IMDb > Fireman Save My Child (1954) > Reviews & Ratings - IMDb

Reviews & Ratings for
Fireman Save My Child More at IMDbPro »

Write review
Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 7 reviews in total 

12 out of 13 people found the following review useful:

A wonderful side-splitter!

Author: sabishi from Denver, Colorado
1 May 2000

I hope someone will make a video of this wonderful old Spike Jones comedy. It was good family fun! I remember when my father watched it he laughed so hard tears were rolling down his cheeks. He said he laughed so hard his stomach hurt! I would love to see it again and hope my daughter can someday see it.

Was the above review useful to you?

7 out of 8 people found the following review useful:

two goofballs (Hugh O'Brian and Buddy Hackett) join a 1910 firefighting company.

6/10
Author: dougbrode from United States
18 March 2006

Here's another of those 'lost' films that somehow fell through the cracks and don't even show up on Turner Classic Movies at three in the morning, when they tend to play obscure so-so pictures for a cult audience that either sets the tape machine or sits up all night long, staring at the tube. Wish they would revive it, though, for it this is anything but subtle, it does contain several well mounted slapstick situations of the type that flourished in the early days of film, before sound came in. Originally, the film was to have starred Bud Abott and Lou Costello. When they dropped out, the studio inserted Hugh O'Brian, who shortly would incarnate the ultra-serous marshal Wyatt Earp on TV, and Buddy Hackett, just then emerging as a world-class funnyman. The decisive move was to rethink this as a (the?) vehicle for Spike Jones and His City Slickers, a madman band that offered more comedy than music. And, as earlier said about this film itself, they weren't subtle but they sure were funny. Another forgotten film waiting to be found.

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Buddy, Save This Movie

Author: gleetroy from United States
21 February 2008

I have never seen this film but have heard a lot about it. Just recently, I was reading an Abbott and Costello biography where it quoted Buddy Hackett as saying that he "replaced" Lou in the film when Lou got ill. (Was it another rheumatic fever attack?) I would like to know the origins of the casting and would like to see this film.

It is easy to see that Hugh O'Brian was essaying the Abbott role. But was he funny at one point?

Spike Jones in a movie that was tailored around him? Just zany enough to be a great idea! When Turner Classic Movies does show it at 3 in the morning I'll have the VCR set

Was the above review useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following review useful:

Fireman Save My Child

7/10
Author: zaphod-74 from United States
15 January 2007

I have to start saying it has been a long time since I have seen it, but have seen it 5 or more times; a wonderful little romp that was clearly inspired by the musical/comedy pairings of new or fading stars with musical groups of prominence. Kay Kyser's mysteries would be a good example.

Having Spike Jones unleashed is the best part of the show, as he and his band play many tunes and are a part of the action, doing a fine job of support. Hugh O'Brien plays the face, Buddy Hackett the part rumor has it that was offered to Lou Costello and thus, Abbott and Costello replacing the leads. Don't know if that was true.

all in all, a pleasant movie, but important to have that much Spike Jones and his band on film for history. Wish that it was released, as I haven't seen or heard of it now in two decades. Hope it is not lost

Was the above review useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following review useful:

Good family comedy

8/10
Author: rmarosy from United States
7 September 2007

I've spent years looking for a copy of this film(16mm,dvd,vhs), so I could show it to my kids. The movie is funny, and Spike and the members of his band show why they were the best musicians in the business. They had to be that good to play that demented. I like it and recommend it for movie lovers of all ages.

The movie is about a turn of the century firehouse, with a crew of misfits that are firemen and the department band (when not fighting the fires). There's the usual running gags, plus the mayhem of Spike Jones and his Orchestra. Also, comedy relief provided by comedian Buddy Hackett and straight-man Hugh O'Brien.

Was the above review useful to you?

Save me from this movie!

3/10
Author: JohnHowardReid
21 June 2016

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

This "Fireman" certain misfires. The script was originally intended to surface as an Abbott and Costello picture, but fortunately for A&C, the studio had second thoughts and decided to use the script as a vehicle for Spike Jones and his City Slickers instead, with Buddy Hackett in the Costello role and Hugh O'Brian as a Bud Abbott substitute. It didn't work! Only the musical numbers were successful. The best of them was a loony rendition of "In a Persian Market" which had the double advantage of being out of copyright and didn't cost Universal a cent. A couple of the other musical numbers could have been moderately successful with audiences too, but they are made less appetizing by long drawn-out "comedy" inserts – especially the "Poet and Peasant Overture". Spike and his boys labor enthusiastically with ad libs as well, but director Leslie Goodwins (who often boasted that he had over two hundred director credits – he did indeed!) manages to make most of their gags fall flat. According to studio publicity, Abbott and Costello can actually be seen in the film, but I've not spotted them myself. According to IMDb, they are present in a "long shot"!

Was the above review useful to you?

One of my all-time favorites; a "must" for Spike Jones fans.

Author: outlaw-6 from Houston, Texas
29 January 2003

Very much a Spike Jones show, although Buddy Hackett was fun to watch, also. The only comparison I can think of (without Spike's music) is Steve Martin's "Roxanne", which was also a comedy about a volunteer Fire Department. Mostly, I very much miss seeing this film on the late-night movie circuit and hope for its return.

Was the above review useful to you?


Add another review


Related Links

Plot summary Ratings Plot keywords
Main details Your user reviews Your vote history