 | John Conte | ... | Himself - Host / ... (571 episodes, 1955-1958) |

| Johnny Crawford | ... | Dickie Browning / ... (15 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Sarah Churchill | ... | Charlotte Lovell / ... (13 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| John Hoyt | ... | Harry / ... (9 episodes, 1955-1958) |

| Peggy McCay | ... | Jane Wilson / ... (9 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Patrick Macnee | ... | Don Pedro / ... (8 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Karen Sharpe | ... | Diane (8 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Irene Hervey | ... | Margaret March / ... (7 episodes, 1955-1958) |
 | Marcia Henderson | ... | Lady Ingram / ... (7 episodes, 1955-1958) |

| Angie Dickinson | | (7 episodes, 1955) |
 | Joan Elan | ... | Clara Middleton / ... (6 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Frances Reid | | (6 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| Tom Tryon | ... | Abraham / ... (6 episodes, 1955-1957) |

| John Abbott | ... | Jasper Purdy (6 episodes, 1955-1958) |

| John Carradine | ... | Dracula / ... (6 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Peter Hanson | ... | Fred Purdy / ... (6 episodes, 1955-1957) |

| Margaret O'Brien | ... | Victoria (5 episodes, 1955-1957) |
 | Geoffrey Toone | ... | Daniel / ... (5 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Ann Doran | ... | Bess (5 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Patrick O'Neal | | (5 episodes, 1956) |
 | Dayton Lummis | ... | Cesar Grandet (5 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Judith Evelyn | | (5 episodes, 1955-1958) |

| John Drew Barrymore | ... | Hadrian (5 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Richard Long | | (5 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Betty Lynn | ... | Emmy Chase (5 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Gene Raymond | ... | Conley / ... (5 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Donald Murphy | ... | Jim Tydings (5 episodes, 1955-1957) |
 | Lamont Johnson | ... | Aesop / ... (5 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Peter Hansen | ... | Beaucaire / ... (5 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Helen Westcott | ... | Kay / ... (5 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| Marshall Thompson | ... | Clifford Pyncheon / ... (5 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Robert Karnes | ... | Frank Wilson / ... (5 episodes, 1956) |

| Robert Horton | ... | Benedick / ... (5 episodes, 1955-1958) |
 | Adrienne Marden | ... | Edith Brisk / ... (5 episodes, 1955-1958) |
 | Addison Richards | ... | Frank / ... (5 episodes, 1955-1957) |

| Zsa Zsa Gabor | ... | Eugenia / ... (5 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Roddy McDowall | | (5 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Victor Jory | ... | Edward Hicks / ... (4 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Constance Ford | | (4 episodes, 1956) |
 | Richard Crane | ... | Joe (4 episodes, 1956) |
 | Philip Bourneuf | | (4 episodes, 1955-1958) |

| Catherine McLeod | ... | Helen (4 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Katharine Bard | | (4 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| George Peppard | ... | Jesse Stuart (4 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Val Dufour | ... | Charles (4 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | June Vincent | ... | Matilda (4 episodes, 1956) |
 | Herschel Bernardi | ... | Borachio (4 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Dean Stockwell | | (4 episodes, 1956) |
 | Norma Moore | ... | Hero (4 episodes, 1958) |
 | John Baragrey | | (3 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Lili Darvas | ... | Old Marquis (3 episodes, 1956) |
 | Mike Bradford | ... | Marvin Hudgens (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Richard Jaeckel | | (3 episodes, 1955-1957) |
 | Ann Harding | | (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| Tommy Kirk | ... | John Tucker / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | James Bell | ... | Rancher (3 episodes, 1956) |
 | Douglas Kennedy | | (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Lenore Shanewise | ... | Mary Lincoln (older) (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| Lyle Talbot | | (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Lurene Tuttle | | (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Virginia Vincent | ... | Mim (3 episodes, 1956) |

| Darryl Hickman | ... | Ben de Franco (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Edward Everett Horton | ... | Mr. Pim (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Dick Foran | | (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Peg Hillias | ... | Mrs. Allen (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Mary Scott | ... | Virginia (3 episodes, 1955-1957) |

| Kathleen Freeman | ... | Village Storekeeper (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Claire Luce | ... | Jean Blake (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Eduardo Ciannelli | | (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Eva Gabor | ... | Hester / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Charles Ruggles | ... | Amos Currie (3 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Will Rogers Jr. | | (3 episodes, 1957) |
 | Reba Waters | ... | Young Cathy (3 episodes, 1955-1957) |

| Richard Crenna | | (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Paul Langton | ... | Matt / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Lisa Daniels | ... | Lucy Weston / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Mary Webster | | (3 episodes, 1956) |

