy Patrick / ... (2 episodes, 1959-1960) |
 | Otto Waldis | ... | Kohn (2 episodes, 1959-1960) |

| Eddie Albert | ... | Leroy Dawson / ... (2 episodes, 1959) |
 | Joseph Bernard | ... | Primitivo (2 episodes, 1959) |
 | Peter Capell | | (2 episodes, 1959) |

| Nicholas Colasanto | ... | Eladio (2 episodes, 1959) |

| Hugh Griffith | ... | Jaggers / ... (2 episodes, 1959) |

| Harry Guardino | ... | Lt. Michael Largo / ... (2 episodes, 1959) |

| Clu Gulager | ... | Zach (2 episodes, 1959) |

| Eileen Heckart | ... | Dorothy / ... (2 episodes, 1959) |
 | Oliver McGowan | ... | Gen. Ledlie (2 episodes, 1959) |
 | Liliane Montevecchi | ... | Carla / ... (2 episodes, 1959) |
 | Jay Overholts | ... | Little Bearers / ... (2 episodes, 1959) |

| Sydney Pollack | ... | Andres (2 episodes, 1959) |
 | Cameron Prud'Homme | ... | Capt. Marshak / ... (2 episodes, 1959) |

| Jason Robards | ... | Robert Jordan (2 episodes, 1959) |

| Maximilian Schell | ... | Gunther / ... (2 episodes, 1959) |

| Maureen Stapleton | ... | Pilar (2 episodes, 1959) |
 | Albert Szabo | ... | Rudolph Petersen (2 episodes, 1959) |