| Tom Helmore | ... | Henry Maurier (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Philip Tonge | | (3 episodes, 1955-1957) |
 | Helen Wallace | ... | Hepzibah Pyncheon (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Margaret Hayes | ... | Margaret Tydings / ... (3 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Benny Baker | | (3 episodes, 1956) |
 | Mary LaRoche | ... | Elaine (3 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Myron Healey | | (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Amzie Strickland | ... | Daughter-in-law (3 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Cathy Downs | ... | Charlotte (3 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Kurt Kasznar | | (3 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Pernell Roberts | ... | Don John / ... (3 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Susan Oliver | | (3 episodes, 1958) |
 | Ernest Truex | | (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Mary Astor | | (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Richard Davalos | ... | Johnny (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Cloris Leachman | ... | Claire De Cintre (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Regis Toomey | ... | Phil Gordon (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Ben Cooper | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Ray Montgomery | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Isobel Elsom | ... | Mrs. Fairfax (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Lewis Martin | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Les Tremayne | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Dabbs Greer | | (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Fred Beir | | (2 episodes, 1957) |

| Mary Anderson | | (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Cynthia Baxter | | (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Martin Milner | | (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Joan Sudlow | ... | Sofan Vestal (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Sue Randall | | (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Sylvia Field | | (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | John Eldredge | ... | Frank Ross (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Richard Arlen | ... | Henry 'Red' Sanders (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| Alan Hale Jr. | ... | Duke (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| Anita Louise | | (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Frances Robinson | ... | Alexa (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| Phyllis Avery | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Warren Berlinger | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Will Hutchins | ... | Robert (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Maureen O'Sullivan | ... | Doris (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Gloria Talbott | ... | Barbara Allen (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Lloyd Corrigan | | (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Steven Geray | ... | Willy (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Jacques Sernas | | (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Patricia Barry | ... | Sally Collier (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Edward Binns | | (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Wally Cox | ... | Vernon Chase (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Patty McCormack | ... | Lucy Smith (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Roger Moore | | (2 episodes, 1957) |

| Leif Erickson | | (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Kent Smith | | (2 episodes, 1958) |

| Nita Talbot | | (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Joe De Santis | | (2 episodes, 1955-1957) |
 | Ross Elliott | | (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Gregory Gaye | | (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| Jane Darwell | | (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Alix Talton | ... | Christine Hughes (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Kathleen Crowley | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Susan Kohner | ... | Joanna Marshall (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | John Lupton | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Franklin Pangborn | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Marilyn Erskine | ... | Judith Mann (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Herbert Rudley | ... | Walter Grimm (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Irene Tedrow | | (2 episodes, 1956) |

| William Schallert | ... | Henry (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Olive Sturgess | ... | Priscilla Mullins (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Katherine Warren | ... | Naomi (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Frances Helm | ... | Olivia Dunne (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Alexander Lockwood | ... | Jonathan March (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Jeanette Nolan | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Mae Clarke | | (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Ellen Corby | ... | Louise (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Jack Albertson | ... | Dogberry (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Dennis Patrick | ... | Ward (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Richard Shannon | ... | Ingham (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Lisa Montell | ... | Yasmin (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Conrad Nagel | | (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Carolyn Craig | ... | Cousin (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Michael Winkelman | ... | Jonathan (2 episodes, 1955) |
 | Robert Patten | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Eric Sinclair | ... | Edward Bancroft (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Claire Meade | ... | Mother Sixpence (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Wendy Winkelman | ... | Pamela (2 episodes, 1955) |
 | Joel Marston | ... | Brad / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Ben Welden | ... | Boss (2 episodes, 1955) |
 | Doris Lloyd | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Ludwig Donath | ... | Sigmund Freud (2 episodes, 1955-1957) |
 | James Dunn | | (2 episodes, 1955-1957) |
 | Anthony Eustrel | ... | Dexter (2 episodes, 1955-1957) |
 | Jan Merlin | | (2 episodes, 1955-1957) |

| John Banner | | (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Sally Brophy | ... | Mona (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| Harry Carey Jr. | | (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Kathy Garver | ... | Sally (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Dorothy Green | | (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| DeForest Kelley | ... | Alan Brecker (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |
 | Melinda Plowman | ... | Granddaughter (2 episodes, 1955-1956) |

| Jeanne Cooper | ... | Ruth (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Patricia Cutts | ... | Lady Mary Carlisle (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Ray Danton | ... | Ben (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Joe Maross | | (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |

| Vincent Price | | (2 episodes, 1956-1958) |
 | Virginia Christine | ... | Mother (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Lawrence Dobkin | | (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Cedric Hardwicke | ... | Mr. Krane (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Robert Morse | ... | Frank Wilson / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |

| Marian Seldes | ... | Sarah / ... (2 episodes, 1956-1957) |
 | Judith Braun | ... | Jo March / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Vinton Hayworth | ... | Foxworth / ... (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Diana Lynn | | (2 episodes, 1956) |
 | Fredd Wayne | | (2 episodes, 1956) |

| Andrew Duggan | ... | Clyde (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |
 | Roberta Haynes | ... | Gomer (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Kerwin Mathews | | (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Lois Smith | | (2 episodes, 1957-1958) |

| Morey Amsterdam | | (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Ralph Clanton | ... | Arthur Lee (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Oskar Homolka | ... | Capt. Cornelius Rockney / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Chet Stratton | ... | Griffin / ... (2 episodes, 1957) |
 | Joan Tetzel | ... | Emmie (2 episodes, 1957) |

| Parley Baer | | (2 episodes, 1958) |

| Nina Foch | ... | Beatrice (2 episodes, 1958) |
 | Stephen Joyce | ... | Claudio (2 episodes, 1958) |